Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 4 › Lesson 4.3

4.3 Moment distribution for beams

Structural Analysis Chapter 4: Displacement methods Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Explain moment distribution (Hardy Cross) as an iterative way of solving the slope-deflection joint equations: lock, unbalance, distribute, carry over.
  • Compute member stiffness (4EI/L, or 3EI/L with a pinned far end), distribution factors and carry-over factors, and use symmetry to shorten the work.
  • Analyse continuous beams with point loads, uniform loads and support settlement, and check the results by statics and an independent stiffness solution.

Theory

Moment distribution solves the same equations as the slope-deflection method but never writes them down. All joints are first locked against rotation, so every loaded span carries its fixed-end moments. The locked joints are then released one at a time: the out-of-balance moment at a released joint is shared among the members meeting there in proportion to their stiffness, and half of each share is carried over to the far end of the member. Repeating the cycle converges to the exact answer. Sign convention for this chapter: a moment acting on the end of a member is positive when it turns clockwise, joint rotations θ are positive clockwise, and the chord rotation ψ = Δ/L is positive when the line joining the two ends of a member turns clockwise. With this rule a negative end moment at the left end of a beam span and a positive end moment at the right end both mean hogging; bending moment diagrams are still drawn with sagging positive.

The stiffness of a member end is the moment needed to rotate it by one radian: 4EI/L if the far end is fixed (or locked), and 3EI/L if the far end is a pin that stays free. At a joint where members with stiffnesses k_1, k_2 and k_3 meet, an out-of-balance moment U is resisted by all of them rotating together by the same angle, so member i takes the share −U k_i/Σk. The ratio DF_i = k_i/Σk is the distribution factor; the factors at a joint add up to one. A fixed support has a distribution factor of zero, and a free pinned end has one.

Moment distribution: lock, balance, carry overABCk = 4EI/Lk = 3EI/LDF0.5 | 0.5FEM−25+25 | −67.5Bal+21.25 | +21.25½no carry-over to pinIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 4.3: Moment distribution at one joint: distribution factors from stiffness, balancing of the out-of-balance moment and a half carry-over to the fixed end. Indiacon original, not to scale.

When the near end of a member with a fixed far end is rotated, the far end develops half the near-end moment in the same sense: the carry-over factor is ½. A member whose far end is a pin carries nothing over, which is why its reduced stiffness 3EI/L is used once the pin has been released and its moment set to zero. For a centre span that is symmetric in shape and load, the two ends rotate equally and oppositely, and its effective stiffness is 2EI/L with no carry-over; for antisymmetric rotation it is 6EI/L.

Moment distribution was the everyday method of analysing continuous beams and frames by hand for decades, because each step is simple arithmetic laid out in a table. It still matters: it gives a feel for how stiffness attracts moment, it is a fast check of computer output, and with a pinned end or symmetry a one-joint problem is exact after a single balance. Support settlement is included by starting from the settlement fixed-end moments of lesson 3.4 (−6EIΔ/L² for a span fixed at both ends, 3EIΔ/L² for one with a pinned far end, with the sign set by the chord rotation).

Derivation

  1. Lock every free joint. Each loaded span carries its fixed-end moments FEM (clockwise positive). Settlement adds −6EIψ/L at both ends of a fixed-fixed span or −3EIψ/L at the fixed end of a span with a pinned far end.
  2. Unlock one joint. Its out-of-balance moment is U = Σ FEM at the joint (minus any applied clockwise joint moment). The joint rotates by θ = −U/Σk, where Σk is the sum of the end stiffnesses of the members meeting there.
  3. Member i receives the balancing moment k_iθ = −U × DF_i, with DF_i = k_i/Σk.
  4. Each balancing moment sends half of itself to the far end of its member if that end is locked (carry-over factor ½); a free pinned far end receives nothing.
  5. Lock the joint again and unlock the next one; repeat until the carried-over moments are negligible. The final end moment at each member end is the sum of its column in the table.
  6. The converged moments satisfy the same joint equilibrium and compatibility as the slope-deflection solution, so the two methods give identical results.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • End stiffness: k = 4EI/L (far end fixed), k = 3EI/L (far end pinned), k = 2EI/L (symmetric centre span), k = 6EI/L (antisymmetric centre span) (kN m per radian)
  • Distribution factor: DF_i = k_i/Σk at the joint; ΣDF = 1; fixed end DF = 0; free pin DF = 1
  • Carry-over factor: ½ towards a fixed or locked far end, 0 towards a free pin
  • Balancing moment: −DF_i × (out-of-balance moment)
  • Fixed-end moments for a span with a pinned far end: uniform load −wL²/8 at the fixed end (clockwise sense, from FEM_AB − FEM_BA/2); central point load −3PL/16
  • Settlement fixed-end moments: −6EIΔ/L² (both ends, fixed-fixed span, chord turning clockwise); −3EIΔ/L² (fixed end of a span with a pinned far end)
Assumptions and limits
  • Linear elastic, small deflections; superposition holds.
  • Prismatic members with constant EI (non-prismatic members need their own stiffness and carry-over factors).
  • Joints rigid; supports unyielding unless a known settlement is included through settlement fixed-end moments.
  • No sway in this lesson (beams on vertical supports); sway frames are treated in lesson 4.4.
  • Limits: convergence slows when stiff and flexible members meet; stop when carry-over moments are below about one per cent of the largest moment, or use the slope-deflection or matrix method for an exact answer.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Moment distribution is a result of mechanics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, accept elastic analysis of continuous beams by any method that satisfies equilibrium and compatibility; pattern loading, redistribution of moments and moment coefficients are set in each practice's own codes and are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (three-span road-bridge deck beam, symmetric)

Problem. A continuous beam ABCD has spans 5 m, 6 m and 5 m on simple supports and carries 18 kN/m throughout. EI is constant. Find the support moments and reactions.

  1. Use symmetry: the end spans have pinned far ends (k = 3EI/5 = 0.6EI) and the symmetric centre span has k = 2EI/6 = 0.333EI with no carry-over.
  2. Distribution factors at B: DF_BA = 0.6/0.933 = 0.643, DF_BC = 0.357.
  3. Fixed-end moments (pinned far end for AB): FEM_BA = +18 × 25/8 = +56.25 kN m; FEM_BC = −18 × 36/12 = −54 kN m. Out of balance +2.25 kN m.
  4. Balance −2.25: BA gets −1.45, BC gets −0.80. Final M_BA = +54.80 kN m, M_BC = −54.80 kN m, exact in one step. By symmetry M_C = M_B.
  5. Reactions: R_A = 45 − 54.80/5 = 34.04 kN; R_B = (45 + 10.96) + 54 = 109.96 kN; R_C = 109.96 kN, R_D = 34.04 kN. Check: total 288 kN = 18 × 16.

Answer. M_B = M_C = −54.80 kN m (hogging); R_A = R_D = 34.04 kN, R_B = R_C = 109.96 kN

Example 2 (beam with a fixed end and unequal stiffness)

Problem. A beam ABC is fixed at A and pinned at C, with a roller at B. Span AB = 4 m (second moment I) carries a central point load of 50 kN; span BC = 6 m (second moment 2I) carries 15 kN/m. Find the moments and reactions.

  1. Stiffness at B: k_BA = 4EI/4 = 1.0EI; k_BC = 3E(2I)/6 = 1.0EI (pinned far end). DF_BA = DF_BC = 0.5.
  2. Fixed-end moments: FEM_AB = −50 × 4/8 = −25, FEM_BA = +25 kN m; FEM_BC (pinned far end) = −15 × 36/8 = −67.5 kN m. Out of balance at B: 25 − 67.5 = −42.5 kN m.
  3. Balance +42.5: +21.25 to BA and +21.25 to BC. Carry-over ½ × 21.25 = 10.63 to A; nothing to the pin C.
  4. Final: M_AB = −25 + 10.63 = −14.38 kN m; M_BA = 25 + 21.25 = +46.25 kN m; M_BC = −67.5 + 21.25 = −46.25 kN m. Bending moments: −14.38 kN m at A and −46.25 kN m at B (hogging).
  5. Reactions: 4R_A = 100 + 14.38 − 46.25, R_A = 17.03 kN; 6R_C = 270 − 46.25, R_C = 37.29 kN; R_B = 140 − 17.03 − 37.29 = 85.68 kN.

Answer. M_A = −14.38 kN m, M_B = −46.25 kN m; R_A = 17.03, R_B = 85.68, R_C = 37.29 kN

Example 3 (settlement of an interior support)

Problem. A two-span beam ABC (6 m + 6 m) is fixed at A and pinned at C, with B on a roller; EI = 3 × 10⁴ kN m². No load acts, but B settles 12 mm. Find the moments and reactions.

  1. Settlement fixed-end moments: span AB (fixed-fixed, chord clockwise): −6EIΔ/L² = −6 × 3 × 10⁴ × 0.012/36 = −60 kN m at A and at B. Span BC (pinned far end, chord anticlockwise): +3EIΔ/L² = +30 kN m at B.
  2. Stiffness: k_BA = 4EI/6, k_BC = 3EI/6, so DF_BA = 4/7 = 0.571, DF_BC = 3/7 = 0.429.
  3. Out of balance at B: −60 + 30 = −30 kN m. Balance +30: +17.14 to BA, +12.86 to BC; carry-over +8.57 to A.
  4. Final: M_AB = −60 + 8.57 = −51.43 kN m; M_BA = −60 + 17.14 = −42.86 kN m; M_BC = +42.86 kN m. Bending moment at A −51.43 kN m (hogging), at B +42.86 kN m (sagging).
  5. Reactions: 6R_A = 51.43 + 42.86, R_A = 15.71 kN; 6R_C = 42.86, R_C = 7.14 kN; R_B = −22.86 kN. The settling support loses 22.86 kN of reaction, shared by its neighbours.

Answer. M_A = −51.43 kN m, M_B = +42.86 kN m; R_A = 15.71, R_B = −22.86, R_C = 7.14 kN

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Compute the end stiffnesses (4EI/L, 3EI/L for a pinned far end, 2EI/L or 6EI/L for symmetric or antisymmetric centre spans) and the distribution factors at each joint.
  2. Compute the fixed-end moments of all loads and any settlement (clockwise positive).
  3. Release the joints in turn: balance the out-of-balance moment by the distribution factors and carry half over to locked far ends.
  4. Repeat until the carry-overs are negligible; add each column for the final end moments.
  5. Convert to sagging-positive bending moments, find reactions by statics, and check that they add up to the total load.

Site notes

  • Moment coefficients printed in design aids for continuous beams and slabs come from analyses like these, with pattern loading.
  • A quick one-cycle distribution is a good site-office check when a beam's support condition changes, for example when a column is removed or a new support is added.
  • Settling interior columns reduce their own reaction and increase the neighbours', as Example 3 shows; this matters for raft and isolated footings on variable soil.
  • Stiff members attract moment: a deeper beam or a stiffer column at a joint takes a larger share.
Common mistakes
  • Using 4EI/L for a member whose far end is a free pin, then also carrying over to it.
  • Distribution factors at a joint that do not add up to one.
  • Forgetting to reverse the sign when balancing (the balancing moment is minus the out-of-balance times DF).
  • Carrying over to a pinned end or carrying over a fixed-end moment instead of a balancing moment.
  • Mixing the clockwise end-moment sign with sagging-positive bending moments in the final diagram.
Quick check

At a joint with one unknown rotation, moment distribution with reduced stiffness 3EI/L for pinned far ends and 2EI/L for symmetric spans is exact after one balance and one carry-over; iteration is needed only when two or more neighbouring joints are both free to rotate.

Summary

  • Lock, compute fixed-end moments, unlock, distribute by DF = k/Σk, carry over half, repeat.
  • Stiffness 4EI/L (far end fixed), 3EI/L (far end pinned), 2EI/L symmetric span.
  • The converged result equals the slope-deflection solution.
  • Settlement enters through settlement fixed-end moments.
  • Check every answer by statics.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1At joint B, member BA is 4 m long with EI and its far end fixed; member BC is 6 m long with 2EI and its far end pinned. Find the distribution factors.

k_BA = 4EI/4 = 1.0EI, k_BC = 3(2EI)/6 = 1.0EI, so DF_BA = DF_BC = 0.5.

2Use moment distribution to find the fixed-end moment of a propped cantilever AB (fixed at A, propped at B), span 6 m, 20 kN/m.

FEM_AB = −60, FEM_BA = +60. Release B (DF = 1): −60 at B, carry-over −30 to A. M_AB = −90 kN m = −wL²/8.

3A beam has two equal spans of 5 m, both ends pinned, and carries 16 kN/m. Find the moment over the middle support.

Pinned-far-end FEMs ±16 × 25/8 = ±50 kN m balance at B, so M_B = −50 kN m (hogging).

4A moment of 30 kN m is applied at the pinned end B of a member whose far end A is fixed. What moment develops at A?

Carry-over ½: 15 kN m at A, in the same rotational sense.

5Repeat Example 2 without the 50 kN load. Find the moments at A and B and the reaction at A.

Out of balance −67.5; +33.75 to each side; carry-over +16.88 to A. M_A = +16.88 kN m (sagging), M_B = −33.75 kN m; R_A = (−16.88 − 33.75)/4 = −12.66 kN (downward).

6A beam has spans 6 m and 4 m, both ends pinned, EI constant, and carries 12 kN/m throughout. Find the moment over the middle support.

k_BA = 3EI/6 = 0.5EI, k_BC = 3EI/4 = 0.75EI; DF 0.4 and 0.6. FEMs +54 and −24 kN m; out of balance +30; M_BA = 54 − 12 = 42 kN m, so M_B = −42 kN m.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.