Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 2 › Lesson 2.2

2.2 Castigliano's theorems

Structural Analysis Chapter 2: Energy methods Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • State Castigliano's first and second theorems and the theorem of least work, and say when each applies.
  • Find the deflection or rotation at any point of a beam or frame by adding a dummy load or couple and differentiating the strain energy.
  • Find the redundant reaction of a singly indeterminate beam by the theorem of least work.

Theory

Castigliano's theorems turn strain energy into deflections and forces by partial differentiation. The first theorem says that if the strain energy is written in terms of the displacements, the partial derivative of U with respect to the displacement δ_i at a load point gives the load P_i there. The second theorem says that if the complementary energy is written in terms of the loads, its partial derivative with respect to the load P_i gives the displacement δ_i at that load, in its direction. For linear elastic structures U and U* are equal, so the second theorem is used in the everyday form δ_i = ∂U/∂P_i. Sign convention as in lesson 2.1: a positive answer means the point moves in the direction of the load it is paired with.

In practice the deflection is often wanted at a point that has no load, or in a direction where no load acts. The trick is to place an imaginary dummy load Q there, in the direction wanted, write the bending moment including Q, differentiate, and then set Q = 0. For a rotation a dummy couple is used instead. Because the differentiation can be done inside the integral, the working formula is δ = ∫ (M/EI)(∂M/∂Q) dx, evaluated with Q = 0, plus similar axial and shear terms where they matter.

w (kN/m)Qdeflected shapeδ = ∫ (M/EI)(∂M/∂Q) dx, then Q = 0Indiacon original
Figure 2.2: A dummy load Q at the free end of a cantilever: differentiate the strain energy with respect to Q, then set Q to zero to get the tip deflection. Indiacon original, not to scale.

The theorem of least work is the second theorem applied to a redundant force. If a support is rigid, the displacement at that support is zero, so the derivative of the strain energy with respect to its reaction must be zero: ∂U/∂R = 0. Of all the reaction values that satisfy equilibrium, the real one makes the strain energy a minimum. This gives the extra compatibility equation needed for an indeterminate structure, and with several redundants there is one such equation for each.

The method is systematic and works for curved members, frames and mixed axial and bending structures. Its limits come from its assumptions: the supports must be unyielding (if a support settles by Δ, then ∂U/∂R = −Δ or +Δ depending on the direction chosen, not zero), the material must be elastic, and the first theorem in its general form needs the energy expressed in displacements, which is natural in the stiffness method. Temperature and lack of fit must be added as separate displacement terms because they produce movement without stored energy from load.

Derivation

  1. Let a linear elastic structure carry loads P₁ … P_n with deflections δ₁ … δ_n at the load points. By Clapeyron's theorem its stored energy is U = ½ Σ P_j δ_j.
  2. Increase only P_i by a small amount dP_i. The extra energy is dU = (∂U/∂P_i) dP_i.
  3. Now apply the loads in the reverse order: dP_i first (its own small work is of second order), then all P_j, during which dP_i, already in place, moves through the full δ_i and does extra work dP_i δ_i.
  4. The final state is the same, so the stored energy must be the same either way: (∂U/∂P_i) dP_i = dP_i δ_i, which gives Castigliano's second theorem δ_i = ∂U/∂P_i.
  5. For a beam with U = ∫ M²/(2EI) dx, differentiate under the integral: δ_i = ∫ (M/EI)(∂M/∂P_i) dx. With a dummy load Q at the point, ∂M/∂Q is the bending moment caused by a unit load there, and Q is set to zero after differentiating.
  6. Least work: for a redundant reaction R at an unyielding support the displacement is zero, so ∂U/∂R = ∫ (M/EI)(∂M/∂R) dx = 0. For a propped cantilever of span L with uniform load w, M = R x − w x²/2 measured from the prop, and ∫₀^L (R x − w x²/2) x dx = 0 gives R = 3wL/8.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • First theorem: P_i = ∂U/∂δ_i (energy written in displacements)
  • Second theorem (linear): δ_i = ∂U/∂P_i; rotation θ_i = ∂U/∂M_i
  • Beam or frame: δ = ∫ (M/EI)(∂M/∂Q) dx, with Q = 0 afterwards; truss: δ = Σ (N L/EA)(∂N/∂Q)
  • Least work: ∂U/∂R = 0 for each redundant R at an unyielding support
  • Propped cantilever, uniform load: R = 3wL/8, fixed-end moment wL²/8; central point load: R = 5P/16
  • Units: M in kN m, EI in kN m², x in m gives δ in m; multiply by 1000 for mm
Assumptions and limits
  • Linear elastic material and small displacements, so that U = U* and δ_i = ∂U/∂P_i.
  • Loads applied slowly, and supports rigid unless a settlement term is added.
  • Only the energy terms written are included; usually bending for beams and frames and axial force for trusses.
  • Dummy loads are set to zero after differentiation, so they do not change the answer.
  • Limits: temperature, lack of fit and support movement are not captured by load energy and must be added separately; nonlinear behaviour needs the complementary energy form.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Castigliano's theorems and least work are results of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, accept any recognised elastic analysis, including energy methods, for finding deflections and redundant forces; serviceability deflection limits are set in each practice's own codes and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (cantilever by a dummy load and a dummy couple, exam style)

Problem. A cantilever of span 3 m carries a uniform load of 12 kN/m. EI = 3 × 10⁴ kN m². Find the deflection and the slope at the free end by Castigliano's second theorem.

  1. Place a dummy load Q downward at the free end; with x from the free end, M = Q x + w x²/2 (hogging taken positive here, the same sign throughout) and ∂M/∂Q = x.
  2. δ = (1/EI) ∫₀^L (w x²/2)(x) dx with Q = 0, which is wL⁴/(8EI) = 12 × 81/(8 × 3 × 10⁴) = 0.00405 m = 4.05 mm.
  3. For the slope place a dummy couple C at the free end: M = C + w x²/2 and ∂M/∂C = 1.
  4. θ = (1/EI) ∫₀^L w x²/2 dx = wL³/(6EI) = 12 × 27/(6 × 3 × 10⁴) = 0.0018 rad, both positive, so they are in the directions of Q (down) and C (the tip turns down).

Answer. Tip deflection 4.05 mm downward; tip slope 0.0018 rad

Example 2 (propped balcony beam by least work)

Problem. A balcony beam of span 6 m is built into the wall at A and propped at its outer end B by a column. It carries 20 kN/m. Treating the prop as rigid, find the prop reaction, the wall moment and the largest sagging moment.

  1. Take R as the redundant at B and x from B: M = R x − w x²/2 (sagging positive), ∂M/∂R = x.
  2. Least work: ∫₀^6 (R x − 10 x²) x dx = 72R − 3240 = 0, so R = 45 kN, which is 3wL/8.
  3. Wall reaction R_A = 120 − 45 = 75 kN; wall moment M_A = 45 × 6 − 20 × 36/2 = 270 − 360 = −90 kN m, that is 90 kN m hogging (wL²/8).
  4. The shear is zero at x = R/w = 2.25 m from the prop, where M = 45 × 2.25 − 10 × 2.25² = 50.6 kN m sagging (9wL²/128).
  5. If the prop were left out, the wall moment would be wL²/2 = 360 kN m; the prop cuts it to a quarter, but only if it is firm. A prop that settles changes these numbers.

Answer. Prop reaction 45 kN; wall reaction 75 kN; wall moment 90 kN m hogging; largest sagging moment 50.6 kN m at 2.25 m from the prop

Example 3 (sign-gantry bracket, site style)

Problem. A steel bracket for a road sign has a vertical post 4 m high fixed at its base and a horizontal arm 2 m long rigidly joined at the top. A sign weighing 10 kN hangs at the end of the arm. EI = 8000 kN m² for both members. Find the vertical and horizontal movement of the arm tip, using bending energy only.

  1. Arm, with x from the tip: M = P x, ∂M/∂P = x. Post: M = P a = 20 kN m throughout, ∂M/∂P = a = 2 m.
  2. Vertical: δ_v = (1/EI)[∫₀^2 P x² dx + ∫₀^4 P a² dy] = (10/8000)(8/3 + 16) = 0.0233 m = 23.3 mm downward.
  3. Horizontal: add a dummy Q horizontally at the tip, pointing away from the post. It gives no moment in the arm, and in the post at depth y below the top it adds Q y in the same sense as P a, so ∂M/∂Q = y.
  4. δ_h = (1/EI) ∫₀^4 (P a) y dy = P a h²/(2EI) = 10 × 2 × 16/(2 × 8000) = 0.020 m = 20 mm, positive, so away from the post.
  5. The resultant movement is √(23.3² + 20²) = 30.7 mm. The post bending supplies 16 of the 18.7 parts of the vertical movement, so stiffening the post helps far more than stiffening the arm.

Answer. Tip moves 23.3 mm down and 20 mm outward (about 30.7 mm in all)

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Identify the point and direction where a displacement is wanted, or the redundant to be found.
  2. If no real load acts there, add a dummy load Q (for a deflection) or a dummy couple C (for a rotation) in the chosen direction.
  3. Write M (and N where needed) for every member as a function of position, including the dummy load or redundant, with one consistent sign convention.
  4. Find ∂M/∂Q (or ∂M/∂R) for each member; set the dummy load to zero.
  5. Evaluate δ = Σ ∫ (M/EI)(∂M/∂Q) dx, or solve ∂U/∂R = 0 for the redundant; a positive result is in the direction assumed.

Site notes

  • The theorem of least work assumes the prop or support does not move. Temporary props on soft ground, or on a slab below that is itself deflecting, take less load than the analysis shows and leave more moment at the fixed end.
  • Cantilever brackets for signs, lights and canopies often deflect mostly through the post or column, not the arm; check base plates and holding-down bolts, which add rotation not included in the calculation.
  • When back-propping a slab during construction, prop stiffness decides how load is shared; record actual prop positions and any shims removed.
  • Measured deflections larger than predicted usually point to support rotation, joint slip or cracking rather than an error in the energy calculation.
Common mistakes
  • Forgetting to set the dummy load to zero after differentiating.
  • Changing the sign convention for M between members of a frame, which can turn a sum into a difference.
  • Applying least work at a support that settles; the derivative then equals the settlement, not zero.
  • Differentiating with respect to a load that is not independent (for example a reaction already fixed by statics).
  • Losing a factor because EI is in kN m² while lengths are in mm.
Quick check

For a cantilever, the tip deflection from a uniform load is wL⁴/(8EI) and the tip slope wL³/(6EI); their ratio is 3L/4. If your deflection divided by slope is far from three-quarters of the span, check the integration. Valid for prismatic cantilevers under full-length uniform load.

Summary

  • First theorem: P_i = ∂U/∂δ_i; second theorem: δ_i = ∂U/∂P_i for linear structures.
  • A dummy load or couple gives deflections and rotations where no load acts.
  • Working formula: δ = ∫ (M/EI)(∂M/∂Q) dx with Q set to zero.
  • Least work: ∂U/∂R = 0 gives each redundant at an unyielding support.
  • Propped cantilever: 3wL/8 for uniform load, 5P/16 for a central point load.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A simply supported beam of span 6 m carries a central point load of 50 kN; EI = 4 × 10⁴ kN m². Find the midspan deflection by Castigliano's theorem.

M = P x/2 on each half; δ = 2 ∫₀^3 (P x/2)(x/2) dx/EI = PL³/(48EI) = 50 × 216/(48 × 4 × 10⁴) = 5.63 mm.

2Find the free-end slope of a 3 m cantilever carrying 10 kN at the tip; EI = 2 × 10⁴ kN m².

Dummy couple: θ = ∫₀^3 P x dx/EI = PL²/(2EI) = 10 × 9/(4 × 10⁴) = 0.00225 rad.

3A bar of length 2 m, A = 400 mm² and E = 200 000 N/mm² is stretched by 1.5 mm. Use the first theorem to find the force.

U = EAδ²/(2L), so P = ∂U/∂δ = EAδ/L = 200 000 × 400 × 1.5/2000 = 60 000 N = 60 kN.

4A propped cantilever of span L carries a point load P at midspan. Show by least work that the prop reaction is 5P/16, and find it for P = 32 kN.

Compatibility at the prop: R L³/(3EI) = 5PL³/(48EI), the same as ∂U/∂R = 0, so R = 5P/16 = 10 kN.

5A support of a propped beam settles by 8 mm. What replaces ∂U/∂R = 0?

∂U/∂R equals the displacement of the support in the direction of R, here −8 mm if R is taken upward and the support moves down.

6Why can the second theorem in the form δ = ∂U/∂P not be used for a cable structure that stiffens as it deflects?

Its load-deflection curve is nonlinear, so U and U* differ; the deflection is the derivative of the complementary energy U*, not of U.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.