3.1 Method of consistent deformations
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain the force method (method of consistent deformations): release redundants to get a stable determinate primary structure, then restore compatibility.
- Set up and solve compatibility equations Δ_i0 + Σ f_ij X_j = 0, finding the flexibility coefficients by the unit load method of Chapter 2.
- Analyse continuous beams and indeterminate trusses with one or two redundants and check the answers by equilibrium and by Maxwell's symmetry f_ij = f_ji.
Theory
A statically indeterminate structure has more unknown forces than the equations of equilibrium can find. The force method treats the extra forces, the redundants, as the main unknowns. Pick as many redundants as the degree of indeterminacy (lesson 1.2), remove the restraints that carry them, and the structure becomes a determinate primary (released) structure that equilibrium alone can analyse. Sign convention for this chapter: bending moment positive when sagging (tension at the bottom), so support moments in continuous beams come out negative (hogging); reactions and redundants positive upward or in the assumed direction of the released restraint; member forces positive in tension.
The primary structure under the real loads moves at the released points: the deflection Δ_10 at the place of redundant X_1, for example, where the real structure has a support that does not move. The redundant is then applied to the primary structure as a load, producing a movement f_11 X_1, where f_11 is the flexibility coefficient, the movement at point 1 caused by a unit value of X_1. Compatibility says the real structure does not move at the support, so Δ_10 + f_11 X_1 = 0. This one equation gives X_1, and everything else follows by equilibrium and superposition (lesson 1.3).
With several redundants the same idea gives one compatibility equation for each released restraint: Δ_i0 + Σ_j f_ij X_j = 0. The coefficients f_ij form the flexibility matrix, which is symmetric by Maxwell's theorem (lesson 2.5), so only the diagonal and one side need computing. Each coefficient is a deflection of the determinate primary structure and is found by the unit load method: f_ij = ∫ m_i m_j dx/EI for beams and frames, Σ n_i n_j L/(AE) for trusses. Releasing an internal force, such as the force in a truss member or the moment at an interior support, works the same way; the compatibility condition is then that the two sides of the cut fit together.
The choice of redundants is free as long as the primary structure is stable. A two-span beam can be released by removing the middle support (primary: one long simple span) or by putting a hinge over it (primary: two simple spans); both give the same answer, but some choices make the integrals easier. The method is practical by hand for one to three redundants. For larger structures the displacement methods of Chapter 4 and the matrix methods are usually quicker, but the force method remains the clearest way to see where compatibility enters and is the basis for settlement and temperature effects in lesson 3.4.
Derivation
- Find the degree of static indeterminacy n and choose n redundants X_1 … X_n so that removing them leaves a stable, determinate primary structure.
- Analyse the primary structure under the real loads and find the movements Δ_i0 at each released point, in the direction of X_i (unit load method).
- Apply X_i = 1 alone to the primary structure and find the movements f_ji at every released point j; f_ji is the flexibility coefficient.
- Superposition: the total movement at point i is Δ_i0 + Σ_j f_ij X_j.
- Compatibility: in the real structure the released points do not move (or move by a known amount), so Δ_i0 + Σ_j f_ij X_j = 0 for i = 1 … n, a set of n linear equations [f]{X} = −{Δ_0}.
- Solve for the redundants, then find all reactions and internal forces by equilibrium, or by superposition: M = M_0 + Σ m_i X_i. For a two-span beam with equal spans l under w per metre, releasing the middle support gives Δ_10 = −5w(2l)⁴/(384EI) (downward) and f_11 = (2l)³/(48EI), so X_1 = 5w(2l)/8 = 1.25 w l.
Compatibility, one redundant: Δ_10 + f_11 X_1 = 0, so X_1 = −Δ_10/f_11Several redundants: Σ_j f_ij X_j = −Δ_i0, i = 1 … n; [f] symmetric, f_ij = f_jiBeams and frames: Δ_i0 = ∫ M_0 m_i dx/EI, f_ij = ∫ m_i m_j dx/EI (moments in kN m, EI in kN m², x in m)Trusses: Δ_i0 = Σ N_0 n_i L/(AE), f_ij = Σ n_i n_j L/(AE) (kN, mm, mm², kN/mm²)Final forces by superposition: M = M_0 + Σ m_i X_i, N = N_0 + Σ n_i X_iTwo equal spans l, uniform load w: middle reaction 1.25 w l, end reactions 0.375 w l, support moment −w l²/8Three-bar hanger (central bar vertical, outer bars at θ, same A and E): F_centre = P/(1 + 2 cos³θ), F_outer = F_centre cos²θ
- Linear elastic material and small displacements, so superposition holds and the flexibility coefficients are constants.
- The primary structure is stable and determinate; a released structure that is a mechanism cannot be analysed.
- Bending deformation governs beams and frames (shear and axial deformation ignored unless stated); axial deformation governs pin-jointed trusses.
- Supports are unyielding unless a known settlement is included on the right-hand side of the compatibility equation.
- Limits: the hand method becomes lengthy beyond about three redundants; results depend on relative stiffness EI or AE, so cracked or composite sections must use realistic stiffness values.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- The method of consistent deformations is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, analyse indeterminate structures by elastic compatibility methods of this kind, by hand or by computer; load values, load combinations and any permitted redistribution of moments are set in each practice's own codes and are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A continuous floor beam ABC has two equal spans of 6 m, simple supports at A, B and C, constant EI, and carries 20 kN/m over its full length. Find the reactions and the moment over B.
- Degree of indeterminacy: 4 reactions (pin at A, rollers at B and C, here with no horizontal load) against 3 equations, so one redundant. Choose X = R_B (upward); the primary structure is a simple span of 12 m.
- Primary deflection at B (downward): Δ_10 = 5wL⁴/(384EI) = 5 × 20 × 12⁴/(384EI) = 5400/EI.
- Flexibility: a unit upward load at B lifts B by f_11 = L³/(48EI) = 1728/(48EI) = 36/EI.
- Compatibility: −5400/EI + (36/EI) X = 0, so R_B = 150 kN (= 1.25 w l with l = 6 m).
- Equilibrium: R_A = R_C = (240 − 150)/2 = 45 kN. Moment over B: M_B = 45 × 6 − 20 × 6²/2 = 270 − 360 = −90 kN m (hogging), which is w l²/8 with l = 6 m.
Answer. R_B = 150 kN, R_A = R_C = 45 kN, M_B = −90 kN m
Problem. A pipe-rack load of 100 kN hangs from a joint carried by three steel rods: a vertical rod 3 m long and two rods each inclined at 30° to the vertical, anchored to the same overhead beam. All rods have A = 500 mm² and E = 200 kN/mm². Find the rod forces and the drop of the joint.
- One redundant: three rods meet at a joint with two equilibrium equations. Take X = tension in the vertical rod; the primary structure is the two inclined rods alone.
- Primary structure under P − X: each inclined rod carries (P − X)/(2 cos 30°), length 3/cos 30° = 3.464 m, and the joint drops (P − X) L/(2AE cos³30°).
- Compatibility: the drop of the joint equals the stretch of the vertical rod, X L/(AE). So X = (P − X)/(2 cos³30°), giving X = P/(1 + 2 cos³30°) = 100/(1 + 1.299) = 43.50 kN.
- Inclined rods: F = X cos²30° = 43.50 × 0.75 = 32.62 kN each. Check: 43.50 + 2 × 32.62 × cos 30° = 43.50 + 56.50 = 100 kN.
- Drop of the joint: X L/(AE) = 43.50 × 3000/(500 × 200) = 1.31 mm. The stiffer, shorter vertical rod takes the largest share.
Answer. Vertical rod 43.50 kN, inclined rods 32.62 kN each, drop 1.31 mm
Problem. A beam ABCD has three equal spans of 5 m on simple supports and carries 12 kN/m throughout; EI constant. Using the reactions at B and C as redundants, find all reactions and the moments over B and C.
- Primary structure: a simple span AD of 15 m. Points B and C are at 5 m and 10 m.
- Primary deflections from the load, w x(L³ − 2Lx² + x³)/(24EI) at x = 5 m: Δ_10 = Δ_20 = 12 × 5 × (3375 − 750 + 125)/(24EI) = 6875/EI (downward).
- Flexibility coefficients from the simple-span formula: f_11 = f_22 = a²b²/(3EIL) = 25 × 100/(45EI) = 55.56/EI; f_12 = f_21 = P b x(L² − b² − x²)/(6EIL) with b = 5, x = 5: 25 × 175/(90EI) = 48.61/EI (symmetric, as Maxwell requires).
- Compatibility: 55.56 X_1 + 48.61 X_2 = 6875 and 48.61 X_1 + 55.56 X_2 = 6875. By symmetry X_1 = X_2 = 6875/104.17 = 66.0 kN (= 1.1 w l).
- Ends: R_A = R_D = (180 − 132)/2 = 24 kN (= 0.4 w l). M_B = M_C = 24 × 5 − 12 × 5²/2 = −30 kN m (= −0.1 w l²).
Answer. R_A = R_D = 24 kN, R_B = R_C = 66 kN, M_B = M_C = −30 kN m
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the degree of indeterminacy and choose redundants that leave a stable primary structure with easy moment diagrams.
- Draw the M_0 (or N_0) diagram of the primary structure under the real loads and the m_i (or n_i) diagrams for each unit redundant.
- Compute Δ_i0 and f_ij by the unit load method or standard deflection formulas; use f_ij = f_ji.
- Write and solve the compatibility equations [f]{X} = −{Δ_0}, with any known support movement on the right-hand side.
- Find the remaining reactions and the final diagrams by equilibrium or M = M_0 + Σ m_i X_i; check that all supports satisfy equilibrium and the signs make physical sense.
Site notes
- The middle support of a two-span beam carries 1.25 w l, much more than the w l a simple-span tributary estimate gives; props and bearings at interior supports are sized for this.
- Removing an interior prop or support during construction or alteration turns a continuous beam into a long simple span with far larger sagging moment; never remove one without checking.
- The share of load each member takes depends on stiffness: in a hanger group, the shortest and stiffest rod takes the most. A new, stiffer member added beside an old one attracts load away from it.
- When a computer model gives reactions that do not add up to the applied load, or a flexibility check is not symmetric, look for a modelling error before using the results.
- Choosing redundants that leave a mechanism (for example removing two horizontal restraints of a frame).
- Mixing sign conventions between Δ_i0 and f_ij; both must be measured in the assumed direction of X_i.
- Forgetting that compatibility for an internal release is the relative movement of the two cut faces, not the movement of one face.
- Using unequal EI values without including them in the integrals; the redundants depend on relative stiffness.
- Not checking the final answer by overall equilibrium.
For a two-span continuous beam with equal spans under a full uniform load, the middle support takes 5/8 of the total load (1.25 w l) and each end takes 3/16 (0.375 w l); the hogging moment over the middle support equals the simple-span midspan moment w l²/8 of one span. Valid for equal spans, constant EI and unyielding supports.
Summary
- Force method: release redundants, analyse the determinate primary structure, restore compatibility.
- One equation per redundant: Δ_i0 + Σ f_ij X_j = 0.
- Flexibility coefficients come from the unit load method and form a symmetric matrix.
- Final forces by superposition M = M_0 + Σ m_i X_i, then check equilibrium.
- Results depend on relative stiffness, so stiffer parts attract more force.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A continuous beam has two equal spans of 5 m and carries 16 kN/m throughout. Find the three reactions and the moment over the middle support.
R_B = 1.25 × 16 × 5 = 100 kN; R_A = R_C = (160 − 100)/2 = 30 kN; M_B = −16 × 25/8 = −50 kN m.
2A beam is indeterminate to the second degree. How many compatibility equations are needed, and how many different flexibility coefficients must be computed?
Two equations; the 2 × 2 flexibility matrix has four terms but f_12 = f_21, so only three different coefficients (f_11, f_22, f_12) are needed.
3Repeat Example 2 with the outer rods at 45° to the vertical and a load of 60 kN.
F_centre = 60/(1 + 2 × 0.3536) = 35.15 kN; F_outer = 35.15 × 0.5 = 17.57 kN each. Check: 35.15 + 2 × 17.57 × 0.7071 = 60 kN.
4A two-span beam ABC has spans of 4 m each and a single 40 kN load at the middle of span AB. Using R_B as the redundant, find R_B.
Primary span 8 m: deflection at B from the load at 2 m = 40 × 2 × 4 × (64 − 4 − 16)/(48EI) = 293.3/EI; f_11 = 512/(48EI) = 10.67/EI; R_B = 293.3/10.67 = 27.5 kN (= 11P/16).
5Why must the primary structure be stable?
Because the method analyses it under the loads and under each unit redundant by equilibrium alone; a mechanism has no unique equilibrium solution and its deflections are not defined.
6In Example 3, compute f_21 directly (deflection at B from a unit load at C) and confirm it equals f_12.
Unit load at C (a = 10 m from A, b = 5 m from D); point B at x = 5 m lies to the left of the load, so δ = b x (L² − b² − x²)/(6EIL) = 1 × 5 × 5 × (225 − 25 − 25)/(6 × 15 EI) = 48.61/EI, equal to f_12.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.