Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 2 › Lesson 2.4

2.4 Unit load method for trusses

Structural Analysis Chapter 2: Energy methods Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Apply the unit load method to pin-jointed trusses with δ = Σ N n L/(AE), laying the work out in a member table.
  • Find joint deflections caused by temperature change and by members made too long or too short (lack of fit), and use them to set camber.
  • Check answers with simple limits, such as zero movement of a determinate truss shape under uniform temperature.

Theory

In a pin-jointed truss with loads at the joints every member carries only axial force, so the only strain energy is axial and the unit load method takes a simple form. Apply a unit load at the joint whose movement is wanted, in the direction wanted, and find the member forces n caused by it. With N the member forces from the real loads, the joint deflection is δ = Σ N n L/(AE), summed over all members. Sign convention for this lesson: member forces positive in tension, both for N and for n; a positive δ is in the direction of the unit load.

The same virtual work argument as in lesson 2.3 applies. The unit load and its member forces n are in equilibrium; the real truss supplies member elongations e = N L/(AE). The unit load moving through the joint deflection does external work 1 × δ, and the member forces n moving through the elongations do internal work Σ n e. Because only elongations enter, they need not come from load: a member heated by ΔT lengthens by e = α ΔT L, and a member made too long by Δ has e = +Δ (too short gives −Δ). The same formula δ = Σ n e then gives the joint movement from temperature or fabrication errors.

30 kNABCD−25 (−5/6)−25 (−5/6)+30 (1)+20 (2/3)+20 (2/3)N (n), kNIndiacon original
Figure 2.4: King-post truss with a hoist load at the tie: real member forces N in kN and, in brackets, the forces n from a unit load at the same joint (tension positive). Indiacon original, not to scale.

The work is best set out as a table with one row per member: length L, area A, real force N, unit force n, and the product N n L/A. Only members with both N and n non-zero contribute, so zero-force members under either load can be skipped. The table also shows which members control the deflection, which tells the designer where extra area is worth adding. A second unit load case, for example a horizontal unit load, needs only a new n column.

Camber is the opposite use. Long-span trusses are often fabricated with some members slightly short or long so that, under dead load, the bottom chord ends up straight or slightly hogging. The required length change is found by asking what lack of fit Δ gives a joint movement equal and opposite to the calculated dead-load deflection. In a statically determinate truss such length changes, and uniform temperature changes, cause movement but no member forces, because the truss is free to adjust; in an indeterminate truss they also cause forces, which is the subject of the force method in the next chapter.

Derivation

  1. Real system: under the real joint loads each member carries force N and lengthens by e = N L/(AE) (plus α ΔT L for temperature, plus Δ for lack of fit).
  2. Virtual system: a unit load at joint j in the chosen direction, with member forces n found by joints or sections; it is in equilibrium with its reactions.
  3. External virtual work: the unit load moves through the real deflection, 1 × δ_j; reactions at unyielding supports do no work.
  4. Internal virtual work: each member force n moves through the real elongation e, giving Σ n e.
  5. Equating: δ_j = Σ n e = Σ N n L/(AE) + Σ n α ΔT L + Σ n Δ. The same result follows from Castigliano's theorem with U = Σ N²L/(2AE) and ∂N/∂Q = n.
  6. Uniform temperature on a determinate truss: every length is scaled by (1 + α ΔT), so the truss keeps its shape about the pinned support, and joints that lie on a line through the pin in the direction of interest do not move in the perpendicular direction. This is a useful check on the n values.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Joint deflection from loads: δ = Σ N n L/(AE) (N and n in kN, L in mm, A in mm², E in kN/mm² gives δ in mm)
  • Temperature: δ = Σ n α ΔT L; lack of fit: δ = Σ n Δ (Δ positive when the member is too long)
  • Combined: δ = Σ n (N L/(AE) + α ΔT L + Δ)
  • Support movement: subtract Σ r Δ_s, where r is the unit-load reaction and Δ_s the support movement in its direction
  • Steel: E = 200 kN/mm², α = 12 × 10⁻⁶ per °C
  • Member elongation e = N L/(AE); strain energy U = Σ N²L/(2AE)
Assumptions and limits
  • Joints are frictionless pins and loads act only at joints, so members carry axial force only.
  • Linear elastic members and small displacements; geometry is taken as the original one.
  • Supports are unyielding unless a support movement term −Σ r Δ_s is added.
  • Temperature change is uniform along each member and lack of fit is a change of the member's unstressed length.
  • Limits: joint stiffness causes secondary bending that slightly reduces deflections; slack in bolted joints adds movement that the formula does not include and can be larger than the elastic value in light trusses.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Truss deflection by the unit load method is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, all compute truss deflections and camber by elastic methods of this kind; deflection limits, camber rules and material values for design are set in each practice's own codes and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (two-member bracket, exam style)

Problem. A wall bracket has a horizontal member AB 3 m long, pinned to the wall at A, and an inclined member CB pinned to the wall at C, 4 m directly above A, so CB is 5 m long. A load of 60 kN hangs at B. Areas: AB 2000 mm², CB 1000 mm²; E = 200 kN/mm². Find the vertical and horizontal movements of B.

  1. Real forces at B: vertical, N_CB × 4/5 = 60, so N_CB = +75 kN (tension); horizontal, N_AB = −75 × 3/5 = −45 kN (compression).
  2. Unit load downward at B: n_CB = +1.25, n_AB = −0.75.
  3. Table: AB, N n L/A = (−45)(−0.75)(3000)/2000 = 50.63; CB, (75)(1.25)(5000)/1000 = 468.75; sum 519.4.
  4. δ_v = 519.4/200 = 2.60 mm downward.
  5. Unit load horizontal at B, away from the wall: n_AB = +1, n_CB = 0. δ_h = (−45)(1)(3000)/(2000 × 200) = −0.34 mm, so B moves 0.34 mm towards the wall.

Answer. B moves 2.60 mm down and 0.34 mm towards the wall

Example 2 (roof truss with a hoist, and camber from a short king post)

Problem. A king-post roof truss spans 8 m with a rise of 3 m: rafters AB and BC (5 m), tie AD and DC (4 m each, D at midspan) and king post BD (3 m). A is pinned and C is on a roller. A chain hoist of 30 kN hangs from D. Areas: rafters 1500 mm², ties 1000 mm², king post 800 mm²; E = 200 kN/mm². (a) Find the vertical deflection of D. (b) The king post is fabricated 3 mm short to give camber; find the net movement of D under the hoist load.

  1. Real forces: BD = +30 kN; at B, 2 × F × 3/5 = 30 gives rafters −25 kN; at A, the tie carries 25 × 4/5 = +20 kN; reactions 15 kN each.
  2. Unit load down at D: forces are the real ones divided by 30, so rafters −5/6, ties +2/3, post +1.
  3. Table of N n L/A: rafters 2 × 25 × (5/6) × 5000/1500 = 138.9; ties 2 × 20 × (2/3) × 4000/1000 = 106.7; post 30 × 1 × 3000/800 = 112.5; sum 358.1.
  4. (a) δ_D = 358.1/200 = 1.79 mm downward.
  5. (b) Lack of fit: δ = n Δ = 1 × (−3) = −3 mm, so D is lifted 3 mm with no member forces. Net under the hoist: 1.79 − 3 = −1.21 mm, that is 1.21 mm above the straight line.

Answer. (a) 1.79 mm down; (b) 1.21 mm up after the 3 mm camber

Example 3 (spread at the roller and temperature effects)

Problem. For the truss of Example 2, find (a) the horizontal movement of the roller C under the hoist load, (b) the movements of C and of D when the whole truss warms by 30 °C, and (c) the movement of D when only the tie warms by 30 °C (rafters shaded). α = 12 × 10⁻⁶ per °C.

  1. Unit horizontal load at C, away from A: reactions give no vertical components, so the rafters and post carry nothing and the tie carries n = +1.
  2. (a) δ_C = Σ N n L/(AE) = 2 × 20 × 1 × 4000/(1000 × 200) = 0.80 mm outward.
  3. (b) Uniform rise: e = α ΔT L. δ_C = Σ n e = 1 × 12 × 10⁻⁶ × 30 × 8000 = 2.88 mm outward. For D: Σ n e = α ΔT[2(−5/6)(5000) + 2(2/3)(4000) + 1(3000)] = α ΔT × 0 = 0, so D does not move vertically: the truss keeps its shape.
  4. (c) Tie only: each half lengthens 12 × 10⁻⁶ × 30 × 4000 = 1.44 mm; δ_D = 2 × (2/3) × 1.44 = 1.92 mm downward.
  5. The roller must allow at least 0.80 + 2.88 = 3.68 mm of outward movement for these cases, and uneven heating moves D more than the hoist load does.

Answer. (a) 0.80 mm; (b) C 2.88 mm outward, D zero vertical; (c) D 1.92 mm down

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Find the real member forces N by joints or sections; record them with tension positive.
  2. Apply a unit load at the joint and in the direction wanted; find the member forces n.
  3. Make a table: member, L, A, N, n, N n L/A; add α ΔT L and Δ columns if temperature or lack of fit act.
  4. Sum the columns: δ = Σ N n L/(AE) + Σ n α ΔT L + Σ n Δ.
  5. Interpret the sign: positive means in the direction of the unit load. For camber, choose Δ values that cancel the dead-load deflection.

Site notes

  • Check camber on the fabrication drawings and measure it on the assembled truss before lifting; a truss erected without its designed camber will sag visibly under the roof load.
  • Bolt slip in bearing-type connections adds deflection: a truss with many bolted joints in clearance holes can deflect noticeably more than the calculation on first loading.
  • Hoists and pipe hangers fixed to bottom-chord nodes are loads the original design may not include; get them checked, and fix them at nodes, not mid-member.
  • Roller and sliding bearings must allow the spread from load and temperature; seized bearings turn a determinate truss into a tied arch with forces the designer did not plan for.
Common mistakes
  • Using different sign conventions for N and n (both must be tension positive).
  • Leaving out members because their N is zero although n is not zero (they contribute nothing for loads, but they do for temperature or lack of fit).
  • Mixing units: kN with N/mm², or lengths in m with areas in mm².
  • Using the length change of a member as Δ with the wrong sign: too long is positive, too short negative.
  • Expecting uniform temperature to cause forces in a determinate truss; it causes movement only.
Quick check

Uniform temperature on a statically determinate truss changes every length by the same ratio, so the truss keeps its shape about the pinned support: the movement of any joint is α ΔT times its distance from the pin, along the line to the pin. If your Σ n α ΔT L disagrees with this, recheck the n values. Valid for determinate trusses with one pinned support and a free roller.

Summary

  • Trusses: δ = Σ N n L/(AE), with N and n both tension positive.
  • Temperature and lack of fit enter as member elongations: δ = Σ n (α ΔT L + Δ).
  • A member table shows which members control deflection.
  • Camber is set by deliberate lack of fit that cancels the dead-load deflection.
  • Determinate trusses move but carry no force under temperature and lack of fit.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Two members, each 2 m long and at 45° to the vertical, hang a load of 50 kN at their common joint. A = 500 mm², E = 200 kN/mm². Find the vertical deflection of the joint.

N = 50/(2 cos 45°) = 35.36 kN and n = 0.7071 in each; δ = 2 × 35.36 × 0.7071 × 2000/(500 × 200) = 1.00 mm.

2In Example 1, the area of CB is doubled to 2000 mm². Find the new vertical deflection of B.

CB term becomes 234.4; δ = (50.63 + 234.4)/200 = 1.425 mm, about 1.43 mm.

3In Example 1, member CB is fabricated 2 mm too long and carries no load. How far does B drop when the bracket is assembled?

δ = n Δ = 1.25 × 2 = 2.5 mm downward, with no member forces.

4A member has N = 0 under the real loads but n = 0.8 for the unit load. Does it affect the deflection?

Not for the load term, since N n L/(AE) = 0, but it does if it is heated or made too long or short, because n e is not zero.

5In Example 2(a), what share of the deflection comes from the rafters?

138.9/358.1 = 38.8 per cent (ties 29.8 per cent, king post 31.4 per cent).

6Why can a statically determinate truss with one member 5 mm too long be assembled without force, while an indeterminate one cannot?

In a determinate truss the joints can move to fit the member, since there are just enough members to fix the shape. In an indeterminate truss the extra member is resisted by the others, so forcing it in sets up forces in all of them.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.