Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 6 › Lesson 6.2

6.2 Power transmitted by shafts

Strength of Materials Chapter 6: Torsion Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Relate the power transmitted by a rotating shaft to its torque and speed, P = 2π N T/60.
  • Design a solid or hollow shaft for a given power and speed on the basis of strength (allowable shear stress) and of stiffness (allowable twist per unit length), and adopt the larger diameter.
  • Allow for fluctuating torque and compare the steel needed for solid and hollow shafts carrying the same power.

Theory

A shaft transmits power by carrying torque while it turns. Work done by a torque T turning through an angle φ is T φ, so the rate of doing work, the power, is T times the angular speed ω. Speeds of motors and pumps are usually given in revolutions per minute, N, and one revolution is 2π radians, so ω = 2π N/60 rad/s and P = 2π N T/60 watts with T in N·m. For the same power, a fast shaft carries a small torque and a slow shaft a large one; this is why gearboxes reduce speed and the slow output shaft is the thickest.

Once the torque is known, the shaft is sized from lesson 6.1. For strength, the maximum shear stress 16 T/(π d³) must not exceed the allowable value, which gives d = (16 T/(π τ_allow))^(1/3). For stiffness, the angle of twist per unit length T/(G J) must not exceed a stated limit, often a fraction of a degree per metre in practical shaft design, which gives a minimum J and hence another diameter. The shaft must satisfy both, so the larger diameter governs and is rounded up to a standard size.

MotorPumpN rev/min, Treaction torque to baseP = 2π N T/60strength: 16 T/(π d³) ≤ τstiffness: T/(G J) ≤ θ/LIndiacon original
Figure 6.2: Power transmitted by a shaft: torque and speed set the power, and the shaft is sized for both strength and stiffness while the reaction torque goes into the motor base. Indiacon original, not to scale.

The torque in real drives is not steady. Starting, reciprocating machinery, a concrete mixer drum turning a lumpy load or a crusher biting on stone all produce peaks above the mean torque. Designers therefore size the shaft for a maximum torque found from the mean torque times a ratio based on the machine and duty. Repeated reversals and fluctuations also bring fatigue into play, which is why keyways, shoulders and press fits, where stress concentrates, are where shafts usually crack.

For long line shafts, such as those of vertical turbine pumps at river intakes and tube wells, stiffness and whirling (resonance of the rotating shaft) can govern rather than stress. A hollow shaft gives more stiffness per unit weight than a solid one, which is useful when the shaft must be supported over long distances or lifted by a small crane during maintenance. The civil engineer's interest is in the loads such machines put on their supports and foundations: the reaction torque at the motor base equals the shaft torque.

Derivation

  1. Work of a torque turning through dφ: dW = T dφ. Power P = dW/dt = T dφ/dt = T ω.
  2. With N revolutions per minute, ω = 2π N/60 rad/s, so P = 2π N T/60 (W, with T in N·m).
  3. Torque from power: T = 60 P/(2π N). For P in kW, T (N·m) = 9549 P/N.
  4. Strength criterion (solid): 16 T_max/(π d³) ≤ τ_allow, so d ≥ (16 T_max/(π τ_allow))^(1/3).
  5. Stiffness criterion: θ/L = T_max/(G J) ≤ (θ/L)_allow, so J ≥ T_max/(G (θ/L)_allow) and d ≥ (32 J/π)^(1/4).
  6. Hollow shaft with inner diameter k D: τ_max = 16 T/(π D³ (1 − k⁴)), so D = d_solid/(1 − k⁴)^(1/3) for the same stress.
  7. Weight ratio hollow/solid for the same torque and stress = (1 − k²) D²/d_solid² = (1 − k²)/(1 − k⁴)^(2/3).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • P = 2π N T/60 (W; N in rev/min, T in N·m)
  • T = 60 P/(2π N); with P in kW, T (N·m) = 9549 P/N
  • Strength: d = (16 T_max/(π τ_allow))^(1/3)
  • Stiffness: J = T_max L/(G θ_allow), d = (32 J/π)^(1/4)
  • Hollow, inner/outer ratio k: D = (16 T/(π τ (1 − k⁴)))^(1/3)
  • Weight ratio hollow/solid = (1 − k²)/(1 − k⁴)^(2/3)
  • Degrees to radians: θ (rad) = θ (°) × π/180
Assumptions and limits
  • All assumptions of lesson 6.1 apply: circular sections, linear elastic shear behaviour, small twist.
  • Power is transmitted at constant speed; acceleration torques are covered by the ratio of maximum to mean torque.
  • Bending of the shaft by belt pulls, gear forces or self-weight is ignored here and added in lesson 6.3.
  • Allowable shear stresses and twist limits used in the examples are stated design inputs for practice, not code values.
  • Limits: whirling speed, fatigue at stress raisers, bearing and coupling design are separate checks in machine design.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Shaft sizing for power transmission is mechanics plus machine design practice; no civil design code governs the formulas in this lesson.
  • Allowable stresses, torque ratios and twist limits for shafts come from machine design practice and from the maker of the pump, motor or gearbox; the values in the examples are stated inputs for practice.
  • Side by side, not ranked: Indian, European and American civil codes deal with the effects of such machines on structures (dynamic loads on supports and machine foundations) rather than with the shafts themselves; that topic belongs with machine foundations in foundation engineering.

Worked examples

Example 1 (site style: dewatering pump shaft)

Problem. A dewatering pump at a basement excavation is driven by a 30 kW motor at 1450 rev/min. Find the torque and the diameter of a solid steel shaft if the allowable shear stress is 40 N/mm².

  1. T = 60 P/(2π N) = 60 × 30 000/(2π × 1450) = 197.6 N·m = 1.976 × 10⁵ N·mm.
  2. d = (16 T/(π τ))^(1/3) = (16 × 1.976 × 10⁵/(π × 40))^(1/3) = 29.3 mm.
  3. Adopt a 30 mm shaft (before allowing for the keyway and bending, which are checked separately).

Answer. T = 197.6 N·m; d = 29.3 mm, adopt 30 mm

Example 2 (strength and stiffness: concrete mixer drive)

Problem. The drum drive shaft of a site concrete mixer transmits 15 kW at 200 rev/min. The maximum torque is 1.4 times the mean. The allowable shear stress is 55 N/mm², the twist must not exceed 1° per metre, and G = 80 000 N/mm². Find the shaft diameter.

  1. T_mean = 60 × 15 000/(2π × 200) = 716.2 N·m; T_max = 1.4 × 716.2 = 1002.7 N·m.
  2. Strength: d = (16 × 1.0027 × 10⁶/(π × 55))^(1/3) = 45.3 mm.
  3. Stiffness: θ/L = 1° per 1000 mm = 1.745 × 10⁻⁵ rad/mm, so J ≥ 1.0027 × 10⁶/(80 000 × 1.745 × 10⁻⁵) = 7.18 × 10⁵ mm⁴, giving d = (32 J/π)^(1/4) = 52.0 mm.
  4. Stiffness governs; adopt 55 mm.

Answer. Strength 45.3 mm, stiffness 52.0 mm; adopt 55 mm

Example 3 (hollow versus solid: river intake line shaft)

Problem. A vertical turbine pump at a river intake absorbs 75 kW at 1450 rev/min. Compare a solid shaft with a hollow shaft whose inner diameter is 0.6 of the outer, both at an allowable shear stress of 45 N/mm².

  1. T = 60 × 75 000/(2π × 1450) = 493.9 N·m.
  2. Solid: d = (16 × 4.939 × 10⁵/(π × 45))^(1/3) = 38.2 mm.
  3. Hollow: D = 38.2/(1 − 0.6⁴)^(1/3) = 38.2/0.9547 = 40.0 mm, inner diameter 0.6 × 40.0 = 24.0 mm.
  4. Weight ratio = (1 − 0.6²) × 40.0²/38.2² = 0.64 × 1.097 = 0.70; the hollow shaft saves about 30 % of the steel for a 5 % larger outside diameter.

Answer. Solid 38.2 mm; hollow 40.0 mm outer, 24.0 mm inner; hollow uses about 70 % of the steel

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Convert the power and speed to torque: T = 60 P/(2π N).
  2. Apply the ratio of maximum to mean torque if the drive is not steady.
  3. Find the diameter for strength from the allowable shear stress.
  4. Find the diameter for stiffness from the allowable twist per unit length.
  5. Adopt the larger, round up to a standard size, and check keyways, bending (lesson 6.3) and the supports for the reaction torque.

Site notes

  • The reaction torque of a motor or gearbox goes into its base plate and holding-down bolts; check them and the plinth for it, especially for large pumps and crushers.
  • Batching plant mixers, winches and conveyor drives run slow and carry large torque, so their shafts are thick; fast pump shafts are slender for the same power.
  • Long pump line shafts are hollow or supported by bearings at intervals because twist and whirling govern before stress does.
  • Shafts that crack usually do so at a keyway or shoulder after many cycles; look there first during maintenance inspections.
Common mistakes
  • Forgetting the 60 when the speed is in rev/min, or using rev/s and rad/s interchangeably.
  • Mixing kW with W or N·m with N·mm.
  • Designing only for strength when the stiffness limit governs.
  • Sizing for mean torque when the drive has starting or shock peaks.
  • Inserting the twist limit in degrees into T/(G J), which needs radians.
Quick check

T (N·m) = 9549 × P (kW)/N (rev/min). For the same power, halving the speed doubles the torque and increases the solid shaft diameter by 2^(1/3), about 26 %.

Summary

  • Power transmitted by a shaft is P = 2π N T/60.
  • For a given power, torque varies inversely with speed.
  • Shafts are sized for strength (allowable shear stress) and for stiffness (allowable twist per unit length); the larger diameter governs.
  • Fluctuating drives are sized on the maximum torque, and fatigue at stress raisers is checked separately.
  • Hollow shafts give the same strength for much less steel.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1What power does a shaft transmit when it carries 500 N·m at 960 rev/min?

P = 2π × 960 × 500/60 = 50 265 W = 50.3 kW.

2Find the torque in a shaft transmitting 10 kW at 1440 rev/min.

T = 60 × 10 000/(2π × 1440) = 66.3 N·m.

3What is the largest power a solid 50 mm shaft can transmit at 300 rev/min with an allowable shear stress of 40 N/mm²?

T = π d³ τ/16 = π × 125 000 × 40/16 = 9.82 × 10⁵ N·mm = 981.7 N·m. P = 2π × 300 × 981.7/60 = 30 843 W = 30.8 kW.

4If the speed of a shaft is doubled while the power stays the same, how does the required solid diameter change?

The torque halves, and d varies with T^(1/3), so the diameter becomes (1/2)^(1/3) = 0.794 of the original, about 21 % smaller.

5A shaft transmits 20 kW at 500 rev/min with a maximum torque 1.25 times the mean; the allowable shear stress is 50 N/mm². Find the solid shaft diameter for strength.

T_mean = 60 × 20 000/(2π × 500) = 382.0 N·m; T_max = 477.5 N·m. d = (16 × 4.775 × 10⁵/(π × 50))^(1/3) = 36.5 mm; adopt 38 or 40 mm.

6A 40 mm solid shaft 2 m long carries 400 N·m; G = 80 000 N/mm². Find the total twist.

J = π × 40⁴/32 = 2.513 × 10⁵ mm⁴. θ = 400 × 10³ × 2000/(80 000 × 2.513 × 10⁵) = 0.0398 rad = 2.28°.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.