Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 6 › Lesson 6.4

6.4 Closed-coiled helical springs

Strength of Materials Chapter 6: Torsion Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Show that the wire of a closed-coiled helical spring under an axial load is mainly in torsion, and derive its shear stress, deflection and stiffness from the torsion equation of lesson 6.1.
  • Allow for direct shear and coil curvature with the Wahl correction factor, and design a spring for a given load, stress and deflection.
  • Combine springs in series and in parallel, and use spring stiffness to estimate the natural frequency of a mass on springs, as used for vibration isolators.

Theory

A helical spring is a wire wound into a helix of mean coil radius R. In a closed-coiled spring the coils lie almost touching, so the helix angle is small, usually under about 10°, and each coil is very nearly a flat ring. When an axial load W pulls or pushes the spring, any cross-section of the wire must balance W at a lever arm R from the spring axis. The wire section therefore carries a torque T = W R about the wire's own axis, plus a direct shear force W, and the bending of the wire is negligible because the coils are nearly flat.

The torque produces the main stress. From lesson 6.1 the shear stress at the wire surface is 16 T/(π d³) = 16 W R/(π d³), where d is the wire diameter. The direct shear force adds a little on the inner side of the coil, and the curvature of the wire makes the stress on the inner side higher still, because the inner fibres are shorter. Both effects are allowed for by multiplying the torsion stress by a correction factor. The Wahl factor, K = (4C − 1)/(4C − 4) + 0.615/C, where C = D/d is the spring index (mean coil diameter over wire diameter), is the form most textbooks use; for a typical index of 6 to 10 it adds about 15 to 25 %.

WRT = W Rdirect shear Wδ = 64 W R³ n/(G d⁴)k = G d⁴/(64 R³ n)Indiacon original
Figure 6.4: Closed-coiled helical spring: the axial load W puts the wire in torsion with T = W R, which sets both the shear stress and the axial deflection. Indiacon original, not to scale.

The deflection follows from the twist of the whole wire. The wire length is about 2π R n for n active coils. Twisted by T = W R, it turns through θ = T l/(G J) = 64 W R² n/(G d⁴) end to end, and the load point moves along the spring axis by R θ, so δ = 64 W R³ n/(G d⁴) = 8 W D³ n/(G d⁴). The stiffness k = W/δ = G d⁴/(64 R³ n) depends strongly on the wire diameter (fourth power) and the coil radius (cube) and inversely on the number of coils. The same result comes from energy: ½ W δ equals T² l/(2 G J), the strain energy of a shaft in torsion, as in lesson 5.5.

Springs combine like this. In series, the same load passes through each spring and the deflections add, so 1/k = 1/k₁ + 1/k₂. In parallel, such as nested springs or several springs under one machine base, the deflection is common and the loads add, so k = k₁ + k₂. A mass m on springs of total stiffness k has natural frequency f = (1/2π) √(k/m), which for a static deflection δ under the weight becomes f = (1/2π) √(g/δ). Civil engineers meet springs in variable-load pipe hangers, vibration isolators under generator sets and pumps, buffers at the ends of crane and lift runways, and spring supports in seismic isolation and testing rigs.

Derivation

  1. Free body of part of the spring cut through the wire: equilibrium about the spring axis requires a torque T = W R in the wire and a direct shear force W; the bending moment in the wire is negligible for a small helix angle.
  2. Torsion of the wire (lesson 6.1): τ = 16 T/(π d³) = 16 W R/(π d³) = 8 W D/(π d³), with D = 2R.
  3. Wire length for n active coils: l = 2π R n (helix angle neglected).
  4. Twist of the wire: θ = T l/(G J) = W R × 2π R n/(G π d⁴/32) = 64 W R² n/(G d⁴).
  5. Axial deflection: δ = R θ = 64 W R³ n/(G d⁴) = 8 W D³ n/(G d⁴); stiffness k = G d⁴/(64 R³ n).
  6. Energy check: U = T² l/(2 G J) = 32 W² R³ n/(G d⁴) and ½ W δ = 32 W² R³ n/(G d⁴), which agree.
  7. Corrected stress: τ_max = K × 16 W R/(π d³), K = (4C − 1)/(4C − 4) + 0.615/C, C = D/d. Direct shear alone gives the factor (1 + d/(4R)) = (1 + 0.5/C).
  8. Series: δ = W/k₁ + W/k₂, so 1/k = 1/k₁ + 1/k₂. Parallel: W = k₁ δ + k₂ δ, so k = k₁ + k₂. Natural frequency: f = (1/2π) √(k/m) = (1/2π) √(g/δ_static).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Torque in the wire: T = W R (N·mm)
  • Shear stress: τ = 16 W R/(π d³) = 8 W D/(π d³) (N/mm²); corrected τ_max = K × 8 W D/(π d³)
  • Wahl factor: K = (4C − 1)/(4C − 4) + 0.615/C, spring index C = D/d
  • Deflection: δ = 64 W R³ n/(G d⁴) = 8 W D³ n/(G d⁴) (mm)
  • Stiffness: k = G d⁴/(64 R³ n) = G d⁴/(8 D³ n) (N/mm)
  • Strain energy: U = ½ W δ = W²/(2k)
  • Series 1/k = Σ 1/kᵢ; parallel k = Σ kᵢ; f = (1/2π) √(k/m) = (1/2π) √(g/δ_static)
Assumptions and limits
  • Closed coils with a small helix angle, so each coil acts as a flat ring and the wire is in torsion only; open-coiled springs, where the wire also bends, need a fuller theory.
  • The load acts along the spring axis, and the spring is not buckling sideways; long compression springs need a guide or a buckling check.
  • Linear elastic wire material with shear modulus G; the deflection formula ignores the small extra deflection from direct shear.
  • Only active coils count in n; end coils that are closed and ground do not deflect.
  • Limits: fatigue under repeated load, surge in fast-acting springs and the solid (fully closed) length are separate design checks.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • The mechanics of closed-coiled helical springs is not governed by any design code; no design code governs the derivation or the formulas of this lesson.
  • Springs for pipe hangers, vibration isolators and buffers are manufactured items selected from makers' data for load, stiffness and travel; the civil engineer specifies the loads, deflections and supporting structure.
  • Side by side, not ranked: Indian, European and American spring material and manufacturing standards exist for wire and finished springs, and machine-foundation and isolation design are treated in foundation engineering; none of them changes the mechanics shown here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (site style: variable-load pipe hanger spring)

Problem. A pipe hanger spring has wire diameter 20 mm, mean coil diameter 120 mm and 10 active coils; G = 80 000 N/mm². It carries 3 kN. Find the shear stress without and with the Wahl factor, the deflection, the stiffness and the energy stored.

  1. R = 60 mm. τ = 16 W R/(π d³) = 16 × 3000 × 60/(π × 8000) = 114.6 N/mm².
  2. C = 120/20 = 6; K = 23/20 + 0.615/6 = 1.253; τ_max = 1.253 × 114.6 = 143.5 N/mm².
  3. δ = 64 W R³ n/(G d⁴) = 64 × 3000 × 60³ × 10/(80 000 × 20⁴) = 32.4 mm.
  4. k = W/δ = 3000/32.4 = 92.6 N/mm; U = ½ W δ = ½ × 3000 × 32.4 = 48 600 N·mm = 48.6 J.

Answer. τ = 114.6 N/mm² (143.5 with Wahl); δ = 32.4 mm; k = 92.6 N/mm; U = 48.6 J

Example 2 (design: vibration isolator under a generator set)

Problem. Each of the isolator springs under a diesel generator set carries 2 kN. The static deflection should be about 25 mm, the spring index C = 8, the allowable corrected shear stress 350 N/mm², and G = 80 000 N/mm². Find the wire diameter and number of active coils, and the natural frequency of the mounted set.

  1. C = 8: K = 31/28 + 0.615/8 = 1.184.
  2. τ_max = K × 8 W C/(π d²) ≤ 350, so d² ≥ 1.184 × 8 × 2000 × 8/(π × 350) = 137.8 mm², d = 11.7 mm; adopt 12 mm, D = 96 mm.
  3. n = δ G d⁴/(8 W D³) = 25 × 80 000 × 12⁴/(8 × 2000 × 96³) = 2.93; adopt 3 active coils.
  4. With n = 3: δ = 8 × 2000 × 96³ × 3/(80 000 × 12⁴) = 25.6 mm and τ_max = 1.184 × 8 × 2000 × 96/(π × 12³) = 335 N/mm² ≤ 350.
  5. f = (1/2π) √(9810/25.6) = 3.12 Hz, well below a running speed of 1500 rev/min (25 Hz), so the set is isolated.

Answer. d = 12 mm, D = 96 mm, 3 active coils; δ = 25.6 mm, τ_max = 335 N/mm², f = 3.12 Hz

Example 3 (nested crane buffer springs: parallel and series)

Problem. A crane runway buffer uses two springs of stiffness 50 N/mm and 75 N/mm. Find the combined stiffness when they are nested (parallel) and when placed end to end (series), and the deflection and spring loads under 5 kN in each arrangement.

  1. Parallel: k = 50 + 75 = 125 N/mm; δ = 5000/125 = 40 mm; loads 50 × 40 = 2000 N and 75 × 40 = 3000 N.
  2. Series: 1/k = 1/50 + 1/75, k = 30 N/mm; δ = 5000/30 = 166.7 mm (100 mm + 66.7 mm); each spring carries the full 5000 N.
  3. Energy absorbed at 5 kN: parallel ½ × 5000 × 40 = 100 000 N·mm = 100 J; series ½ × 5000 × 166.7 = 416 700 N·mm = 416.7 J.
  4. The series pair is softer and absorbs more energy for the same force; the nested pair is stiffer and shorter in travel.

Answer. Parallel 125 N/mm, 40 mm (2.0 and 3.0 kN); series 30 N/mm, 166.7 mm

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Find the axial load per spring and the required deflection or stiffness.
  2. Choose a spring index C and compute the Wahl factor K.
  3. Find the wire diameter from the corrected shear stress, and round up.
  4. Find the number of active coils from the deflection formula, and round to a practical value.
  5. Recheck stress and deflection with the adopted sizes, and for isolators check the natural frequency against the machine speed.
  6. Check solid length, buckling of long compression springs and fatigue for repeated loads.

Site notes

  • Variable spring hangers support hot pipelines in plants and treatment works while letting the pipe move with temperature; the stiffness sets how much the load changes as the pipe moves.
  • Spring isolators under generator sets, pumps and chillers on roofs stop vibration reaching the slab; check that the slab carries the point loads at the isolator positions.
  • Buffers at the ends of crane runways and lift pits absorb the energy of an overrun; the buffer stroke and stiffness decide the force passed to the structure.
  • Compression springs that are long for their diameter can buckle sideways; makers fit guide rods or cups, so check they are installed.
Common mistakes
  • Using the mean coil radius and the mean coil diameter interchangeably (64 W R³ n and 8 W D³ n are the same only when D = 2R).
  • Counting inactive end coils in n, which overestimates deflection.
  • Omitting the Wahl factor in design, which underestimates the peak stress by 15 to 30 %.
  • Adding stiffnesses of springs in series instead of adding their flexibilities.
  • Using the outside or inside coil diameter instead of the mean coil diameter.
Quick check

k = G d⁴/(8 D³ n): double the wire diameter and the spring is 16 times stiffer; double the coil diameter and it is 8 times softer; double the coils and it is 2 times softer. A static deflection of 25 mm gives a natural frequency of about 3.15 Hz.

Summary

  • In a closed-coiled spring under axial load, the wire is in torsion with T = W R.
  • τ = 16 W R/(π d³), corrected by the Wahl factor for direct shear and curvature.
  • δ = 64 W R³ n/(G d⁴) and k = G d⁴/(64 R³ n).
  • Springs in series add flexibilities; springs in parallel add stiffnesses.
  • Natural frequency f = (1/2π) √(g/δ_static) links spring design to vibration isolation.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Find the stiffness of a spring with wire diameter 10 mm, mean coil diameter 80 mm and 12 active coils; G = 80 000 N/mm².

k = G d⁴/(8 D³ n) = 80 000 × 10⁴/(8 × 80³ × 12) = 16.3 N/mm.

2What is the largest axial load on the spring of Q1 if the shear stress (without the Wahl factor) must not exceed 400 N/mm²?

W = π d³ τ/(16 R) = π × 1000 × 400/(16 × 40) = 1963 N, about 1.96 kN.

3Find the strain energy stored in the spring of Q1 at the load of Q2.

U = W²/(2k) = 1963.5²/(2 × 16.28) = 118 400 N·mm = 118.4 J.

4Find the Wahl factor for a spring index of 5.

K = (4 × 5 − 1)/(4 × 5 − 4) + 0.615/5 = 19/16 + 0.123 = 1.311.

5How do the stiffness and the safe load of a spring change if the wire diameter is doubled while D and n are unchanged?

Stiffness varies with d⁴, so it rises 16 times; the safe load for the same stress varies with d³ (ignoring the change in K), so it rises 8 times.

6A spring of stiffness 20 N/mm is cut into two equal halves. What is the stiffness of each half, and of the two halves placed side by side?

Each half has half the coils, so its stiffness doubles to 40 N/mm. Side by side (parallel) they give 80 N/mm.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.