2.5 Maxwell-Betti reciprocal theorem
After this lesson you should be able to:
- State Betti's law and Maxwell's reciprocal theorem and prove them from the order in which loads are applied.
- Use reciprocal deflections to find a deflection that is easier to compute or measure with the load and the point swapped.
- Explain why the flexibility matrix of a linear structure is symmetric and how reciprocity underlies influence lines for deflection.
Theory
Betti's law states that, for a linear elastic structure with unyielding supports, the work done by a first set of loads acting through the displacements caused by a second set equals the work done by the second set acting through the displacements caused by the first. Maxwell's reciprocal theorem is the special case of single unit loads: the deflection at point i caused by a unit load at point j equals the deflection at j caused by a unit load at i, δ_ij = δ_ji. The two points can be anywhere, and the loads can be forces or couples, as long as each displacement is measured in the direction of the load paired with it. Sign convention as in this chapter: a displacement is positive in the direction of the load it is paired with.
The law is not obvious from a sketch. A load at the tip of a cantilever and the same load at midspan produce very different deflected shapes, yet the tip deflection caused by the midspan load is exactly the midspan deflection caused by the tip load. The reason is energy: the work stored in a linear structure does not depend on the order in which loads are applied, and writing that work for the two orders gives the reciprocal relation directly. It mixes forces and moments too: the rotation at a point caused by a unit force elsewhere equals the deflection at that second point caused by a unit couple at the first, numerically, in consistent units.
Reciprocity has three everyday uses. First, it cuts work: a deflection that is awkward to compute can be found with the load and the observation point swapped. Second, it makes the flexibility matrix (the table of δ_ij) symmetric, so in the force method only half of the coefficients need computing, and the stiffness matrix of the displacement methods is symmetric for the same reason. Third, it turns deflected shapes into influence lines: the deflected shape caused by a unit load at point i is the influence line for the deflection at i as a load moves across the structure. The Müller-Breslau principle for force influence lines rests on the same idea.
The theorem holds only within its assumptions. The structure must be linear elastic with small displacements, the supports must not move during loading, and both load states must act on the same structure with the same supports. It fails once the material yields, cracks progressively or creeps, if supports settle under load, or if geometric nonlinearity (large deflection, axial load affecting bending) is significant. Even so, it is a powerful check: a computed flexibility matrix that is not symmetric points to an error.
Derivation
- Apply load P_A at point A first. It deflects A by δ_AA and does work ½ P_A δ_AA.
- Then apply P_B at point B. It does its own work ½ P_B δ_BB, and P_A, already in place, moves further by δ_AB (deflection at A caused by B), doing work P_A δ_AB at full value. Total: ½ P_A δ_AA + ½ P_B δ_BB + P_A δ_AB.
- Apply the loads in the reverse order: P_B first, then P_A. The total is ½ P_B δ_BB + ½ P_A δ_AA + P_B δ_BA.
- For a linear elastic structure the stored energy depends only on the final state, not on the order of loading, so the two totals are equal: P_A δ_AB = P_B δ_BA (Betti's law).
- With P_A = P_B = 1, δ_AB = δ_BA (Maxwell's theorem). For a cantilever of span L, a unit load at the tip gives a deflection at x of x²(3L − x)/(6EI); at x = L/2 this is 5L³/(48EI), the same as the tip deflection from a unit load at midspan.
- Flexibility matrix: the deflections are δ_i = Σ f_ij P_j; Maxwell's theorem gives f_ij = f_ji, so the matrix [f] is symmetric, and its inverse, the stiffness matrix, is symmetric too.
Betti's law: Σ P_A δ_AB = Σ P_B δ_BA (forces times displacements of the other state)Maxwell's theorem: δ_ij = δ_ji for unit loads; also θ_ij (rotation from a unit force) = δ_ji (deflection from a unit couple), in consistent unitsCantilever, unit load at the tip: deflection at x = x²(3L − x)/(6EI); at midspan 5L³/(48EI)Simple span L, load P at a from the left (b = L − a), deflection at x ≤ a: P b x (L² − b² − x²)/(6EIL)Flexibility matrix: δ = [f] P with f_ij = f_ji; stiffness matrix [k] = [f]⁻¹ is symmetricUnits: δ in m with P in kN, L in m, EI in kN m²
- Linear elastic material and small displacements; superposition holds.
- Supports are unyielding during both load states and the structure is the same in both.
- Displacements are measured at the load points in the directions of the loads paired with them.
- Loads are applied slowly; no energy is lost to friction, cracking or plastic flow.
- Limits: reciprocity fails after yielding, progressive cracking or creep, under support settlement during loading, and in geometrically nonlinear behaviour.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- The reciprocal theorems are results of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, use matrix and influence-line analysis that rests on reciprocity in the same way; load testing procedures and acceptance criteria are set in each practice's own documents and are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A cantilever of span 4 m has EI = 2 × 10⁴ kN m². (a) Show that a 10 kN load at midspan gives the same tip deflection as the midspan deflection given by a 10 kN load at the tip. (b) Write the flexibility matrix for points 1 (midspan) and 2 (tip).
- (a) Load at midspan: the outer half stays straight, so δ_tip = P(L/2)³/(3EI) + P(L/2)²/(2EI) × L/2 = 5PL³/(48EI) = 5 × 10 × 64/(48 × 2 × 10⁴) = 3.33 mm.
- Load at the tip: δ at x = L/2 is P x²(3L − x)/(6EI) = 10 × 4 × 10/(6 × 2 × 10⁴) = 3.33 mm. The two agree.
- (b) f₁₁ = (L/2)³/(3EI) = 8/(6 × 10⁴) m per kN = 0.133 mm/kN; f₂₂ = L³/(3EI) = 1.067 mm/kN.
- f₁₂ = f₂₁ = 5L³/(48EI) = 0.333 mm/kN; only three of the four numbers needed computing.
- Flexibility matrix [f] = [[0.133, 0.333], [0.333, 1.067]] mm/kN, symmetric as Maxwell's theorem requires.
Answer. Both deflections 3.33 mm; f₁₁ = 0.133, f₁₂ = f₂₁ = 0.333, f₂₂ = 1.067 mm/kN
Problem. A simply supported test beam spans 10 m with EI = 1 × 10⁵ kN m². In test 1 a 50 kN jack load acts 3 m from the left support and a dial gauge reads at 6 m. In test 2 the jack and the gauge are swapped. Predict both readings.
- Test 1: load at a = 3 m, point at x = 6 m (to the right of the load); measured from the right end the point is at 4 m and the load at 7 m, so δ = P × 3 × 4 × (100 − 9 − 16)/(6EI × 10) = 50 × 12 × 75/(60 × 10⁵) = 0.0075 m.
- Test 2: load at 6 m (b = 4 m), point at x = 3 m: δ = P b x (L² − b² − x²)/(6EIL) = 50 × 4 × 3 × (100 − 16 − 9)/(60 × 10⁵) = 0.0075 m.
- Both readings are 7.5 mm, as Maxwell's theorem predicts.
- If the two measured readings differ by more than the gauge accuracy, the beam is not behaving linearly (cracking, slip at the bearings, or a support that moves), which is itself useful information.
Answer. 7.5 mm in both tests
Problem. A cantilever of span 3 m has EI = 1.8 × 10⁴ kN m². State 1: a 20 kN load at the tip. State 2: a 30 kN m couple at the tip. Check Betti's law using the tip rotation of state 1 and the tip deflection of state 2.
- State 1: tip rotation θ₁ = PL²/(2EI) = 20 × 9/(3.6 × 10⁴) = 0.0050 rad.
- State 2: tip deflection δ₂ = ML²/(2EI) = 30 × 9/(3.6 × 10⁴) = 0.0075 m = 7.5 mm.
- Betti: P × δ₂ = 20 × 0.0075 = 0.150 kN m; M × θ₁ = 30 × 0.0050 = 0.150 kN m. The two works are equal.
- Per unit load: rotation per kN = 9/36 000 = 2.5 × 10⁻⁴ rad; deflection per kN m = 2.5 × 10⁻⁴ m. A force and a couple are reciprocal in the same way as two forces.
Answer. θ₁ = 0.0050 rad, δ₂ = 7.5 mm; both products 0.150 kN m
Step-by-step procedure
- Check that the structure is linear elastic with unyielding supports, and that both load states act on the same structure.
- Identify the two points and directions; pair each load with the displacement in its own direction.
- Compute (or measure) whichever reciprocal deflection is easier: δ_ji instead of δ_ij.
- For Betti's law with general loads, equate Σ P_A δ_AB and Σ P_B δ_BA and solve for the unknown displacement.
- Use the symmetry of the flexibility matrix as a check: f_ij and f_ji computed separately must agree.
Site notes
- In a load test, swapping the jack and the gauge positions should give the same reading; a clear difference shows nonlinearity, bearing slip or support movement.
- Influence lines for deflection can be found from a single loaded deflected shape: the shape under a unit load at the gauge point shows how that point responds to a load anywhere.
- On bridges, deflection under a test vehicle at one position and gauges at several points gives, by reciprocity, the response at one point to the vehicle at several positions.
- Results from a structure that has cracked or yielded during the test no longer obey reciprocity; plan the load steps so that the linear range is tested first.
- Comparing a deflection with a rotation without pairing each with the matching load (force with deflection, couple with rotation).
- Applying the theorem to a structure whose supports settle during loading.
- Swapping the points but measuring the deflection in a different direction from the load.
- Expecting reciprocity after cracking or yielding.
- Forgetting that Betti's law equates works, so loads of different size must be included.
For a cantilever, the tip deflection from a load at midspan is 5/16 of the tip deflection from the same load at the tip (5L³/48EI against L³/3EI). The same 5/16 ratio applies to the midspan deflection from a tip load. Valid for prismatic cantilevers in the linear range.
Summary
- Betti: P_A δ_AB = P_B δ_BA for any two load states on the same linear structure.
- Maxwell: δ_ij = δ_ji for unit loads, including force-couple pairs.
- Proof: stored energy does not depend on the order of loading.
- Flexibility and stiffness matrices are symmetric.
- Deflected shapes under a unit load are influence lines for deflection.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A simply supported beam of span 8 m has EI = 5 × 10⁴ kN m². A 40 kN load acts 2 m from the left support. Find the deflection 5 m from the left support, and say what load position would give the same reading at 2 m.
From the right end the point is at 3 m and the load at 6 m: δ = 40 × 2 × 3 × (64 − 4 − 9)/(6 × 5 × 10⁴ × 8) = 5.1 mm. The same 40 kN at 5 m gives 5.1 mm at 2 m.
2State the conditions under which Maxwell's theorem holds.
Linear elastic material, small displacements, unyielding supports, the same structure in both states, and each displacement measured in the direction of its paired load.
3A 10 kN load at C produces a deflection of 4 mm at D. What deflection at C does a 25 kN load at D produce?
δ_DC per kN = 0.4 mm, so δ_CD = 0.4 mm per kN; 25 kN gives 10 mm at C.
4Load P₁ = 30 kN at point 1 gives 2 mm at point 2. Load P₂ = 50 kN at point 2 alone gives what deflection at point 1?
Betti: P₁ δ₁₂ = P₂ δ₂₁, so 30 δ₁₂ = 50 × 2 and δ₁₂ = 3.33 mm.
5Use reciprocity to find the midspan deflection of a 6 m simple span under 10 kN/m; EI = 2 × 10⁴ kN m².
The midspan deflection from load w dx at x equals w dx times the deflection at x from a unit midspan load; integrating gives 5wL⁴/(384EI) = 5 × 10 × 1296/(384 × 2 × 10⁴) = 8.44 mm.
6How does Maxwell's theorem relate to influence lines?
The deflected shape under a unit load at point i gives, at every point j, δ_ji = δ_ij: the deflection at i when the unit load is at j. So the shape is the influence line for the deflection at i.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.