3.6 Rolling resistance
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Explain rolling resistance as the result of deformation at the contact between a wheel and the surface.
- Calculate the force to roll a wheel using the coefficient of rolling resistance, on level ground and on a slope.
- Compare rolling and sliding resistance and relate them to site haulage and pavement design.
Theory
A perfectly rigid wheel on a perfectly rigid surface would need no force to keep rolling at constant speed. Real wheels and surfaces deform: a tyre flattens, the ground or rail is pressed in, and the material ahead of the contact is compressed while the material behind recovers incompletely. The result is that the resultant ground reaction acts slightly ahead of the point directly below the axle.
This forward offset, a, is called the coefficient of rolling resistance. It has the dimension of length, unlike the dimensionless coefficient of friction. Because the normal reaction is offset by a, it has a moment about the axle that resists rolling. A horizontal force P at the axle must balance it, so P r ≈ W a and P = W a / r for a wheel of radius r. Larger wheels and harder surfaces roll more easily.
Values of a are small for hard materials (a fraction of a millimetre for steel wheels on steel rails) and much larger for soft tyres on soft ground. That difference is why railways move freight so efficiently and why haul roads on site are compacted and maintained: a rutted, soft haul road can multiply the rolling resistance of dumpers many times.
Rolling resistance is often written as a dimensionless coefficient Crr = a / r, so that P = Crr W. On a slope, the component of weight along the slope adds to it, giving the total tractive force needed.
Derivation
- Consider a wheel of weight W and radius r, pulled at the axle by a horizontal force P at constant speed.
- The ground reaction R passes through the axle (for equilibrium of a three-force body: W, P and R) and acts at horizontal distance a ahead of the point below the axle.
- Moments about the point where R acts: P × (height of the axle above that point) = W × a. For small a, that height is nearly r, so P r ≈ W a.
- Hence P = W a / r, and Crr = P / W = a / r.
- On a slope of angle θ, the normal component is W cos θ and the along-slope component W sin θ, so the force along the slope to move uphill is P = W (sin θ + (a/r) cos θ).
P = W a / r (N, with a and r in the same length unit)Coefficient of rolling resistance (dimensionless): Crr = a / rUphill tractive force: P = W (sin θ + Crr cos θ)Gradient of 1 in n: tan θ = 1/n
- Constant speed; no acceleration and no air resistance.
- Small deformation, so a is much smaller than r and the axle height is taken as r.
- a is a property of the wheel–surface pair and condition; published values vary widely and should be taken from tests or maker data.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- No design code governs this lesson. Rolling resistance appears indirectly in road and pavement practice through surface evenness (roughness) requirements in IRC specifications and in vehicle operating cost studies; those documents govern quality, not this mechanics.
Worked examples
Problem. A steel wheel of 600 mm diameter carries 10 kN on a steel plate. Taking a = 0.5 mm, find the horizontal force at the axle to keep it rolling. Compare with sliding the same load with μ = 0.3.
- r = 300 mm.
- P = W a / r = 10 000 × 0.5 / 300 = 16.67 N.
- Sliding would need μ W = 0.3 × 10 000 = 3 000 N.
- Rolling needs about 1/180 of the sliding force.
Answer. 16.67 N rolling against 3 000 N sliding
Problem. A trolley carrying 5 kN in total runs on wheels of 400 mm diameter up a ramp of 1 in 20. Take a = 1 mm. Find the force along the ramp needed to push it up at steady speed.
- r = 200 mm, so Crr = 1/200 = 0.005.
- tan θ = 1/20, θ = 2.862°; sin θ = 0.04994, cos θ = 0.99875.
- P = 5 000 (0.04994 + 0.005 × 0.99875) = 5 000 × 0.05493 = 274.7 N.
- The gradient term (249.7 N) dominates; on the level only 25 N would be needed.
Answer. About 274.7 N
Step-by-step procedure
- Find the wheel radius and the coefficient of rolling resistance for the surface.
- Compute Crr = a / r.
- On the level, P = Crr W; on a slope, add W sin θ.
- Divide among driven wheels if needed; check against available effort or engine tractive force.
- Compare with sliding to judge whether rollers or wheels are worthwhile.
Site notes
- Moving heavy machinery or precast units on steel rollers over steel plates needs only a small fraction of the sliding force, but watch for runaway on even slight gradients.
- Keep haul roads compacted, drained and free of ruts; soft or rutted surfaces greatly increase rolling resistance, fuel use and tyre wear.
- Larger wheels on trolleys and wheelbarrows roll more easily over rough ground, because P falls as r grows.
- Treating a as dimensionless; it is a length and must be in the same unit as r.
- Using the diameter instead of the radius.
- Forgetting the slope component when moving loads on ramps.
- Applying a value of a from one surface (steel on steel) to another (tyres on soil).
- Ignoring rolling resistance completely in haulage estimates.
Double the wheel diameter and you halve the rolling force. On any noticeable gradient, the slope term usually exceeds rolling resistance.
Summary
- Rolling resistance comes from deformation at the contact.
- P = W a / r; Crr = a / r.
- On a slope, P = W (sin θ + Crr cos θ).
- Rolling is far easier than sliding, and harder, smoother surfaces roll more easily.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A 50 kN rail wagon has wheels of 900 mm diameter and a = 0.25 mm. Find the rolling resistance.
P = 50 000 × 0.25 / 450 = 27.78 N.
2A 2 kN barrow has a wheel of 350 mm diameter on loose ground with a = 10 mm. Find the force to keep it rolling.
P = 2 000 × 10 / 175 = 114.3 N.
3What is Crr for a = 0.8 mm and r = 400 mm?
Crr = 0.8 / 400 = 0.002.
4In Example 2, what force is needed to hold the trolley still on the ramp if rolling resistance is ignored?
W sin θ = 5 000 × 0.04994 = 249.7 N.
5Why do rail systems need much less tractive force per tonne than road vehicles?
Steel wheels on steel rails deform very little, so a, and hence Crr, is far smaller than for rubber tyres on asphalt.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, D. F. Mazurek, P. J. Cornwell, B. P. Self, Vector Mechanics for Engineers: Statics and Dynamics, McGraw Hill, 12th edition, 2019.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Pearson, 15th edition, 2022 (published 2021).
- J. L. Meriam, L. G. Kraige, J. N. Bolton, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Wiley, 9th edition, 2018.
- S. Timoshenko, D. H. Young, J. V. Rao, S. Pati, Engineering Mechanics (in SI units), McGraw Hill Education (India), 5th edition, 2013.