Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 2 › Lesson 2.1

2.1 Strain energy and complementary energy

Structural Analysis Chapter 2: Energy methods Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Explain strain energy as the work stored in an elastic body by its loads, and complementary energy as the area on the other side of the load-deflection curve.
  • Derive the strain energy of a member in axial force, bending, shear and torsion, and use Clapeyron's theorem W = ½ P δ for a single load on a linear structure.
  • Judge which energy terms matter in a given structure, for example why shear energy is dropped for slender beams but not for deep ones.

Theory

When a load is applied slowly to an elastic structure, it moves through a displacement and does work. If the material is elastic and nothing is lost to friction, heat or cracking, that work is stored inside the structure as strain energy U, and it is given back when the load is removed, just as a stretched spring gives back its energy. Energy methods use this single scalar quantity, instead of following forces member by member, to find deflections and redundant forces. Sign convention for this chapter: axial force is positive in tension, bending moment is positive when it causes sagging (or, in frames, tension on the inside face), and a deflection or rotation is positive in the direction of the load or unit load that is paired with it.

Draw the load-deflection curve of a member. The area under the curve, between the curve and the deflection axis, is the strain energy U = ∫P dδ. The area between the curve and the load axis is the complementary energy U* = ∫δ dP. Their sum is the rectangle P δ. For a linear elastic structure the curve is a straight line, the two triangles are equal and U = U* = ½ P δ. This is Clapeyron's theorem: the work of a gradually applied load is half of the load times its final deflection, not the full product, because the load grows from zero as the structure deflects.

UU*δPU + U* = P δIndiacon original
Figure 2.1: Strain energy U is the area under the load-deflection curve; complementary energy U* is the area above it. For a straight line the two are equal. Indiacon original, not to scale.

At a point in the material the stored energy per unit volume is the strain energy density, the area under the stress-strain curve: u = ∫σ dε, which is σ²/(2E) for a linear material in uniaxial stress. Adding this over the volume of a member gives the familiar expressions. A bar in axial force stores N²L/(2EA). A beam stores ∫M²/(2EI) dx in bending and ∫α_s V²/(2GA) dx in shear, where α_s is a shape factor (6/5 for a rectangle). A shaft stores ∫T²/(2GJ) dx in torsion. The total strain energy of a structure is the sum over all members and all actions.

Not every term matters. In a slender beam the bending term is far larger than the shear term, so the shear term is usually dropped; in a truss only axial force acts. In frames the bending term normally dominates the axial term. For a rectangular simply supported beam the ratio of shear energy to bending energy is about 1.2 (E/G)(d/L)², which is a few per cent for a span-to-depth ratio of 10 but large for a deep beam or a short bracket. Complementary energy becomes different from strain energy only when the load-deflection relation is nonlinear, for example in a cable that stiffens as it tightens or a material beyond its elastic range; then deflections must be found from U*, not U.

Derivation

  1. Work of a slowly applied load: as the load grows from 0 to P, the deflection grows from 0 to δ; the work is W = ∫₀^δ P dδ. For a linear structure P = k δ, so W = ½ k δ² = ½ P δ (Clapeyron's theorem), and this work is stored as U.
  2. Strain energy density: a small cube of sides dx, dy, dz under stress σ stretches by ε dx; the work is ∫σ dε dV, so u = ∫σ dε per unit volume, and for σ = E ε, u = σ²/(2E) = E ε²/2.
  3. Axial member: σ = N/A is uniform, so U = ∫ (N/A)²/(2E) A dx = ∫ N²/(2EA) dx, which is N²L/(2EA) for a prismatic bar with constant N.
  4. Bending: σ = M y/I, so over a cross-section ∫ σ²/(2E) dA = M²/(2EI²) ∫ y² dA = M²/(2EI); integrating along the member gives U = ∫ M²/(2EI) dx.
  5. Shear and torsion: in the same way the shear stress gives U = ∫ α_s V²/(2GA) dx, where α_s = (A/I²)∫(Q/b)² dA is 6/5 for a rectangle, and a circular shaft with τ = T r/J gives U = ∫ T²/(2GJ) dx.
  6. Complementary energy: U* = ∫₀^P δ dP. Since U + U* = P δ for any curve, U* = U only when the curve is straight; for a nonlinear elastic member the two differ and the deflection is δ = dU*/dP.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Clapeyron's theorem, single load on a linear structure: W = U = ½ P δ (P in N, δ in mm, U in N mm; 1 N mm = 10⁻³ J)
  • Strain energy density u = σ²/(2E) = E ε²/2 (N/mm², that is N mm per mm³)
  • Axial: U = Σ N²L/(2EA) (N in N, L in mm, E in N/mm², A in mm²)
  • Bending: U = ∫ M²/(2EI) dx; shear: U = ∫ α_s V²/(2GA) dx with α_s = 6/5 for a rectangle
  • Torsion: U = ∫ T²/(2GJ) dx (T in N mm, G in N/mm², J in mm⁴)
  • Complementary energy U* = ∫ δ dP; U + U* = P δ; U* = U only for linear behaviour
Assumptions and limits
  • Loads are applied slowly (statically), so no kinetic energy is produced and all work is stored.
  • The material is elastic: the stored energy is fully recovered on unloading, with no losses to friction, yielding or cracking.
  • For the closed-form expressions, small displacements and linear elastic material are assumed, so U = U* = ½ P δ.
  • Member expressions use beam theory: plane sections remain plane, the member is slender and stresses are found from N, M, V and T.
  • Limits: strain energy is a quadratic, not linear, function of load, so the energies of two load cases cannot be added; the cross term must be kept. Beyond the elastic range, or under impact, other methods are needed.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Strain energy and complementary energy are results of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, all use energy and virtual work principles behind their deflection and stiffness calculations; the elastic moduli and load values used in design come from each practice's own codes and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (cantilever deflection from energy, exam style)

Problem. A cantilever of length 3 m carries a point load of 20 kN at its free end. EI = 2 × 10⁴ kN m². Ignoring shear energy, find the strain energy and, using Clapeyron's theorem, the deflection under the load.

  1. Taking x from the free end, M = P x, so U = ∫₀^L (P x)²/(2EI) dx = P²L³/(6EI).
  2. U = 20² × 3³/(6 × 2 × 10⁴) = 10 800/120 000 = 0.090 kN m = 90 J.
  3. Clapeyron: U = ½ P δ, so δ = 2U/P = 2 × 0.090/20 = 0.0090 m = 9.0 mm.
  4. Check with the standard result δ = PL³/(3EI) = 20 × 27/(6 × 10⁴) = 0.0090 m; the two agree.

Answer. U = 90 J; tip deflection 9.0 mm

Example 2 (tie rod: uniform or thickened?)

Problem. A steel hanger rod of a footbridge is 4 m long, 25 mm in diameter and carries 100 kN. E = 200 000 N/mm². (a) Find its strain energy and extension. (b) If 1 m of its length is thickened to 32 mm diameter, find the new strain energy at the same load.

  1. (a) A = π × 25²/4 = 490.9 mm²; U = N²L/(2EA) = (10⁵)² × 4000/(2 × 200 000 × 490.9) = 203 700 N mm = 203.7 J.
  2. Extension δ = NL/(EA) = 10⁵ × 4000/(200 000 × 490.9) = 4.07 mm; check ½ × 10⁵ × 4.074 = 203 700 N mm.
  3. (b) Thick part A₂ = π × 32²/4 = 804.2 mm²; U = (N²/2E)(3000/490.9 + 1000/804.2) = 25 000 × (6.112 + 1.243) = 183 900 N mm = 183.9 J.
  4. The peak stress in the thin part is 10⁵/490.9 = 203.7 N/mm² in both cases, but the thickened rod stores about 10 per cent less energy, so under a sudden or impact load it would reach a higher stress. Bolts meant to absorb shock are therefore turned down along the shank, not thickened.

Answer. (a) 203.7 J and 4.07 mm; (b) 183.9 J at the same peak stress of 203.7 N/mm²

Example 3 (is shear energy worth keeping?)

Problem. A rectangular concrete beam 300 mm wide and 600 mm deep spans 6 m, simply supported, and carries a central point load of 200 kN. E = 25 000 N/mm² and ν = 0.2. Compare the bending and shear strain energies and the deflections they cause.

  1. G = E/(2(1 + ν)) = 25 000/2.4 = 10 417 N/mm²; I = 300 × 600³/12 = 5.4 × 10⁹ mm⁴; A = 180 000 mm².
  2. Bending: M = Px/2 on each half, so U_b = P²L³/(96EI) = (2 × 10⁵)² × 6000³/(96 × 25 000 × 5.4 × 10⁹) = 666 700 N mm = 666.7 J, which gives δ_b = 2U_b/P = 6.67 mm (= PL³/48EI).
  3. Shear: V = P/2 along the span, so U_s = α_s (P/2)² L/(2GA) = 1.2 × 10¹⁰ × 6000/(2 × 10 417 × 180 000) = 19 200 N mm = 19.2 J, adding 2 × 19 200/200 000 = 0.19 mm.
  4. Ratio U_s/U_b = 19.2/666.7 = 2.9 per cent, matching 1.2 (E/G)(d/L)² = 1.2 × 2.4 × 0.01 = 0.0288.
  5. For this slender beam the shear term can be dropped; for a deep transfer beam with d/L = 0.5 the same ratio would be 0.72, and shear deformation must be kept.

Answer. Bending energy 666.7 J (6.67 mm), shear energy 19.2 J (0.19 mm), shear about 2.9 per cent of bending

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Draw the structure, its loads and its supports; find the reactions.
  2. For each member write the internal actions (N, M, V, T) as functions of position, with the sign convention stated.
  3. Write the strain energy of each member from the relevant expressions and decide which terms can be dropped (shear in slender beams, axial in frames).
  4. Add the member energies to get U for the structure.
  5. For a single load on a linear structure, use δ = 2U/P; for anything more, go on to Castigliano's theorems (lesson 2.2) or the unit load method (lessons 2.3 and 2.4).

Site notes

  • Energy absorption matters wherever loads arrive suddenly: crash barriers, fender systems at jetties, anchor bolts under machinery and lifting gear are all sized by the energy they can take, not only by the force.
  • A long, slender, uniform tie or bolt stores more energy at a given stress than a short or locally thickened one; do not let fabricators thicken or weld lugs onto shock-absorbing rods without the designer's approval.
  • Shear deformation is real in deep members: deep transfer girders, pile caps and short corbels deflect more than bending theory alone predicts.
  • Load tests record load and deflection together; the area under the measured curve is the energy put into the structure, and a loop that does not close on unloading shows energy lost to cracking or slip.
Common mistakes
  • Writing the work of a load as P δ instead of ½ P δ for a gradually applied load.
  • Adding the strain energies of two load cases separately; energy is quadratic, so the cross term is lost.
  • Mixing units, for example kN with mm and N/mm² without converting; work in N and mm, or kN and m, throughout.
  • Dropping shear energy in a deep beam or a short bracket where it is significant.
  • Using strain energy instead of complementary energy to find deflections of a nonlinear structure such as a cable.
Quick check

For a rectangular simply supported beam under a central load, shear energy is about 1.2 (E/G)(d/L)² of the bending energy; with E/G about 2.4 to 2.6 this is about 3 per cent or less when the span is at least ten times the depth. Valid for prismatic, linear elastic beams; use the full expression for deep members.

Summary

  • Strain energy U is the work stored by slowly applied loads in an elastic structure.
  • Linear structure: U = U* = ½ P δ (Clapeyron's theorem).
  • Member energies: N²L/(2EA), ∫M²/(2EI) dx, ∫α_s V²/(2GA) dx, ∫T²/(2GJ) dx.
  • Bending dominates beams and frames; axial force alone acts in trusses.
  • Energies of separate load cases cannot be added; complementary energy differs from strain energy when behaviour is nonlinear.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A steel bar 2 m long with A = 500 mm² carries 50 kN in tension. E = 200 000 N/mm². Find its strain energy.

U = (50 000)² × 2000/(2 × 200 000 × 500) = 25 000 N mm = 25 J.

2Find the strain energy density in steel stressed to 250 N/mm² with E = 200 000 N/mm².

u = 250²/(2 × 200 000) = 0.156 N mm per mm³ (0.156 MJ/m³).

3A cantilever 4 m long carries 10 kN/m over its full length; EI = 2 × 10⁴ kN m². Find the bending strain energy.

M = w x²/2, so U = w²L⁵/(40EI) = 100 × 1024/(40 × 2 × 10⁴) = 0.128 kN m = 128 J.

4A stiffening spring follows P = c δ² with c = 2 kN/mm². At δ = 3 mm find P, U and U*.

P = 18 kN; U = c δ³/3 = 18 kN mm; U* = P δ − U = 54 − 18 = 36 kN mm. They differ because the spring is nonlinear.

5A solid steel shaft of 50 mm diameter and 1.5 m length carries a torque of 2 kN m; G = 80 000 N/mm². Find its strain energy.

J = π × 50⁴/32 = 613 600 mm⁴; U = (2 × 10⁶)² × 1500/(2 × 80 000 × 613 600) = 61 100 N mm = 61.1 J.

6Why can the energies of a dead load case and a live load case not simply be added?

Strain energy varies with the square of the load: (P₁ + P₂)² is not P₁² + P₂². The cross term 2P₁P₂ is missing, so the structure must be analysed under the combined loads, or deflections (which are linear) added instead.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.