Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 4 › Lesson 4.4

4.4 Moment distribution for frames

Structural Analysis Chapter 4: Displacement methods Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Apply moment distribution to rigid frames whose joints only rotate (non-sway frames), including columns with fixed bases and beams with pinned far ends.
  • Analyse sway frames by superposition: a non-sway stage with a holding force, and a sway stage with assumed sway moments scaled to cancel the holding force.
  • Use symmetry and antisymmetry to shorten frame distributions, and check the results by the storey shear equation and by statics.

Theory

A rigid frame is analysed by moment distribution exactly like a beam, except that more than two members may meet at a joint and the columns carry moments too. The member stiffness, distribution and carry-over rules of lesson 4.3 apply unchanged: a column with a fixed base has end stiffness 4EI/h and carries half of its balancing moment down to the base. Sign convention for this chapter: a moment acting on the end of a member is positive when it turns clockwise, joint rotations θ are positive clockwise, and the chord rotation ψ = Δ/L is positive when the line joining the two ends of a member turns clockwise. With this rule a negative end moment at the left end of a beam span and a positive end moment at the right end both mean hogging; bending moment diagrams are still drawn with sagging positive.

If the frame cannot sway, because it is braced, symmetric under symmetric load, or held by a support, one distribution gives the answer. If it can sway, the joints also translate, and a single distribution with locked translations would be in error by the effect of that sway. The standard remedy is superposition in two stages. Stage 1: prevent sway with an imaginary horizontal prop, distribute the load moments, and find the prop force R from the storey shear equation. Stage 2: let the frame sway by an arbitrary amount with joint rotations locked, which puts sway fixed-end moments of −6EIΔ/h² on each fixed-ended column (or −3EIΔ/h² at the top of a pinned-base column), distribute these, and find the horizontal force S the sway needs.

Sway frame = no-sway stage + c × sway stageprop RStage 1: no sway+ c ×Δ′Stage 2: sway, force SIndiacon original, not to scale; c = R/S
Figure 4.4: Two-stage moment distribution for a sway frame: distribute with sway prevented, distribute an assumed sway, then add the sway stage scaled by c = R/S. Indiacon original, not to scale.

The real frame has no prop, so the true sway is the Stage 2 result multiplied by the factor c = R/S, chosen so that the prop force disappears. Final moments are Stage 1 + c × Stage 2. Because the sway moments of all columns of a storey come from the same Δ, columns of equal height and equal EI get equal assumed sway moments; for unequal columns the assumed values are in proportion to EI/h².

Symmetry shortens the work. Under symmetric load a symmetric frame does not sway, and the beam's effective stiffness in the distribution is 2EI/L with no carry-over across the axis of symmetry. Under antisymmetric load (horizontal load on a symmetric frame), the joint rotations are equal and the beam's effective stiffness is 6EI/L, again with no carry-over, so a single-bay portal needs only half the frame.

Derivation

  1. Stage 1 (no sway): lock all joint translations, apply the loads, distribute and carry over until converged; compute the column shears V = −(M_top + M_bottom)/h and the prop force R needed for storey equilibrium.
  2. Stage 2 (sway only): give the storey an arbitrary sway Δ' with joint rotations locked. Fixed-ended columns of height h receive −6EIΔ'/h² at both ends; it is convenient to assume a round value such as −100 kN m.
  3. Distribute the Stage 2 moments with the same factors; compute the column shears and the total horizontal force S that this sway requires.
  4. The real structure has no prop: the true sway is c Δ' with c S = R (in the sense that removes the prop), so c = R/S.
  5. Final moments: M = M_Stage1 + c × M_Stage2. The storey shear equation is then satisfied with the actual horizontal load.
  6. This is exactly the slope-deflection solution of lesson 4.2, obtained by superposition of two distributions instead of solving the simultaneous equations directly.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Column end stiffness: 4EI/h (fixed base), 3EI/h (pinned base, no carry-over to the base) (kN m per radian)
  • Beam effective stiffness: 2EI/L (symmetric load), 6EI/L (antisymmetric load), no carry-over in either case
  • Sway fixed-end moments: −6EIΔ/h² at both ends of a fixed-ended column; −3EIΔ/h² at the top of a pinned-base column
  • Column shear: V = −(M_top + M_bottom)/h; storey equation ΣV = H
  • Sway correction: c = R/S; M = M_no-sway + c M_sway
  • Assumed sway moments of columns in one storey in proportion to EI/h² (fixed bases)
Assumptions and limits
  • Linear elastic, small displacements; second-order (P-Δ) effects ignored.
  • Prismatic, axially rigid members, so all column tops of a storey sway by the same Δ.
  • Rigid joints; bases fully fixed or perfectly pinned.
  • Loads applied at joints or along members with known fixed-end moments.
  • Limits: one sway per storey is practical by hand; multi-storey sway frames need one stage per storey and are usually solved by the matrix stiffness method.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Moment distribution for frames is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, analyse building frames elastically and set in their own codes the loads, load combinations, stiffness of cracked members, sway limits and second-order requirements; those values are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (non-sway frame: column and beam meeting at one joint)

Problem. A column AB, 4 m high with flexural rigidity EI and a fixed base A, supports at its top B a beam BC, 6 m long with rigidity 2EI, pinned to a wall at C. The beam carries 24 kN/m. Find the end moments and the reactions.

  1. The pin at C holds the frame against sway. Stiffness at B: k_BA = 4EI/4 = 1.0EI; k_BC = 3(2EI)/6 = 1.0EI (pinned far end). DF_BA = DF_BC = 0.5.
  2. Fixed-end moment of the beam with its far end pinned: FEM_BC = −24 × 36/8 = −108 kN m. Out of balance at B −108 kN m.
  3. Balance +108: +54 to BA and +54 to BC; carry-over +27 to the base A.
  4. Final: M_AB = +27 kN m, M_BA = +54 kN m, M_BC = −54 kN m. The beam has 54 kN m hogging at B; the column bends in double curvature.
  5. Reactions: beam, 6R_C = 432 − 54, R_C = 63 kN and the vertical force at B = 81 kN carried down the column; column shear −(27 + 54)/4 = −20.25 kN, so the base pushes the column towards C with 20.25 kN and the pin at C pulls the beam back with 20.25 kN.

Answer. M_A = 27, M_B = 54 kN m (column), beam hogging 54 kN m at B; vertical reactions 81 and 63 kN; horizontal 20.25 kN

Example 2 (sway frame by the two-stage method)

Problem. Analyse the fixed-base portal of lesson 4.2, Example 1 (columns 4 m, beam 6 m, equal EI, horizontal load 20 kN at B) by moment distribution.

  1. Stage 1 (sway prevented): no member loads, so all moments are zero and the prop carries R = 20 kN.
  2. Stage 2: assume sway moments of −100 kN m at both ends of each column. With antisymmetry the beam's effective stiffness is 6EI/6 = 1.0EI and the column's is 4EI/4 = 1.0EI, so DF = 0.5 each at B and C.
  3. Balance +100 at B: +50 to BA and +50 to BC; carry-over +25 to the base A. Stage 2 moments: M_AB = −75, M_BA = −50, M_BC = +50 kN m (and the same at C and D by antisymmetry).
  4. Stage 2 column shears: −(−75 − 50)/4 = 31.25 kN each, so S = 62.5 kN. Factor c = 20/62.5 = 0.32.
  5. Final: M_AB = −24, M_BA = −16, M_BC = +16 kN m, the same as the slope-deflection result.

Answer. M_A = M_D = −24 kN m, column tops −16 kN m, beam ends +16 kN m

Example 3 (symmetric portal under floor load, no sway)

Problem. A portal frame ABCD has fixed bases, columns 4 m and a beam 6 m, all with the same EI, and the beam carries 20 kN/m. Find the moments and the base reactions.

  1. Symmetric frame and load: no sway. Use half the frame with beam stiffness 2EI/6 = 0.333EI and column stiffness 4EI/4 = 1.0EI: DF_BA = 0.75, DF_BC = 0.25.
  2. FEM_BC = −20 × 36/12 = −60 kN m. Balance +60: +45 to BA, +15 to BC; carry-over +22.5 to A.
  3. Final: M_AB = +22.5, M_BA = +45, M_BC = −45 kN m; by symmetry M_CB = +45, M_CD = −45, M_DC = −22.5 kN m.
  4. Beam: hogging 45 kN m at each end, midspan sagging 20 × 36/8 − 45 = 45 kN m.
  5. Reactions: vertical 60 kN at each base; column shear (22.5 + 45)/4 = 16.88 kN, so the bases push inwards with 16.88 kN each (equal and opposite, no net horizontal force).

Answer. Column base 22.5 kN m, beam ends 45 kN m hogging, midspan 45 kN m sagging; base thrust 16.88 kN

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Check for sway: braced, symmetric under symmetric load, or held by a support means no sway.
  2. Compute stiffnesses, using 2EI/L or 6EI/L for beams where symmetry or antisymmetry is used, and distribution factors at each joint.
  3. Stage 1: distribute the load fixed-end moments with sway prevented; find the holding force R from the storey shear equation.
  4. If the frame sways, Stage 2: assume sway moments in proportion to EI/h², distribute, find S, and scale by c = R/S.
  5. Add the stages, draw the bending moment diagrams, and check joint balance, storey shear and overall equilibrium.

Site notes

  • Portal frames of warehouses and sheds are checked for wind sway with exactly this superposition; the base fixity assumed must match the base plate and foundation details.
  • A beam framing into a stiff column receives less end moment release than one framing into a slender column; changing column sizes changes beam moments.
  • Base thrust of portal frames under floor or roof load (Example 3) must be resisted by the foundation or a tie at floor level.
  • Computer frame models should reproduce a hand distribution of one bay; a large difference usually means a wrong release or support code in the model.
Common mistakes
  • Ignoring sway in an unsymmetrical frame because the load is vertical.
  • Assuming equal sway moments for columns of different heights instead of in proportion to EI/h².
  • Carrying over across the axis of symmetry when using the 2EI/L or 6EI/L beam stiffness.
  • Forgetting the moment carried down to a fixed base, or carrying over to a pinned base.
  • Scaling the wrong stage: only the sway stage is multiplied by c.
Quick check

For a single-bay symmetric portal, symmetric load needs only half the frame with beam stiffness 2EI/L, and horizontal load needs only half the frame with beam stiffness 6EI/L; one balance at the top joint then gives exact moments, and the two cases can be added for any load.

Summary

  • Frames are distributed like beams, with columns as extra members at each joint.
  • Non-sway frames need one distribution.
  • Sway frames: Stage 1 with a prop, Stage 2 with assumed sway moments, combine with c = R/S.
  • Symmetry (2EI/L) and antisymmetry (6EI/L) halve the work.
  • Check joint balance, storey shear and overall equilibrium.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Repeat Example 1 with a column 3 m high (same EI). Find the moments.

k_BA = 4EI/3 = 1.333EI, k_BC = 1.0EI; DF_BA = 0.571, DF_BC = 0.429. M_BA = 0.571 × 108 = 61.71 kN m, M_BC = −61.71 kN m, M_AB = 30.86 kN m.

2A symmetric two-column frame carries a symmetric roof load. Does the two-stage sway method need Stage 2?

No: with symmetric frame and load the prop force R from Stage 1 is zero, so c = 0 and there is no sway.

3In a sway analysis the Stage 1 prop force is 12 kN and the Stage 2 sway moments (−100 kN m assumed) need 40 kN. Find the factor and the final moment at a column top whose Stage 1 and Stage 2 values are +18 and −60 kN m.

c = 12/40 = 0.3; final moment 18 + 0.3 × (−60) = 0 kN m.

4Repeat Example 3 with a beam load of 30 kN/m.

All moments scale by 1.5: beam ends 67.5 kN m hogging, column bases 33.75 kN m, midspan 67.5 kN m sagging.

5Repeat Example 2 with a horizontal load of 30 kN.

c = 30/62.5 = 0.48: base moments −36 kN m, column tops −24 kN m, beam ends +24 kN m.

6A pinned-base portal (columns 5 m, beam 8 m, equal EI) carries 30 kN horizontally at beam level. Using column stiffness 3EI/5 and antisymmetric beam stiffness 6EI/8, assume −100 kN m at the column tops and find the final column-top moment.

DF column 0.6/1.35 = 0.444, beam 0.556; balance +100 gives column top −55.56 kN m; shears 11.11 kN each, S = 22.22 kN; c = 30/22.22 = 1.35; final column top −75 kN m (beam ends +75 kN m), matching lesson 4.2.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.