Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 1 › Lesson 1.4

1.4 Stability and determinacy checks

Structural Analysis Chapter 1: Fundamentals of structural analysis Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Distinguish statically determinate, indeterminate and unstable structures, and explain why a non-negative count is necessary but not sufficient for stability.
  • Recognise external geometric instability (parallel or concurrent reactions) and internal instability (mechanisms, missing triangulation, collinear hinges) in beams, trusses, frames and arches.
  • Check stability formally with the rank or determinant of the equilibrium equations, and judge when a support arrangement is close to unstable.

Theory

A structure is stable when it can carry any small set of loads in equilibrium with only small deformations of its members. It is unstable when some load makes part or all of it move as a mechanism, with no member resisting. Counting gives the first check. If the degree of indeterminacy D_s (lesson 1.2, including releases) is negative, there are fewer unknown forces than equilibrium equations and the structure is certainly unstable. If D_s is zero or positive the structure may be determinate, indeterminate or still unstable, because the unknowns may be badly arranged. Sign convention as in lesson 1.1: forces up and to the right positive, anticlockwise moments positive, tension positive.

External stability needs at least three reaction components for a plane body, and these must not all be parallel and must not all pass through one point. Three parallel rollers cannot resist a horizontal load. Three reactions whose lines meet at one point cannot resist a moment about that point. Such an arrangement is geometrically unstable even though r = 3. A support system that is nearly concurrent or nearly parallel is stable in theory but gives very large reactions and large movements: it is badly conditioned and should be avoided.

parallel:unstableconcurrent at pin:unstablepin + roller:stableIndiacon original
Figure 1.4: Geometric stability of supports: three parallel reactions or reactions concurrent at one point give an unstable beam; a pin and a roller give a stable one. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Internal stability is about the arrangement of members and releases. A truss built by starting from a triangle and adding each new joint with two non-collinear members is a simple truss and is internally stable. A panel without a diagonal is a mechanism that racks into a parallelogram. A truss can have the right total number of members and still be unstable if one panel has two diagonals and the next has none. In beams and frames each internal hinge removes one moment restraint; enough hinges, or hinges in the wrong places, form a mechanism. Three hinges in a straight line, such as a three-hinged arch flattened until its crown hinge lies on the line of the support hinges, are a classic critical form: the structure must deflect a lot before it can carry load.

The formal test uses the equilibrium equations written as A x = p, where x lists the unknown reactions and member forces, p the loads, and A is the equilibrium (statics) matrix. The structure is stable when the rank of A equals the number of equations, so that every load p can be balanced. It is statically determinate when A is square and non-singular, and indeterminate by (number of unknowns − rank) when stable. If the rank is less than the number of equations, some load cannot be balanced and the structure is unstable, whatever the count. A determinant that is non-zero but small warns of a nearly unstable arrangement.

Derivation

  1. Write one equilibrium equation for each independent direction of each free body: ΣF_x = 0, ΣF_y = 0, ΣM = 0 for each rigid part (three per part), or ΣF_x = 0, ΣF_y = 0 at each truss joint (two per joint).
  2. Collect them as A x = p: n_e equations in n_u unknown forces; the counting rule D_s = n_u − n_e is the difference of the matrix dimensions.
  3. If n_u < n_e (D_s < 0), the columns of A cannot span every load vector, so some p has no solution: the structure is unstable.
  4. If n_u ≥ n_e, the structure is stable only if rank(A) = n_e; a rank deficiency means that a combination of equations has no unknown in it (for example a moment equation about the point where all reaction lines meet), so the structure is geometrically unstable.
  5. Single rigid beam AB of length L with a pin at B (B_x, B_y) and a link at A inclined at angle θ to the beam axis (force F): the three equations give det A = −L sin θ, so the beam is stable for θ ≠ 0 and unstable when the link line passes through B (θ = 0, all three reactions concurrent at B).
  6. For a central load P the moment equation about B gives F L sin θ = P L/2, so F = P/(2 sin θ), which grows without limit as θ → 0: the force rises sharply long before exact concurrency.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Counting: D_s < 0 unstable; D_s ≥ 0 necessary but not sufficient (beam D_s = r − 3 − c, truss m + r − 2j, frame 3m + r − 3j − c)
  • External: r ≥ 3, reactions not all parallel and not all concurrent
  • Equilibrium matrix A x = p: stable if rank(A) = n_e; determinate if A square and det A ≠ 0; degree = n_u − rank(A) when stable
  • Beam with pin at B and link at A at angle θ: det A = −L sin θ; F = P/(2 sin θ) for a central load P
  • Units: forces in kN, lengths in m, angles in degrees
Assumptions and limits
  • Plane structures with rigid members between joints; small displacements (the check is made on the undeformed geometry).
  • Supports and joints behave as idealised (lesson 1.1): a link or roller acts only along its line, a hinge transmits no moment.
  • The rank test detects instability of the model; it does not check member strength or buckling.
  • Counts include every release: hinges, rollers inside the structure and sliding connections.
  • Limits: a structure that is stable only because of very stiff or nearly parallel or concurrent restraints, or because of geometric stiffening after large deflection (as with collinear hinges), should be treated as unsuitable even if the rank test is passed.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Stability and determinacy are checked from statics and geometry; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, all require a complete and stable load path from every load to the foundations, including during construction stages and after the loss of a member where robustness is required; the specific requirements are set in each practice's own codes and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (classify three beams)

Problem. Classify: (a) a beam on a pin at A and a roller at B with an internal hinge at midspan; (b) a beam fixed at A, with an internal hinge at C and a roller at the far end B (a cantilever-and-suspended-span arrangement); (c) a long beam resting on three vertical rollers.

  1. (a) r = 3, c = 1: D_s = 3 − 3 − 1 = −1 < 0, unstable; the two halves fold down at the hinge as a mechanism.
  2. (b) r = 3 + 1 = 4, c = 1: D_s = 4 − 3 − 1 = 0. Part CB rests on the hinge and the roller, and part AC is a cantilever; each part is in equilibrium, so it is stable and determinate.
  3. (c) r = 3: D_s = 0 by count, but all three reactions are vertical (parallel), so there is nothing to resist a horizontal force: geometrically unstable.
  4. Counting decided case (a); cases (b) and (c) have the same count and only the arrangement separates them.

Answer. (a) unstable, D_s = −1; (b) stable and determinate; (c) unstable although D_s = 0

Example 2 (truss panels: count and arrangement)

Problem. (a) A square panel of four pin-jointed members on a pin and a roller. (b) The same panel with one diagonal. (c) A two-panel truss with 6 joints (3 bottom, 3 top), 2 top-chord and 2 bottom-chord members, 3 verticals and 2 diagonals, on a pin and a roller: compare the two diagonals placed one in each panel with both placed crossing in the first panel.

  1. (a) m = 4, j = 4, r = 3: D_s = 4 + 3 − 8 = −1, unstable; the panel racks into a parallelogram.
  2. (b) m = 5: D_s = 5 + 3 − 8 = 0, stable and determinate (two triangles).
  3. (c) m = 9, j = 6, r = 3: D_s = 9 + 3 − 12 = 0 for both arrangements.
  4. One diagonal in each panel: the 12 × 12 equilibrium matrix has rank 12, so the truss is stable and determinate.
  5. Both diagonals in the first panel: the rank falls to 11. The second panel can rack (unstable) while the first panel has one redundant. The count alone could not show this.

Answer. (a) unstable; (b) determinate; (c) one diagonal per panel stable and determinate, both in one panel unstable (rank 11 of 12)

Example 3 (a bearing arrangement close to instability)

Problem. A 6 m beam AB carries a central load of 60 kN. It is pinned at B and held at A by an inclined link (strut) whose line makes an angle θ with the beam axis. Find the link force and the reactions at B for θ = 30°, find the link force for θ = 5°, and explain what happens at θ = 0.

  1. Moment about B: F sin θ × 6 = 60 × 3, so F sin θ = 30 kN.
  2. θ = 30°: F = 30/0.5 = 60 kN; its components are F cos θ = 51.96 kN along the beam and 30 kN upward. Then B_x = −51.96 kN (towards A) and B_y = 60 − 30 = 30 kN.
  3. θ = 5°: F = 30/sin 5° = 344.2 kN, with an axial thrust of 342.9 kN in the beam, for the same 60 kN load.
  4. θ = 0: the link line passes through B, all three reactions meet at B and det A = −6 sin θ = 0; no reaction can resist rotation about B, so the beam is unstable.
  5. Keep reaction lines well away from concurrency; a small angle gives a stable model but huge forces and large movements.

Answer. θ = 30°: F = 60 kN, B_x = −51.96 kN, B_y = 30 kN; θ = 5°: F = 344.2 kN; θ = 0: unstable

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Count unknowns and equations (D_s with all releases). If D_s < 0, the structure is unstable: stop and add restraint.
  2. Check external stability: at least three reactions, not all parallel, not all concurrent.
  3. Check internal arrangement: triangulation of trusses, positions of hinges in beams and frames, collinear hinges.
  4. When in doubt, write the equilibrium matrix and find its rank (by hand for small cases or by computer); compare with the number of equations.
  5. Look at conditioning: very large reactions under modest loads mean the arrangement is close to unstable; change it.

Site notes

  • Temporary stages are the most common source of instability: a truss or frame erected before its bracing, or a beam on temporary rollers, can be a mechanism; follow the erection sequence and install bracing as specified.
  • Removing a diagonal or a bracing member during repairs or alterations can turn a stable truss or frame into a mechanism; get the change checked first.
  • Bearings that are supposed to be pinned but have been left free (or the reverse) change the reaction lines; inspect them against the drawings.
  • Ensure that every hinge shown on the drawing is matched by enough restraint elsewhere; a hinge added on site to ease fitting can make a structure unstable.
Common mistakes
  • Taking D_s = 0 or D_s > 0 as proof of stability.
  • Ignoring the direction of reactions, so that three parallel or concurrent reactions are counted as enough.
  • Forgetting internal hinges or sliding joints in the count.
  • Counting the members of a truss correctly but placing the diagonals so that one panel has none.
  • Accepting a support arrangement that is nearly concurrent because the model solves, without noticing the very large reactions.
Quick check

If all reaction lines are parallel or meet at one point, the structure is unstable whatever the count. Near those limits forces blow up: in Example 3 the link force rises from 60 kN at 30° to 344 kN at 5° (F = P/(2 sin θ)). Valid for plane structures checked on the undeformed geometry.

Summary

  • D_s < 0 means unstable; D_s ≥ 0 is necessary but not sufficient.
  • External instability: reactions all parallel or all concurrent.
  • Internal instability: untriangulated panels, misplaced or too many hinges, collinear hinges.
  • Formal test: rank of the equilibrium matrix equals the number of equations.
  • Avoid nearly unstable arrangements: they give huge reactions and movements.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A beam on a pin and a roller has two internal hinges. Classify it.

D_s = 3 − 3 − 2 = −2: unstable.

2Why is a three-hinged arch with its three hinges in a straight line unsuitable even though the count gives D_s = 0?

The reactions at the hinges act along the line of the hinges and cannot resist a load across it until the arch has deflected significantly; the arrangement is geometrically unstable (a critical form).

3A plane truss has 7 joints and 11 members on a pin and a roller. What does the count say, and what else must be checked?

D_s = 11 + 3 − 14 = 0. It may be determinate, but the arrangement (triangulation, no panel without a diagonal) must be checked.

4A pinned-base portal frame has a hinge at the top of one column and another at midspan of the beam. Classify it.

m = 4, j = 5, r = 4, c = 2: D_s = 12 + 4 − 15 − 2 = −1: unstable.

5In Example 3, find the link force if θ = 10°.

F = 30/sin 10° = 172.8 kN.

6Explain in one or two sentences why a positive degree of indeterminacy does not guarantee stability.

The count compares numbers only; the equations can still be dependent, as when reactions are concurrent or a panel lacks a diagonal, so some load cannot be balanced even though extra unknowns exist elsewhere.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.