4.2 Slope-deflection method for frames with sway
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Extend the slope-deflection equations to rigid frames whose joints can move sideways (sway), with the storey sway Δ as an extra unknown.
- Write the storey shear (sway) equation that balances the column shears against the applied horizontal load.
- Recognise when a frame cannot sway (symmetry or bracing) and when unsymmetrical supports or loads make it sway under gravity load alone.
Theory
A portal frame has two columns and a beam joined rigidly. If its beam can move sideways, the tops of the columns move by the same amount Δ (the beam is taken as axially rigid), and every column gets a chord rotation ψ = Δ/h. Sway is one more unknown displacement, so one more equation is needed. Sign convention for this chapter: a moment acting on the end of a member is positive when it turns clockwise, joint rotations θ are positive clockwise, and the chord rotation ψ = Δ/L is positive when the line joining the two ends of a member turns clockwise. With this rule a negative end moment at the left end of a beam span and a positive end moment at the right end both mean hogging; bending moment diagrams are still drawn with sagging positive.
The joint equations are the same as for beams: at each rigid joint the end moments of the members meeting there sum to the applied joint moment. The extra equation comes from horizontal equilibrium of the whole storey. Cut through the tops of the columns: the horizontal forces carried by the columns (their shears) must balance the horizontal loads applied above the cut. For a column AB of height h with no load along it, moment equilibrium of the column gives the shear at its top as −(M_AB + M_BA)/h, measured in the direction in which positive sway acts.
A frame sways under horizontal load such as wind or an earthquake force, but it can also sway under gravity load if the frame or its load is unsymmetrical: one column stiffer than the other, a pinned base on one side, or a load placed off-centre. A symmetric frame with a symmetric load does not sway, and a frame braced by a wall or a diagonal member does not sway either; in those cases ψ = 0 and the analysis reduces to lesson 4.1.
Pinned column bases are handled with the reduced form M = (3EI/h)(θ − ψ) + (FEM terms), which removes the base rotation. For a single-bay frame under horizontal load only, antisymmetry gives θ_B = θ_C, which halves the work. Each extra storey adds one sway unknown and one storey shear equation; frames with many storeys are therefore solved by the matrix stiffness method, but the hand method shows clearly how lateral load is shared between columns by their stiffness.
Derivation
- Take the unknowns as the joint rotations (θ_B, θ_C) and the storey sway Δ, with ψ = Δ/h for every column of height h (positive when the column top moves in the positive sway direction, which turns the chord clockwise for the left-to-right direction drawn).
- Write the slope-deflection equation for every member end: beams with ψ = 0, columns with their ψ; use the reduced form for a column with a pinned base.
- Free body of a column AB with no load along its height: moments about the base give the horizontal shear at the top, V = −(M_AB + M_BA)/h, acting on the column in the direction of positive sway.
- Storey equilibrium: the sum of the column shears equals the applied horizontal load H at that level (plus the horizontal reactions of any loads applied on the columns themselves). With no horizontal load the sum is zero.
- Solve the joint equations and the storey equation together for θ_B, θ_C and ψ; then Δ = ψh.
- Back-substitute for all end moments and find reactions by statics; check that the horizontal base reactions add up to −H.
Members: M_AB = (2EI/L)(2θ_A + θ_B − 3ψ) + FEM_AB (kN m, EI in kN m², lengths in m)Column with a pinned base B: M_AT = (3EI/h)(θ_T − ψ) + FEM termsChord rotation of columns: ψ = Δ/h (same Δ for all columns of a storey)Column shear (no load on the column): V = −(M_bottom + M_top)/hStorey equation: Σ V = H (applied horizontal load at the storey, in the sway direction)Single bay, pinned bases, horizontal load H at beam level: column top moments = Hh/2 each, base shears H/2 each, vertical reactions ±Hh/L
- Linear elastic, small displacements; second-order (P-Δ) effects are ignored (lesson 'Second-order analysis' treats them).
- Members are prismatic and axially rigid, so both column tops sway by the same Δ and the beam does not change length.
- Joints are rigid and bases are either fully fixed or perfectly pinned.
- Loads on columns, if any, are added through their fixed-end moments and their share of the storey shear.
- Limits: the hand method suits one or two storeys; real bases are partly fixed and the results bracket the truth between the pinned and fixed cases.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- The slope-deflection analysis of sway frames is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, analyse sway frames elastically and then decide in their own codes when second-order effects, notional horizontal loads or sway limits apply; those values are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. A portal frame ABCD has fixed bases A and D, columns AB and DC 4 m high and a beam BC 6 m long, all with the same EI. A horizontal load of 20 kN acts at B towards C. Find the end moments and the sway.
- Unknowns: θ_B, θ_C and ψ = Δ/4. Antisymmetry under horizontal load gives θ_B = θ_C = θ.
- Equations (EI factored in): M_AB = 0.5(θ − 3ψ); M_BA = 0.5(2θ − 3ψ) = θ − 1.5ψ; M_BC = (2/6)(2θ + θ) = θ.
- Joint B: M_BA + M_BC = 0 gives 2θ = 1.5ψ, so ψ = 4θ/3.
- Storey shear: each column carries −(M_AB + M_BA)/4 and the two together carry 20 kN, so M_AB + M_BA = −40: 1.5θ − 3ψ = −40, giving −2.5θ = −40, EIθ = 16 and EIψ = 21.33, so Δ = 4ψ = 85.33/EI m.
- End moments: M_AB = M_DC = 8 − 32 = −24 kN m, M_BA = M_CD = 16 − 32 = −16 kN m, M_BC = M_CB = +16 kN m. Horizontal base reactions 10 kN each opposing the load. Vertical reactions from moments about D for the whole frame: 6R_A = −20 × 4 + 24 + 24 = −32, so R_A = 5.33 kN downward and R_D = 5.33 kN upward.
Answer. Base moments 24 kN m, column tops 16 kN m, beam ends 16 kN m; Δ = 85.33/EI m
Problem. A portal frame ABCD has A fixed and D pinned; columns 4 m, beam BC 6 m, all with the same EI. The beam carries 20 kN/m. Find the end moments and the sway.
- Unknowns θ_B, θ_C and ψ (positive for sway towards D). FEM_BC = −60 kN m, FEM_CB = +60 kN m.
- M_AB = 0.5θ_B − 1.5ψ; M_BA = θ_B − 1.5ψ; M_BC = (2θ_B + θ_C)/3 − 60; M_CB = (2θ_C + θ_B)/3 + 60; M_CD (pinned base, reduced form) = 0.75(θ_C − ψ).
- Joint B: 1.6667θ_B + 0.3333θ_C − 1.5ψ = 60. Joint C: 0.3333θ_B + 1.4167θ_C − 0.75ψ = −60.
- Storey shear with no horizontal load: M_AB + M_BA + M_CD = 0, that is 1.5θ_B + 0.75θ_C − 3.75ψ = 0.
- Solving: EIθ_B = 57.78, EIθ_C = −48.89, EIψ = 13.33, so the frame sways Δ = 53.33/EI m towards D. M_AB = +8.89, M_BA = +37.78, M_BC = −37.78, M_CB = +46.67, M_CD = −46.67 kN m. Horizontal base reactions 11.67 kN (towards D at A, the opposite way at D); vertical reactions 58.52 kN at A and 61.48 kN at D.
Answer. M_A = 8.89, M_B = 37.78, M_C = 46.67 kN m (beam-end hogging 37.78 and 46.67 kN m); sway 53.33/EI m
Problem. A portal frame with pinned bases A and D has columns 5 m high and a beam 8 m long, all with the same EI. A horizontal load of 30 kN acts at beam level. Find the moments, the reactions and the sway.
- Antisymmetry: θ_B = θ_C = θ. Columns use the reduced form M_BA = (3EI/5)(θ − ψ) = 0.6θ − 0.6ψ; beam M_BC = (2EI/8)(3θ) = 0.75θ.
- Joint B: 0.6θ − 0.6ψ + 0.75θ = 0, so ψ = 2.25θ.
- Storey shear: two columns each with shear −M_BA/5 carry 30 kN, so M_BA = −75 kN m. Then 0.6θ − 1.35θ = −75, EIθ = 100 and EIψ = 225, Δ = 1125/EI m.
- Column top moments 75 kN m, beam end moments +75 kN m at both ends with a contraflexure point at midspan.
- Reactions: horizontal 15 kN at each base; vertical ±30 × 5/8 = ±18.75 kN (down at the loaded side A, up at D).
Answer. Column tops 75 kN m; base shears 15 kN; vertical reactions ±18.75 kN; Δ = 1125/EI m
Step-by-step procedure
- Decide whether the frame can sway (unbraced, unsymmetrical stiffness or load, or horizontal load); if not, ψ = 0.
- List unknowns: one rotation per rigid free joint and one sway per storey; use symmetry or antisymmetry to reduce them.
- Write the slope-deflection equation for each member end with ψ = Δ/h for columns; use the reduced form for pinned bases.
- Write the joint equations and one storey shear equation per storey; solve.
- Find end moments, column shears and reactions; check horizontal and vertical equilibrium of the whole frame.
Site notes
- Industrial sheds and portal-framed buildings resist wind sway through the frame action analysed here; base fixity assumed in design must be delivered by the base plate, anchor bolts and foundation.
- A frame that sways under gravity load alone signals unsymmetrical stiffness; bracing bays or shear walls are often added to stop it.
- Pinned bases give much larger sway and larger column-top moments than fixed bases (Example 3 against Example 1); measured sway in a load test helps tell which idealisation fits.
- Cladding, glazing and partitions are sensitive to storey drift, so the sway Δ found here is as important as the moments.
- Leaving out the storey shear equation and treating a sway frame as if its joints only rotate.
- Using different ψ for columns of different heights incorrectly: Δ is common, so ψ = Δ/h differs where h differs.
- Getting the sign of the column shear wrong; write the column free body every time.
- Using antisymmetry (θ_B = θ_C) for a frame that is not symmetric or not under horizontal load only.
- Forgetting the vertical reactions caused by horizontal load (the overturning couple Hh/L for a single bay).
For a single-bay portal with pinned bases under a horizontal load H at beam level, each column carries H/2, the column top moment is Hh/2 whatever the beam stiffness, and the vertical reactions are ±Hh/L. With fixed bases the column moments are smaller and shared between top and base, depending on the beam-to-column stiffness ratio.
Summary
- Sway adds one unknown per storey: Δ, with ψ = Δ/h in every column.
- The extra equation is storey shear equilibrium: Σ −(M_top + M_bottom)/h = H.
- Symmetric frames with symmetric loads do not sway; unsymmetrical ones can sway under gravity load.
- Antisymmetry halves the work for horizontal load on symmetric frames.
- Pinned bases give larger sway and column-top moments than fixed bases.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1How many unknown displacements does a single-bay fixed-base portal frame have in the slope-deflection method, with axially rigid members?
Three: the rotations θ_B and θ_C of the two top joints and one sway Δ.
2In Example 1, if the beam were very much stiffer than the columns, what would the column end moments be?
The joints cannot rotate, each column carries 10 kN and bends in double curvature with equal end moments 10 × 4/2 = 20 kN m at top and base.
3A pinned-base portal with columns 4 m high and a beam 8 m long carries a horizontal load of 40 kN at beam level. Find the column top moments and the reactions.
Column tops 40 × 4/2 = 80 kN m; horizontal reactions 20 kN each; vertical reactions ±40 × 4/8 = ±20 kN.
4A column 5 m high with no load along it has end moments M_AB = −30 kN m and M_BA = −20 kN m. Find its shear.
V = −(−30 − 20)/5 = 10 kN in the positive sway direction.
5A fixed-base portal is symmetric and carries a uniform load on its beam. What is its sway?
Zero: symmetry of frame and load means the joints rotate equally and oppositely and the storey shear equation is satisfied with Δ = 0.
6Repeat Example 1 with a beam 4 m long (columns 4 m, same EI) and a horizontal load of 30 kN. Find the base and column-top moments and the sway.
Joint: θ − 1.5ψ + 1.5θ = 0 gives ψ = 5θ/3; storey: 1.5θ − 3ψ = −60 gives EIθ = 17.14; M_AB = −34.29 kN m, M_BA = −25.71 kN m, beam ends +25.71 kN m; Δ = 114.29/EI m.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.