7.5 Relative motion
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Define the relative position, velocity and acceleration of one particle with respect to another.
- Use v_A = v_B + v_A/B to solve rain, river-crossing, crane and vehicle problems.
- Distinguish the heading of a boat or aircraft from its actual path over the ground.
Theory
Motion is always measured from some reference. A passenger walking along a moving train has one velocity relative to the train and another relative to the platform. For two particles A and B whose positions are measured from the same fixed origin, the position of A relative to B is r_A/B = r_A − r_B, the vector from B to A. Differentiating gives the relative velocity v_A/B = v_A − v_B and the relative acceleration a_A/B = a_A − a_B.
Rearranged, v_A = v_B + v_A/B: the absolute velocity of A is the velocity of the reference B plus the velocity of A as seen from B. This is a vector equation and is usually solved with a velocity triangle or with components. The relative velocity of B with respect to A is the exact negative, v_B/A = −v_A/B.
Three classic cases show the idea. Rain falling vertically appears to slant towards a person moving forward, because v_rain/person = v_rain − v_person. A boat heading straight across a river is carried downstream by the current, so its actual path is the vector sum of its velocity relative to the water and the water's velocity. A crane hook moving with the trolley while being lowered has a ground velocity equal to the trolley velocity plus its velocity relative to the trolley.
The results above assume that the reference B only translates. If the reference frame also rotates, as for a slider on a rotating arm, extra terms appear, including the Coriolis acceleration; these are treated in machine dynamics and are outside this lesson.
Derivation
- Positions from a fixed origin O: r_A and r_B. Relative position: r_A/B = r_A − r_B.
- Differentiate with respect to time: v_A/B = dr_A/dt − dr_B/dt = v_A − v_B.
- Differentiate again: a_A/B = a_A − a_B.
- Hence v_A = v_B + v_A/B and a_A = a_B + a_A/B.
- Since r_B/A = −r_A/B, it follows that v_B/A = −v_A/B.
r_A/B = r_A − r_B (m)v_A/B = v_A − v_B; v_A = v_B + v_A/B (m/s)a_A/B = a_A − a_B (m/s²)v_B/A = −v_A/BRiver of width d, current c, boat speed b relative to water: heading straight across, t = d/b and drift = c d/b; to land directly opposite (b > c), head upstream at sin α = c/b and t = d/(b cos α)
- The reference body translates without rotating; rotating frames need extra terms.
- Speeds are far below the speed of light, so ordinary vector addition holds.
- Current, wind and vehicle speeds are taken as uniform over the region considered.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- No design code governs this lesson; relative motion is a principle of mechanics.
Worked examples
Problem. Rain falls vertically at 6 m/s. A person walks east at 3 m/s. Find the velocity of the rain relative to the person and the angle at which an umbrella should be tilted.
- v_rain = (0, −6) m/s; v_person = (3, 0) m/s.
- v_rain/person = v_rain − v_person = (−3, −6) m/s.
- Magnitude = √(9 + 36) = 6.708 m/s.
- It slants towards the person from ahead at tan⁻¹(3/6) = 26.57° to the vertical, so the umbrella should be tilted forward by 26.57°.
Answer. 6.71 m/s at 26.6° from the vertical; tilt the umbrella forward 26.6°
Problem. A survey boat that moves at 3 m/s relative to the water must cross a river 120 m wide flowing at 1.5 m/s. (a) If it heads straight across, find the crossing time and how far downstream it lands. (b) Find the heading needed to land directly opposite and the crossing time then.
- (a) Velocity across = 3 m/s, so t = 120 / 3 = 40 s. Drift = 1.5 × 40 = 60 m downstream.
- Its actual speed over the ground is √(3² + 1.5²) = 3.354 m/s.
- (b) Head upstream at angle α to the straight-across line so that 3 sin α cancels the current: sin α = 1.5 / 3, α = 30°.
- Speed across = 3 cos 30° = 2.598 m/s, so t = 120 / 2.598 = 46.19 s.
Answer. (a) 40 s, landing 60 m downstream; (b) head 30° upstream, 46.2 s
Problem. Train A, 200 m long, runs east at 72 km/h. Train B, 150 m long, runs on a parallel track at 54 km/h. Find the time for the trains to pass each other completely when (a) they move in opposite directions and (b) B also moves east.
- v_A = 20 m/s, v_B = 15 m/s. The distance to be covered relative to each other is 200 + 150 = 350 m.
- (a) Opposite directions: v_A/B = 20 − (−15) = 35 m/s; t = 350 / 35 = 10 s.
- (b) Same direction: v_A/B = 20 − 15 = 5 m/s; t = 350 / 5 = 70 s.
Answer. (a) 10 s; (b) 70 s
Step-by-step procedure
- Name the bodies and choose one fixed frame (the ground) and the moving reference.
- Write each known velocity as a vector in components.
- Use v_A = v_B + v_A/B; draw the velocity triangle to see which sides are known.
- Solve with components or with the sine and cosine rules.
- Check directions: v_B/A must be the exact negative of v_A/B.
Site notes
- On river and creek surveys, a boat or drone must head into the current to hold a section line; the heading differs from the path over the ground by the drift angle.
- A crane hook's ground velocity is the trolley velocity plus the hoist velocity; slowing the trolley before lowering keeps the load from swinging into workers or formwork.
- Overtaking on a two-lane road uses relative speed: at a speed difference of only 5 m/s, passing a long vehicle takes many seconds, which is why overtaking sight distance is much longer than stopping sight distance.
- Adding speeds arithmetically when the velocities are not along the same line.
- Getting the order wrong: v_A/B = v_A − v_B, not v_B − v_A.
- Confusing the heading of a boat or aircraft with its actual direction of travel over the ground.
- Using total train lengths incorrectly: passing completely needs the sum of the two lengths, not one length.
- Applying the translating-frame formula to a rotating reference.
Absolute velocity = velocity of the reference + velocity relative to the reference, added as vectors.
Summary
- r_A/B = r_A − r_B; v_A/B = v_A − v_B; a_A/B = a_A − a_B.
- v_A = v_B + v_A/B; v_B/A = −v_A/B.
- Solve with a velocity triangle or components.
- Rotating frames add terms (including Coriolis) not covered here.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Car A moves north at 20 m/s and car B moves east at 15 m/s. Find the velocity of A relative to B.
v_A/B = (−15, 20) m/s, 25 m/s, directed 36.87° west of north.
2A boat moves at 4 m/s in still water in a river flowing at 2 m/s. How long does it take to go 600 m downstream and back?
600/6 + 600/2 = 100 + 300 = 400 s.
3A trolley moves along a jib at 0.5 m/s while the hook is lowered at 0.3 m/s relative to the trolley. Find the hook's speed over the ground.
√(0.5² + 0.3²) = 0.5831 m/s.
4An aircraft heads north at 250 km/h relative to the air. The wind blows towards the east at 50 km/h. Find its ground speed and drift angle.
√(250² + 50²) = 254.95 km/h; drift tan⁻¹(50/250) = 11.31° east of north.
5To a cyclist riding at 4 m/s, rain appears to fall vertically at 8 m/s. Find the actual velocity of the rain.
v_rain = v_cyclist + v_rain/cyclist = (4, −8) m/s: 8.944 m/s at 26.57° from the vertical, in the direction of riding.
6If v_A/B = (3, −2) m/s, what is v_B/A?
(−3, 2) m/s.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, D. F. Mazurek, P. J. Cornwell, B. P. Self, Vector Mechanics for Engineers: Statics and Dynamics, McGraw Hill, 12th edition, 2019.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Pearson, 15th edition, 2022 (published 2021).
- J. L. Meriam, L. G. Kraige, J. N. Bolton, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Wiley, 9th edition, 2018.
- S. Timoshenko, D. H. Young, J. V. Rao, S. Pati, Engineering Mechanics (in SI units), McGraw Hill Education (India), 5th edition, 2013.