1.1 Structural forms and idealisation
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Name the main structural forms (beams, trusses, rigid frames, arches, cables, plates and shells) and say how each one carries load.
- Replace a real structure by an analysis model: members as lines on their centroidal axes, joints as pins or rigid connections, and supports as rollers, pins, guided supports or fixed supports.
- Turn floor and roof loads into member loads by tributary width and panel-point loads, and judge how the choice of idealisation changes the forces found.
Theory
Structural analysis finds the forces, moments and movements inside a structure under its loads, so that each member can then be designed. It sits between strength of materials, which studies a single member, and design, which sizes the members. Sign convention for this chapter: global x is to the right and y upward; forces and reactions are positive in the +x and +y directions, moments and rotations positive anticlockwise; axial force in a member is positive in tension; beam bending moment is positive when it causes sagging, as in strength of materials.
Structures are grouped by how they carry load. A beam carries transverse load by bending and shear. A truss is a triangulated set of straight members joined at their ends; with loads applied at the joints its members carry mainly axial tension or compression. A rigid frame (portal, multi-storey building frame) has members joined so that the angle between them stays fixed, and its members carry bending, shear and axial force together. An arch carries load mainly by compression along its curved axis, and a cable mainly by tension along its sagging shape. Slabs, plates and shells spread load in two directions and are often analysed as strips or grillages of beams.
Analysis never works on the real structure; it works on a model. The model keeps the features that control the answer and drops the rest. Members become lines along their centroidal axes, with the span measured between support centres. Joints become either pins, which pass force but no moment, or rigid joints, which pass force and moment. Supports are idealised by the movements they prevent: a roller prevents movement in one direction (1 reaction), a pin prevents both translations (2 reactions), a guided or sliding fixed support prevents rotation and one translation (2 reactions), and a fixed support prevents both translations and rotation (3 reactions).
Loads are idealised too. A slab load in kN/m² becomes a line load on a beam equal to the load intensity times the tributary width the beam carries; roof load on a truss is collected by purlins and applied as point loads at the panel points, with half a panel load at each end joint. The same building can need different models for different questions, so the choice must be stated and checked: a beam that is really built into its supports lies somewhere between simply supported and fully fixed, and the bending moments of the two models differ a lot. A good engineer brackets the answer between the two limits when the real restraint is uncertain.
Derivation
- Line-element model: a prismatic member is replaced by its centroidal axis because, for a slender member, the stress resultants (axial force N, shear V and moment M) on a cross-section fully describe the internal force, and the section dimensions enter only through A and I.
- Tributary load: a one-way slab of intensity q (kN/m²) spanning between parallel beams at spacing s sends half of each adjacent panel to each beam, so an interior beam carries w = q(s/2 + s/2) = q s (kN/m), plus its own weight.
- Panel-point loads: a roof truss at spacing S carrying load q on plan with panel length a receives at each interior node P = q S a and at each end node P/2, so the total is q S × (n a) for n panels, the full roof load on the truss's share of the roof.
- Support idealisation: each restrained displacement gives one reaction component, so roller 1, pin 2, guided (slider with fixed rotation) 2 and fixed support 3; a free displacement gives no reaction.
- Effect of end idealisation on a beam under uniform load w over span L: simply supported gives M_mid = wL²/8; fully fixed gives support moments wL²/12 (hogging) and midspan wL²/24; the real built-in beam lies between these two limits.
- Effect of a restrained support on temperature: a member free to expand changes length by ΔL = αΔT L with no force; if both ends are pinned to rigid supports the strain αΔT is suppressed, giving σ = EαΔT and an axial force F = EAαΔT. This is why bridges and long buildings have a free (roller or sliding) bearing at one end.
Tributary line load on an interior beam w = q s (q in kN/m², s spacing in m, w in kN/m)Panel-point load on a truss P = q S a at interior nodes, P/2 at end nodes (S truss spacing, a panel length, m)Reaction components: roller 1, pin 2, guided support 2, fixed support 3Uniform load w on span L: simply supported M_mid = wL²/8; fixed-fixed M_support = wL²/12 (hogging), M_mid = wL²/24Free thermal movement ΔL = αΔT L; fully restrained force F = EAαΔTUnits: w in kN/m, L in m, M in kN m, E in N/mm², A in mm², α in 1/°C, ΔT in °C
- Members are slender, so a line model on the centroidal axis is adequate; deep beams, short brackets and walls need two-dimensional models instead.
- Truss joints are idealised as frictionless pins and loads act only at joints; the real gusseted or welded joints cause small secondary bending moments that the model ignores.
- Supports are ideal: a roller is frictionless and a fixed support is perfectly rigid; real bearings, foundations and soils are partly flexible.
- Loads are static, applied slowly, and taken as point, uniform or linearly varying idealisations of the real distribution.
- Limits: the idealisation is only as good as its weakest assumption; where restraint is uncertain (built-in ends, flexible foundations, semi-rigid steel connections) analyse both limiting models or model the stiffness directly.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- Structural forms and idealisation are matters of mechanics and modelling judgement; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
- Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, all allow members to be modelled as lines on their centroidal axes with idealised supports and joints, and all ask the designer to choose support and joint models that reflect the real stiffness; the loads themselves come from each practice's own loading code and are not reproduced here.
Worked examples
Problem. An interior floor beam of a building spans 6 m between column centres. One-way slabs on both sides span between parallel beams at 3.5 m centres. The slab carries a dead load of 4.5 kN/m² and an imposed load of 3.0 kN/m². The beam web is 300 mm wide and 500 mm deep with concrete at 25 kN/m³. Find the line load and the bending moments if the beam is idealised (a) as simply supported and (b) as fixed at both ends.
- Slab load q = 4.5 + 3.0 = 7.5 kN/m²; tributary width = 3.5 m, so slab load on the beam = 7.5 × 3.5 = 26.25 kN/m.
- Self-weight of the web = 0.3 × 0.5 × 25 = 3.75 kN/m; total w = 26.25 + 3.75 = 30.0 kN/m.
- (a) Simply supported: reactions wL/2 = 30 × 6/2 = 90 kN; M_mid = wL²/8 = 30 × 36/8 = 135 kN m (sagging).
- (b) Fixed at both ends: M_support = wL²/12 = 30 × 36/12 = 90 kN m (hogging), M_mid = wL²/24 = 45 kN m (sagging).
- The free bending moment wL²/8 = 135 kN m is the same in both models (90 + 45 = 135); only its split between support and midspan changes, which is why the end idealisation must be justified.
Answer. w = 30.0 kN/m; simply supported 135 kN m at midspan; fixed ends 90 kN m hogging at supports and 45 kN m at midspan
Problem. Steel roof trusses of 12 m span are spaced at 5 m centres and have six equal panels of 2 m on plan. The roof load, including sheeting, purlins and the truss share of services, is 1.2 kN/m² on plan, and the purlins sit exactly at the panel points. Find the panel-point loads and the support reactions.
- Interior panel-point load P = q S a = 1.2 × 5 × 2 = 12 kN.
- End nodes carry half a panel: 6 kN each.
- There are five interior nodes: total = 5 × 12 + 2 × 6 = 72 kN.
- Check against the roof area: 1.2 × 5 × 12 = 72 kN; the loads agree.
- By symmetry each support reaction = 72/2 = 36 kN; the end-node loads of 6 kN go straight into the supports, so the truss members carry the remaining load to them.
Answer. Interior panel loads 12 kN, end nodes 6 kN, total 72 kN, reactions 36 kN each
Problem. A steel footbridge girder spans 30 m. Its effective area for axial force is 8000 mm², E = 200 000 N/mm² and α = 12 × 10⁻⁶ per °C. The design temperature rise is 40 °C. Find the movement if one end is on a free sliding bearing, and the axial force if both ends were pinned to rigid abutments.
- Free movement ΔL = αΔT L = 12 × 10⁻⁶ × 40 × 30 000 = 14.4 mm.
- With both ends pinned to rigid supports the strain αΔT = 4.8 × 10⁻⁴ is fully suppressed.
- Stress σ = EαΔT = 200 000 × 4.8 × 10⁻⁴ = 96 N/mm² (compression).
- Force F = σA = 96 × 8000 = 768 000 N = 768 kN, pushing on both abutments.
- The model with a roller (free bearing) at one end gives no temperature force; the pinned-pinned model gives 768 kN. Real bearings are designed to match the chosen model, and the joint gap must allow the 14.4 mm.
Answer. Free movement 14.4 mm; if both ends were restrained, 96 N/mm² and 768 kN in compression
Step-by-step procedure
- Identify the structural form and the main way it carries load (bending, axial, arch or cable action).
- Draw the line model on the centroidal axes, with spans between support centres.
- Decide each joint (pin or rigid) and each support (roller, pin, guided, fixed) from how the real detail is built; note uncertain ones.
- Convert area loads to member loads by tributary width or to panel-point loads, and add self-weight.
- Analyse the model; where a joint or support model is uncertain, analyse both limiting models and design for the worse effect in each region.
- Check that the real details (bearings, connections, foundations) will behave as the model assumes.
Site notes
- A bearing drawn as a roller must actually be free: check that sliding plates are clean, greased or lined as specified, and that holding-down bolts are in slotted holes where movement is expected.
- Concrete beams cast monolithic with columns are partly fixed; cracking near supports in a beam designed as simply supported is a sign of the hogging moment the model ignored.
- Purlins placed between panel points put local bending into truss rafters; record such changes and send them to the designer.
- Temporary works (props, back-propping) change the support system of a slab or beam during construction; the analysis model must match the stage being checked.
- Measuring the span to the face of supports in one place and to centres in another within the same model.
- Treating every connection as rigid (or every one as pinned) without looking at the real detail.
- Forgetting the half panel load at the end nodes, or applying the full roof load to an end node.
- Using the slab area of the whole bay on each beam instead of the tributary width.
- Restraining both ends of a long member against temperature in the model while the real bearing is free, or the reverse.
For a uniformly loaded span the free moment wL²/8 is shared between midspan and supports whatever the end model: simply supported puts all of it at midspan, fully fixed puts two-thirds at the supports and one-third at midspan. If your support and midspan moments do not add up to wL²/8, recheck the model. Valid for prismatic spans under uniform load.
Summary
- Beams bend, trusses carry axial force, frames carry both, arches carry compression and cables tension.
- Analysis works on a model: lines on centroidal axes, pin or rigid joints, idealised supports.
- Roller 1, pin 2, guided 2 and fixed 3 reaction components.
- Area loads become member loads by tributary width (w = q s) or panel-point loads (P = q S a).
- The idealisation changes the answer: bracket uncertain restraint between limiting models.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1How many reaction components do a roller, a pin, a guided support and a fixed support provide in a plane structure?
Roller 1, pin 2, guided support 2 (one translation and rotation prevented), fixed support 3.
2Beams at 4 m centres support a one-way slab carrying 6 kN/m². A beam spans 5 m and is simply supported. Ignoring self-weight, find the line load and the midspan moment.
w = 6 × 4 = 24 kN/m; M = 24 × 5²/8 = 75 kN m.
3A roof load of 0.8 kN/m² on plan is carried by trusses at 4 m centres with 1.5 m panels. Find the interior and end panel-point loads.
Interior P = 0.8 × 4 × 1.5 = 4.8 kN; end nodes 2.4 kN.
4A 20 m steel girder with α = 12 × 10⁻⁶ per °C sees a temperature rise of 35 °C. How much must its free bearing allow?
ΔL = 12 × 10⁻⁶ × 35 × 20 000 = 8.4 mm.
5A beam of span 6 m carries 20 kN/m. Compare the moments for the simply supported and fixed-ended idealisations.
Simply supported: 90 kN m at midspan. Fixed: 60 kN m hogging at supports and 30 kN m at midspan; both sum to wL²/8 = 90 kN m.
6When is it reasonable to model the gusseted joints of a steel truss as pins?
When the members are slender and their axes meet at the joint centres, and loads are applied at the joints; the bending caused by the joint stiffness is then small compared with the axial stresses. Short, stocky members or eccentric joints need a rigid-jointed model or a separate check of secondary moments.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
- C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
- D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.