5.2 Müller-Breslau principle
After this lesson you should be able to:
- State the Müller-Breslau principle and prove it from virtual work (Betti's theorem).
- Sketch influence lines for reactions, shear and moment by releasing the corresponding restraint and imposing a unit displacement, for determinate and indeterminate beams.
- Use qualitative influence lines to choose the spans to load for the worst moments in continuous beams, and obtain a quantitative line for a propped cantilever from its deflected shape.
Theory
Writing equations for every influence line is slow. In 1886 Heinrich Müller-Breslau showed that the shape of an influence line can be drawn directly as a deflected shape. The principle states: the influence line for a force quantity (a reaction, shear or moment) is the deflected shape of the structure when the restraint that carries that quantity is removed and a unit displacement in the direction of the quantity is imposed at the release. Sign convention for this chapter: the moving unit load acts downward; reactions are positive upward; the shear at a section is positive when the resultant of the forces on the part to its left acts upward; a sagging bending moment is positive and a hogging one negative; truss member forces are positive in tension; x is measured from the left support.
For a reaction, remove the support and push the point up by one unit; the beam pivots about the other supports. For the moment at a section, insert a hinge there and impose a unit relative rotation between the two sides. For the shear at a section, insert a slider that allows relative sliding but keeps the two sides parallel, and impose a unit relative vertical separation; because the sides stay parallel, the two branches of a shear influence line are always parallel, which is why the simply supported shear line has slopes −1/L on both sides.
In a statically determinate structure the release turns it into a mechanism, so the displaced shape is made of rigid straight pieces and the influence line is straight, as found by statics in lesson 5.1. In an indeterminate structure the release leaves a structure that must bend, so the influence line is curved. Its exact ordinates need a deflection calculation, but its shape, and in particular where it is positive and negative, can be sketched at once.
That qualitative sketch is the main practical use of the principle. For a continuous beam, the line for the sagging moment in a span bulges up in that span and alternates in sign in the spans beyond, so the live load is placed on alternate spans. The line for the hogging moment over a support is negative in both spans next to that support and alternates beyond, so the live load goes on the two adjacent spans and then on alternate spans. This is the origin of the pattern loading used in building and bridge design.
Derivation
- Let the quantity be the reaction R at support B. Remove the support and apply R as an external force; the structure is in equilibrium under the unit load at x and R.
- State 1: the real loads (the unit load at x and the force R at B). State 2: the released structure with a displacement imposed at B, giving a deflected shape δ(x), with δ_B = 1 at B.
- Virtual work (Betti): the work of the forces of state 1 through the displacements of state 2 equals that of the forces of state 2 through the displacements of state 1. State 2 has force only at B, where state 1 has zero displacement, so the right side is zero.
- Hence R × δ_B − 1 × δ(x) = 0 (the unit load acts downward and δ is taken positive upward), so R = δ(x)/δ_B = δ(x) when δ_B = 1.
- The same argument with a hinge and a unit relative rotation gives the moment, and with a slider and a unit relative separation gives the shear.
- For a propped cantilever (fixed at A, prop at B, span L): remove the prop; a unit upward force at B gives deflection x²(3L − x)/(6EI), with L³/(3EI) at B. Scaling to 1 at B gives the influence line R_B(x) = x²(3L − x)/(2L³).
Principle: influence line of a quantity = deflected shape after releasing it and imposing a unit displacement (dimensionless or m, by quantity)Proof: R × 1 − 1 × δ(x) = 0, so R = δ(x)Shear release: two branches parallel, separated by 1 at the sectionMoment release: hinge with unit relative rotation; ordinate at the section = ab/L for a simply supported beamPropped cantilever (A fixed, B propped): R_B(x) = x²(3L − x)/(2L³); R_B = 5/16 at midspanUniform load check: w ∫ R_B dx = 3wL/8
- Linear elastic behaviour and small displacements, so Betti's theorem and superposition hold.
- The unit displacement at the release is small; the drawing is magnified for clarity.
- Only the restraint for the quantity studied is released; every other support and connection is kept.
- Loads are vertical and act on the beam axis.
- Limits: for indeterminate structures the sketch gives shape and signs; numerical ordinates need a deflection calculation (or a matrix analysis), as in the propped-cantilever example.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- The Müller-Breslau principle is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, require live load on continuous beams and bridges to be arranged for the worst effect at each section, which is what the qualitative influence lines of this lesson show; the load values and arrangement rules in each practice's own codes are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A simply supported beam of span 10 m carries a dead load of 8 kN/m over the whole span and a single moving load of 40 kN. Use the Müller-Breslau principle to draw the influence line for the shear at section C, 3 m from A, and find the greatest and least shear at C.
- Release: cut the shear capacity at C with a slider and separate the two sides by 1 unit, keeping them parallel. The left part pivots about A and the right part about B.
- Both branches have the same slope, −1/10 per m; the left branch reaches −3/10 = −0.3 at C and the right branch +7/10 = +0.7 at C (jump 1).
- Dead load: area = ½ × 7 × 0.7 − ½ × 3 × 0.3 = 2.45 − 0.45 = 2.0 m; V = 8 × 2.0 = 16 kN.
- Moving load: just right of C gives 40 × 0.7 = 28 kN; just left of C gives 40 × (−0.3) = −12 kN.
- Greatest shear 16 + 28 = 44 kN; least shear 16 − 12 = 4 kN. Statics check of the dead-load value: R_A = 40 kN, V_C = 40 − 8 × 3 = 16 kN.
Answer. V_C from 4 kN to 44 kN
Problem. A beam AB of span 6 m is fixed at A and propped at B. Obtain the influence line for the prop reaction R_B, find its ordinates at 2, 3 and 4 m from A, and find R_B and M_A for a 100 kN load at 4 m from A. Check the line with a uniform load of 20 kN/m.
- Remove the prop and lift B by one unit: the deflected shape is the cantilever curve scaled to 1 at B, R_B(x) = x²(3L − x)/(2L³) with L = 6 m (2L³ = 432 m³).
- Ordinates: x = 2: 4 × 16/432 = 0.148; x = 3: 9 × 15/432 = 0.3125 (= 5/16); x = 4: 16 × 14/432 = 0.519.
- Load 100 kN at 4 m: R_B = 51.85 kN; M_A = 51.85 × 6 − 100 × 4 = −88.9 kN m (hogging).
- Uniform load: R_B = w ∫₀ᴸ x²(3L − x)/(2L³) dx = 3wL/8 = 3 × 20 × 6/8 = 45 kN, the known propped-cantilever result.
- The line is curved (cubic), as expected for an indeterminate beam.
Answer. R_B = 51.85 kN, M_A = −88.9 kN m; uniform load check 45 kN
Problem. A three-span continuous beam ABCD has equal spans of 5 m, EI constant and simple supports. It carries a dead load of 10 kN/m on all spans and a live load of 15 kN/m that may occupy any spans. Use qualitative influence lines to choose the loaded spans for the greatest hogging moment at B and the greatest sagging moment in span AB, and compare with all spans loaded.
- Moment at B: release with a hinge at B and a unit relative rotation; the shape dips in AB and BC and rises in CD. So load live on AB and BC.
- Sagging in AB: hinge in span AB; the shape rises in AB, falls in BC and rises in CD. So load live on AB and CD.
- Three-moment equations with live on AB and BC (25 kN/m) and dead only on CD (10 kN/m): 20M_B + 5M_C = −(25 + 25) × 125/4 and 5M_B + 20M_C = −(25 + 10) × 125/4, giving M_B = −68.75 kN m and M_C = −37.5 kN m.
- Live on AB and CD: by symmetry M_B = M_C = −43.75 kN m; span AB reaction R_A = 25 × 2.5 − 43.75/5 = 53.75 kN, greatest sagging 53.75²/(2 × 25) = 57.78 kN m.
- With all spans loaded (25 kN/m): M_B = −0.1 × 25 × 25 = −62.5 kN m and the span AB sagging moment is 50.0 kN m. Pattern loading raises the support moment by 10 per cent and the span moment by 15.6 per cent.
Answer. M_B = −68.75 kN m (AB and BC loaded); span AB sagging 57.78 kN m (AB and CD loaded)
Step-by-step procedure
- Name the quantity and remove the restraint that carries it (support, moment capacity or shear capacity).
- Impose a unit displacement in the positive sense of the quantity at the release, keeping all other restraints.
- Sketch the deflected shape: straight pieces for determinate structures, smooth curves for indeterminate ones.
- Read the signs to decide where live load should go; for numbers, scale known deflection formulas or use statics for determinate cases.
- Check one ordinate by a direct calculation, such as the 5/16 midspan ordinate of a propped cantilever.
Site notes
- Pattern loading of floors (alternate bays for span moments, adjacent bays for support moments) follows directly from the qualitative lines; design software runs the same patterns automatically.
- Engineers testing a scaled model of a structure have used the principle directly: displacing one support of the model and measuring the deflected shape gives the influence line.
- For continuous bridge decks, the hogging region over the piers is governed by vehicles placed on both adjacent spans, which is why continuity steel or prestress is concentrated over the piers.
- When a support is added under an existing beam during strengthening work, the sketch shows at once which spans will see reversed moments.
- Imposing the unit displacement against the positive sense of the quantity, which flips the sign of the whole line.
- Letting the two sides of a shear release rotate relative to each other; they must stay parallel.
- Releasing more than one restraint at a time.
- Drawing straight lines for an indeterminate beam; its influence lines are curved.
- Loading every span to find the worst support moment; pattern loading usually governs.
For a propped cantilever, the ordinate of the prop-reaction influence line at midspan is 5/16, the same fraction that a central point load sends to the prop; Maxwell's reciprocal theorem guarantees this match.
Summary
- Müller-Breslau: release the quantity, impose a unit displacement, and the deflected shape is the influence line.
- Proof by virtual work: R × 1 = 1 × δ(x).
- Determinate structures give straight lines; indeterminate ones give curves.
- Shear releases keep parallel branches; moment releases give a kink with unit relative rotation.
- Qualitative lines decide pattern loading for continuous beams and decks.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1State the Müller-Breslau principle for the reaction at a support.
Remove the support and push it up by one unit in the direction of the reaction; the resulting deflected shape of the beam is the influence line of that reaction.
2A propped cantilever has a span of 8 m. Find the ordinate of the prop-reaction influence line at midspan and the prop force under a 40 kN load there.
Ordinate 5/16 = 0.3125 for any span; prop force 40 × 0.3125 = 12.5 kN.
3For the propped cantilever of Example 2 (6 m), find the prop-reaction ordinate 4.5 m from the fixed end.
x²(3L − x)/(2L³) = 20.25 × 13.5/432 = 0.633.
4A four-span continuous beam ABCDE carries live load. Which spans should be loaded for the greatest hogging moment at B?
Spans AB and BC (both next to B) and then alternate spans beyond, so DE as well; CD is left unloaded.
5A five-span beam has spans AB, BC, CD, DE and EF. Which spans should carry live load for the greatest sagging moment in span BC?
BC and DE (alternate spans), with AB, CD and EF unloaded.
6For the beam of Example 3, find the greatest sagging moment in the middle span BC, and say which spans carry the live load.
Live load on BC only (10 kN/m dead on AB and CD): M_B = M_C = −43.75 kN m and the midspan moment is 25 × 25/8 − 43.75 = 34.38 kN m, against 15.63 kN m with every span loaded.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.