Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 4 › Lesson 4.5

4.5 Introduction to Kani's method

Structural Analysis Chapter 4: Displacement methods Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Derive Kani's iteration from the slope-deflection equation: final moment M_ij = M_Fij + 2M′_ij + M′_ji, with rotation contributions M′_ij found by rotation factors u_ij = −½ k_ij/Σk.
  • Carry out Kani iterations for continuous beams and non-sway frames, including a pinned far end with reduced stiffness.
  • State the displacement factor and storey moment used for sway frames, and see why Kani's method corrects its own arithmetic slips.

Theory

Kani's method, published by Gaspar Kani in the late 1940s, is a third way of solving the slope-deflection equations. Like moment distribution it is iterative, but instead of distributing moments and carrying them over, it iterates directly on the rotation contribution of each joint. A slip in arithmetic is corrected automatically in later cycles, because each new cycle starts from the fixed-end moments and the latest contributions rather than from the previous totals. Sign convention for this chapter: a moment acting on the end of a member is positive when it turns clockwise, joint rotations θ are positive clockwise, and the chord rotation ψ = Δ/L is positive when the line joining the two ends of a member turns clockwise. With this rule a negative end moment at the left end of a beam span and a positive end moment at the right end both mean hogging; bending moment diagrams are still drawn with sagging positive.

Write the slope-deflection equation without sway as M_ij = M_Fij + (2EI/L)(2θ_i + θ_j). Define the rotation contribution of end i of member ij as M′_ij = 2EIθ_i/L = 2E k_ij θ_i, where k_ij = I/L is the relative stiffness. Then M_ij = M_Fij + 2M′_ij + M′_ji: the final moment is the fixed-end moment, plus twice the near-end rotation contribution, plus the far-end contribution.

Kani: rotation factors and final momentk₁ = I₁/L₁k₂ = I₂/L₂k₃ = I₃/hiu = −½ k/Σk; M = M_F + 2M′_near + M′_farIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 4.5: Kani's method: each member at a joint gets a rotation factor u = −½ k/Σk, and every final end moment is the fixed-end moment plus twice the near-end and once the far-end rotation contribution. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Joint i is in equilibrium when Σ_j M_ij = 0. Substituting gives 2Σ_j M′_ij = −(M_Fi + Σ_j M′_ji), where M_Fi = Σ_j M_Fij is the sum of fixed-end moments at the joint. Because every M′_ij at joint i is proportional to k_ij (they share the same θ_i), M′_ij = u_ij (M_Fi + Σ_j M′_ji) with the rotation factor u_ij = −½ k_ij/Σk_i. The rotation factors at a joint add up to −½. Starting from zero and repeatedly applying this formula at each joint converges to the exact rotation contributions.

A pinned far end is handled by using ¾k for that member and the pinned-end fixed-end moment, and leaving that end out of the iteration. Sway frames need one more ingredient: the displacement contribution M″ of each column, iterated with a displacement factor u″_ij = −(3/2) k_ij/Σk over the columns of the storey and the storey moment Q h/3. This lesson shows the formulas and checks them against lesson 4.2; the full multi-storey procedure belongs with the matrix methods of later chapters.

Derivation

  1. Slope-deflection without sway: M_ij = M_Fij + (2EI/L)(2θ_i + θ_j).
  2. Define M′_ij = 2EIθ_i/L (rotation contribution of end i) so that M_ij = M_Fij + 2M′_ij + M′_ji.
  3. Joint equilibrium Σ_j M_ij = 0 gives 2Σ_j M′_ij = −(M_Fi + Σ_j M′_ji).
  4. Since M′_ij = 2Eθ_i k_ij with k_ij = I/L, Σ_j M′_ij = 2Eθ_i Σk_i, so M′_ij = (k_ij/Σk_i) Σ_j M′_ij = −½ (k_ij/Σk_i)(M_Fi + Σ_j M′_ji).
  5. Rotation factor u_ij = −½ k_ij/Σk_i; at a fixed support M′ = 0; for a pinned far end use ¾k and the pinned-end fixed-end moment and omit that end.
  6. With sway, add M″_ij = u″_ij [Q h/3 + Σ(M′_ij + M′_ji)] over the storey columns, u″_ij = −(3/2) k_ij/Σk_storey, include M″ in the joint bracket, and take M_ij = M_Fij + 2M′_ij + M′_ji + M″_ij (equal column heights, Q = storey shear in the sway direction).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Final moment (no sway): M_ij = M_Fij + 2M′_ij + M′_ji (kN m)
  • Rotation factor: u_ij = −½ k_ij/Σk_i, with k = I/L; Σu at a joint = −½
  • Iteration: M′_ij = u_ij (M_Fi + Σ_j M′_ji), M_Fi = sum of fixed-end moments at joint i
  • Pinned far end: use ¾k and the pinned-end fixed-end moment; that end is not iterated
  • Sway: displacement factor u″_ij = −(3/2) k_ij/Σk (storey columns), storey moment Q h/3, M″_ij = u″_ij [Q h/3 + Σ(M′_ij + M′_ji)]
  • Final moment with sway: M_ij = M_Fij + 2M′_ij + M′_ji + M″_ij
Assumptions and limits
  • Linear elastic, small displacements; the method solves exactly the slope-deflection equations.
  • Prismatic members; relative stiffness k = I/L (E constant).
  • Rigid joints; fixed supports have zero rotation contribution.
  • Sway formulas shown for a storey whose columns have equal height and no loads along them.
  • Limits: convergence is reliable for ordinary beams and frames; it slows where very stiff and very flexible members meet. For many unknowns or unequal storey heights, the matrix stiffness method is preferred.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Kani's method is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, accept any elastic analysis that satisfies equilibrium and compatibility; Kani's method is taught widely in Indian and European courses, while American texts usually present slope-deflection, moment distribution and matrix methods. Design values are set in each practice's own codes and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (one joint, pinned far end)

Problem. Solve the beam of lesson 4.3, Example 2 by Kani's method: A fixed, AB = 4 m (I) with a central 50 kN load, BC = 6 m (2I) with 15 kN/m, C pinned.

  1. Relative stiffness: k_BA = I/4 = 0.25I; k_BC = ¾ × 2I/6 = 0.25I (pinned far end). Σk = 0.5I, so u_BA = u_BC = −0.25.
  2. Fixed-end moments: M_FAB = −25, M_FBA = +25, M_FBC (pinned far end) = −67.5 kN m. M_FB = 25 − 67.5 = −42.5 kN m.
  3. Rotation contributions (A fixed, so M′_AB = 0; C not iterated): M′_BA = M′_BC = −0.25 × (−42.5) = +10.63 kN m. One cycle is exact because there is only one free joint.
  4. Final: M_AB = −25 + 0 + 10.63 = −14.38 kN m; M_BA = 25 + 2 × 10.63 + 0 = +46.25 kN m; M_BC = −67.5 + 2 × 10.63 = −46.25 kN m.
  5. Same as moment distribution and slope-deflection: −14.38 kN m at A and −46.25 kN m at B (hogging).

Answer. M_A = −14.38 kN m, M_B = −46.25 kN m

Example 2 (three-span beam with two free joints)

Problem. A beam ABCD has three spans of 6 m, fixed at A and D and on rollers at B and C; EI constant. Span AB carries 20 kN/m, span BC a central load of 60 kN, span CD no load. Find the moments by Kani's method.

  1. k = I/6 for every span; at B and at C Σk = 2I/6, so every rotation factor is −0.25.
  2. Fixed-end moments: M_FAB = −60, M_FBA = +60, M_FBC = −45, M_FCB = +45 kN m. M_FB = 15, M_FC = 45 kN m.
  3. Cycle 1: M′_B = −0.25(15 + 0) = −3.75; M′_C = −0.25(45 − 3.75) = −10.31. Cycle 2: M′_B = −0.25(15 − 10.31) = −1.17; M′_C = −0.25(45 − 1.17) = −10.96. Cycle 3: −1.01 and −11.00. Cycle 4: −1.00 and −11.00 (converged).
  4. Final: M_AB = −60 + 0 − 1 = −61; M_BA = 60 − 2 + 0 = +58; M_BC = −45 − 2 − 11 = −58; M_CB = 45 − 22 − 1 = +22; M_CD = 0 − 22 + 0 = −22; M_DC = 0 + 0 − 11 = −11 kN m.
  5. Reactions: 6R_A = 360 + 61 − 58, R_A = 60.5 kN; R_D = −(22 + 11)/6 = −5.5 kN (hold-down); R_B = 95.5 kN, R_C = 29.5 kN by statics. Total 180 kN = the load.

Answer. M_A = −61, M_B = −58, M_C = −22, M_D = +11 kN m (bending moments); R_D = −5.5 kN

Example 3 (fixed-base portal under floor load)

Problem. Solve the portal of lesson 4.4, Example 3 (columns 4 m, beam 6 m, equal EI, 20 kN/m on the beam) by Kani's method, iterating both joints.

  1. Relative stiffness: columns I/4 = 0.25I, beam I/6 = 0.1667I; Σk = 0.4167I at B and at C. Rotation factors u_column = −0.3, u_beam = −0.2.
  2. M_FB = −60, M_FC = +60 kN m. The frame is symmetric under symmetric load, so it does not sway and M″ = 0.
  3. Cycle 1: at B, M′_BA = −0.3 × (−60) = 18.0, M′_BC = 12.0; at C, bracket 60 + 12 = 72, M′_CB = −14.4, M′_CD = −21.6. Cycle 2: at B, bracket −60 − 14.4, M′_BA = 22.32, M′_BC = 14.88; at C, M′_CB = −14.98, M′_CD = −22.46. Converged: M′_BA = 22.5, M′_BC = 15, M′_CB = −15, M′_CD = −22.5.
  4. Final: M_AB = 0 + 0 + 22.5 = +22.5; M_BA = 0 + 45 + 0 = +45; M_BC = −60 + 30 − 15 = −45; M_CB = +45, M_CD = −45, M_DC = −22.5 kN m.
  5. Same as lesson 4.4: beam ends 45 kN m hogging, column bases 22.5 kN m.

Answer. Beam ends −45 kN m, column bases 22.5 kN m, as by moment distribution

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Compute relative stiffnesses k = I/L (¾k for a pinned far end) and rotation factors u = −½ k/Σk at each free joint; check Σu = −½.
  2. Compute fixed-end moments and their sum M_F at each joint.
  3. Iterate joint by joint: M′_ij = u_ij (M_Fi + Σ far-end M′ (+ M″ if sway)), always using the latest values.
  4. Stop when two successive cycles agree to the precision needed.
  5. Final moments M_ij = M_Fij + 2M′_ij + M′_ji (+ M″_ij); check joint balance and statics.

Site notes

  • Kani tables are compact and self-correcting, which made them popular for hand analysis of multi-bay building frames before computers.
  • For design-office checks, Kani's method on a single bay of a frame gives a quick independent comparison with frame software.
  • Because errors wash out in later cycles, an iteration that will not converge usually signals a wrong rotation factor or a wrong fixed-end moment, not an arithmetic slip.
  • The method works in relative stiffness I/L, so a consistent unit for I is all that is needed.
Common mistakes
  • Using the old cycle's values instead of the latest values when they are available.
  • Forgetting the factor 2 on the near-end contribution in the final moment.
  • Rotation factors that do not add up to −½ at a joint.
  • Iterating a pinned far end instead of using ¾k and the pinned-end fixed-end moment.
  • Ignoring sway in an unsymmetrical frame.
Quick check

Kani's final moment is always 'fixed-end moment + twice the near-end contribution + the far-end contribution'. At a joint with two equal members and fixed far ends each rotation factor is −0.25; with a column and a beam the larger stiffness takes the larger share.

Summary

  • Kani's method iterates the rotation contributions M′ of the slope-deflection equations.
  • Rotation factor u = −½ k/Σk; iteration M′ = u (M_F + Σ far-end M′).
  • Final moment M_F + 2M′_near + M′_far.
  • Self-correcting; converges to the slope-deflection solution.
  • Sway adds displacement contributions with factor −(3/2) k/Σk and storey moment Qh/3.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Two members meet at joint B, each with relative stiffness 0.25I and fixed far ends. Find the rotation factors.

u = −½ × 0.25/0.5 = −0.25 each; the sum is −0.5.

2Three members meet at a joint with relative stiffnesses 1, 2 and 2 (units of I/L). Find the rotation factors.

Σk = 5: u = −0.1, −0.2 and −0.2 (sum −0.5).

3A final Kani moment is needed for a member end with M_F = −20 kN m, M′_near = 6 kN m and M′_far = −4 kN m. Find it.

M = −20 + 2 × 6 − 4 = −12 kN m.

4Solve a propped cantilever AB (A fixed, B pinned; 6 m; 20 kN/m) by Kani's method, treating B as a joint with one member.

u_BA = −½; M_FB = +60; M′_BA = −30; M_BA = 60 − 60 + 0 = 0; M_AB = −60 + 0 − 30 = −90 kN m = −wL²/8.

5Repeat Example 3 with a beam load of 30 kN/m. Give the converged M′_BA, M′_BC and the final moments at B and A.

Contributions scale by 1.5: M′_BA = 33.75, M′_BC = 22.5 kN m; M_BA = 67.5 kN m, M_BC = −67.5 kN m, M_AB = 33.75 kN m.

6For the fixed-base portal of lesson 4.2, Example 1 (columns 4 m, beam 6 m, equal I, Q = 20 kN), find the displacement factors and the storey moment, and state the converged result of Kani's iteration.

u″ = −(3/2) × 0.25/0.5 = −0.75 for each column; storey moment Qh/3 = 26.67 kN m; the iteration converges to M_AB = −24 kN m, M_BA = −16 kN m and beam ends +16 kN m, as in lesson 4.2.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.