6.1 Three-hinged arches
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain how an arch carries load mainly by compression, and why a three-hinged arch is statically determinate.
- Find the support reactions, the horizontal thrust and the bending moment, normal thrust and radial shear at any section of a three-hinged parabolic or circular arch.
- Show that a parabolic arch under a uniform load over the whole span is funicular (free of bending), and use the crown-hinge condition to handle temperature change and the influence line for the thrust.
Theory
A beam carries vertical load by bending: the top fibres are squeezed, the bottom fibres are stretched, and the depth needed grows quickly with the span. An arch curves upward between two abutments that stop its ends from spreading. The abutments push inward with a horizontal thrust H, and that thrust, acting at the height of the arch rib, produces a moment that opposes the beam moment of the load. With a well-chosen shape, the rib carries almost pure compression, which is why masonry, concrete and steel arches can span much further than beams of the same depth. Sign convention for this chapter: loads act downward; vertical reactions are positive upward; the horizontal thrust H of an arch is positive when the abutment pushes inward on the arch, and cable tension is positive; a bending moment that causes tension on the inner (lower) face of an arch rib is positive (sagging) and the opposite is negative (hogging); x is measured from the left support, the rise y of an arch upward from the springing line and the sag of a cable downward from the chord joining its supports.
A two-dimensional arch with pinned supports at both springings has four reaction components (two vertical, two horizontal) but only three equations of overall equilibrium. A third hinge, usually at the crown, adds one more condition: the bending moment there must be zero. The three-hinged arch is therefore statically determinate, like a simple beam. It is not affected by settlement of the supports or by a change of temperature, because the two halves can rotate about the hinges and the crown simply rises or falls a little without any stress.
For springings at the same level, the vertical reactions are the same as those of a simply supported beam of the same span under the same loads. Taking moments about the crown hinge for the half-arch on either side gives H = M_C,beam/h, where M_C,beam is the beam moment at the crown position and h is the rise. The moment at any section of the arch is then M = M_beam − H y: the beam moment minus the thrust times the height of the rib above the springing line. The thrust reduces the moment everywhere, and where H y equals M_beam exactly the rib carries no bending at all.
The shape for which M = 0 everywhere under a given load is the funicular shape (the shape a hanging cable would take, turned upside down). For a uniform load per horizontal length over the whole span the funicular is a parabola, y = 4h x(L − x)/L², and the thrust is H = wL²/(8h). Under any other load pattern the same parabola carries some bending, smaller than in a beam: half-span loading gives sagging under the loaded half and hogging under the empty half. The resultant force on a section is resolved into a normal thrust N along the rib and a radial shear Q across it, using the slope θ of the rib. The influence line for H is a triangle with its peak L/(4h) at the crown, and the influence line for the moment at a section is the beam moment line minus y times the H line, as in lessons 5.1 and 5.2.
Derivation
- Take a three-hinged arch with springings A and B at the same level, span L, rise h and crown hinge C at x = L/2. Overall moments about B and about A give V_A and V_B, equal to the reactions of a simple beam of span L under the same loads.
- Free body of the left half: the moments about C of V_A, H and the loads on AC must add to zero, so V_A L/2 − (moment about C of the loads on AC) − H h = 0, which is M_C,beam − H h = 0 and H = M_C,beam/h. The horizontal reactions at A and B are equal and opposite when only vertical loads act.
- Section at x with rib height y: the moment of the forces to the left is M = V_A x − (moment of the loads to the left) − H y = M_beam(x) − H y(x).
- Parabolic rib y = 4h x(L − x)/L², with slope tan θ = dy/dx = 4h(L − 2x)/L². Under a uniform load w over the whole span, M_beam = w x(L − x)/2 and H = (wL²/8)/h, so H y = (wL²/(8h)) × 4h x(L − x)/L² = w x(L − x)/2 = M_beam and M = 0 at every section.
- Resolving the forces to the left of the section along and across the rib: normal thrust N = H cos θ + V sin θ (compression positive) and radial shear Q = V cos θ − H sin θ, where V = V_A − (loads to the left) is the beam shear at x.
- Temperature: the chord from a springing to the crown has length c with c² = (L/2)² + h². A uniform rise ΔT lengthens it by c α ΔT; with the springings fixed, 2h dh = 2c dc gives the crown rise dh = c² α ΔT/h, and the thrust becomes M_C,beam/(h + dh) with no temperature stress.
Vertical reactions (level springings): V_A, V_B as for a simple beam of span L (kN)Horizontal thrust: H = M_C,beam/h (kN), with M_C,beam the simple-beam moment at the crown position (kN m) and h the rise (m)Moment at a section: M = M_beam(x) − H y(x) (kN m)Parabolic rib: y = 4h x(L − x)/L²; tan θ = 4h(L − 2x)/L²Full-span uniform load w (kN/m): H = wL²/(8h), M = 0 (funicular); crown point load W: H = WL/(4h)Normal thrust N = H cos θ + V sin θ; radial shear Q = V cos θ − H sin θ (kN)Circular rib of span L and rise h: radius R = (L²/4 + h²)/(2h); y = √(R² − (x − L/2)²) − (R − h)Influence line for H: triangle with peak L/(4h) at the crown
- The arch is a plane curved member with hinges at the two springings and at one point of the rib (usually the crown); the hinges carry no moment.
- Loads are vertical and act in the plane of the arch; springings are at the same level unless stated.
- Linear elastic material and small deflections, so the geometry used in the equilibrium equations is the unloaded shape.
- The arch rib is treated as a line along its centroidal axis; the depth of the rib is small compared with the span and rise.
- Limits: the method gives forces only; buckling of slender ribs in and out of plane, local bending at hangers or spandrel columns, and the flexibility of the abutments are separate checks. Springings at different levels need moments about each support with both H and V in the equations.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- Three-hinged arch analysis is a result of statics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, set the loads, load combinations and member design rules for arch bridges and arched roofs in their own loading, concrete, steel and masonry codes; those values are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A three-hinged parabolic arch has a span of 40 m and a rise of 8 m. A uniform load of 20 kN/m covers the left half only. Find the reactions, the horizontal thrust, the bending moments at the quarter points, and the normal thrust and radial shear at the left quarter point.
- Load 20 × 20 = 400 kN acting 10 m from A: V_A = 400 × 30/40 = 300 kN, V_B = 100 kN.
- Beam moment at the crown from the right: V_B × 20 = 2 000 kN m, so H = 2 000/8 = 250 kN (check from the left: 300 × 20 − 20 × 20²/2 = 2 000 kN m).
- At x = 10 m: y = 4 × 8 × 10 × 30/40² = 6 m; M_beam = 300 × 10 − 20 × 10²/2 = 2 000 kN m; M = 2 000 − 250 × 6 = +500 kN m (sagging).
- At x = 30 m: y = 6 m; M_beam = 100 × 10 = 1 000 kN m; M = 1 000 − 1 500 = −500 kN m (hogging).
- In the left half M = 100x − 5x², greatest at x = 10 m; in the right half the extreme is also at the quarter point, so the extremes are ±wL²/64 = ±500 kN m.
- At x = 10 m: tan θ = 4 × 8 × (40 − 20)/40² = 0.4, θ = 21.80°; beam shear V = 300 − 200 = 100 kN; N = 250 cos θ + 100 sin θ = 232.1 + 37.1 = 269.3 kN; Q = 100 cos θ − 250 sin θ = 92.8 − 92.8 = 0 (the moment is at its peak there).
Answer. V_A = 300 kN, V_B = 100 kN, H = 250 kN; M = +500 kN m at x = 10 m and −500 kN m at x = 30 m; at x = 10 m, N = 269.3 kN and Q = 0
Problem. A three-hinged circular steel arch rib spans 24 m with a rise of 6 m over an industrial hall. A hoist hangs a load of 100 kN from the rib 6 m from the left springing A. Find the thrust, the moment under the load and the resultant force on the left bearing.
- Radius R = (24²/4 + 6²)/(2 × 6) = (144 + 36)/12 = 15 m; centre 9 m below the springing line.
- V_A = 100 × 18/24 = 75 kN, V_B = 25 kN.
- Crown, from the unloaded right half: M_C,beam = 25 × 12 = 300 kN m; H = 300/6 = 50 kN.
- Rib height at x = 6 m: y = √(15² − 6²) − 9 = 13.748 − 9 = 4.748 m.
- M = 75 × 6 − 50 × 4.748 = 450 − 237.4 = 212.6 kN m (sagging).
- Bearing A: resultant √(75² + 50²) = 90.1 kN, at 56.3° to the horizontal; the foundation must take 50 kN of horizontal thrust (or a tie must).
Answer. H = 50 kN; M = 212.6 kN m under the hoist load; 90.1 kN on bearing A at 56.3° to the horizontal
Problem. A three-hinged parabolic steel arch of span 40 m and rise 8 m carries a uniform load of 15 kN/m over the whole span. The temperature rises by 30 °C (α = 12 × 10⁻⁶ per °C). Find the rise of the crown and the change in thrust.
- Before: H = wL²/(8h) = 15 × 40²/(8 × 8) = 375 kN, and the rib carries no bending.
- Half-arch chord: c² = 20² + 8² = 464 m².
- Crown rise: dh = c² α ΔT/h = 464 × 12 × 10⁻⁶ × 30/8 = 0.0209 m, about 21 mm.
- After: H = M_C,beam/(h + dh) = 3 000/8.0209 = 374.0 kN, a drop of about 1 kN (0.26 per cent).
- No temperature moment arises, because the hinges let the two halves rotate freely; only the geometry, and so the thrust, changes slightly.
Answer. Crown rises about 21 mm; H falls from 375 kN to 374.0 kN; no temperature stress
Step-by-step procedure
- Sketch the arch with the three hinges, span L, rise h and the loads; write the equation of the rib (parabola or circle).
- Find V_A and V_B from overall moments (as for a simple beam when the springings are level).
- Take moments about the crown hinge for the half with fewer loads to get H = M_C,beam/h.
- At each section, find y, the beam moment and the beam shear; then M = M_beam − H y.
- Find the slope θ of the rib and resolve into the normal thrust N and the radial shear Q.
- Check: the moment at all three hinges must be zero, and under a full uniform load a parabolic rib must give M = 0 everywhere.
Site notes
- Arch thrust has to go somewhere: into rock or massive abutments in valley bridges, or into a steel tie at springing level in tied arches and arched roofs over halls. Movement of an abutment does not stress a three-hinged arch, but it does lower the crown.
- Hinges are real details: pins or curved bearing plates in steel arches, and narrowed concrete throats or lead-filled joints in older concrete and masonry arches. They must be inspected for seizure and corrosion, because a seized hinge changes the structure from three-hinged to two-hinged or fixed.
- During erection a three-hinged arch is often built as two half-arches cantilevered or propped out from the abutments and joined at the crown hinge, which makes the final forces easy to predict.
- Slender ribs can buckle sideways under their own compression; wind bracing between twin ribs and the deck connection are what hold them in line.
- Half-span live loading, not full loading, usually governs the bending design of the rib.
- Using H = wL²/(8h) for a load that does not cover the whole span; for any other loading H must come from the crown-hinge condition.
- Measuring y from the crown instead of from the springing line.
- Forgetting the sign of H y: the thrust reduces the beam moment, it does not add to it.
- Resolving N and Q with the wrong angle, or using the beam shear without the thrust components.
- Assuming springings at different levels give the same vertical reactions as a simple beam; H then enters the overall moment equations.
For a parabolic three-hinged arch, H for a full uniform load is wL²/(8h) and the rib moment is zero; under a half-span uniform load the largest moments are ±wL²/64 at the quarter points, one eighth of the moment wL²/8 that a beam of the same span would carry under the full load, which shows how much the thrust saves.
Summary
- An arch turns vertical load into compression in the rib plus horizontal thrust at the abutments.
- The third hinge makes the arch statically determinate: H = M_C,beam/h for level springings.
- The moment at any section is M = M_beam − H y; a parabolic rib under a full uniform load is funicular (M = 0).
- The resultant on a section is resolved into a normal thrust N and a radial shear Q using the slope of the rib.
- Temperature change and support movement cause no stress in a three-hinged arch; they only move the crown and change H slightly.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A three-hinged parabolic arch of span 30 m and rise 5 m carries 12 kN/m over the whole span. Find H and the bending moment at the quarter point.
H = 12 × 30²/(8 × 5) = 270 kN; M = 0 at every section, because the parabola is the funicular shape for this load.
2A three-hinged parabolic arch of span 20 m and rise 4 m carries a point load of 200 kN at the crown. Find H and the moment at the quarter points.
V = 100 kN each; H = WL/(4h) = 200 × 20/16 = 250 kN; at x = 5 m, y = 3 m and M = 100 × 5 − 250 × 3 = −250 kN m (hogging).
3Why does a rise in temperature not stress a three-hinged arch?
The two halves rotate about the hinges and the crown rises freely; no restraint means no temperature force, only a small change in H.
4What is the peak ordinate of the influence line for H in a three-hinged arch of span 40 m and rise 8 m, and the greatest H from a single 100 kN moving load?
Peak L/(4h) = 40/32 = 1.25 at the crown; greatest H = 125 kN with the load at the crown.
5For the arch of question 1, find the normal thrust at the springing.
V_A = 180 kN, H = 270 kN; since Q = 0 for a funicular rib, N = √(180² + 270²) = 324.5 kN, along the rib (tan θ = 4h/L = 0.667 = 180/270).
6What is the funicular shape for a single point load at midspan?
Two straight lines meeting under the load (a triangle); a rib of that shape would carry the load in pure compression.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.