2.5 Frames and machines
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Distinguish frames and machines from trusses by identifying multi-force members.
- Dismember a frame into members, applying equal and opposite pin forces between them.
- Find pin forces and support reactions, and the mechanical advantage of simple machines.
Theory
A frame is a structure in which at least one member carries forces at more than two points or carries transverse load, so it is a multi-force member and will bend. A machine is a similar assembly with moving parts, designed to change the size or direction of a force: pliers, cutters, levers and toggles. Both are analysed by taking them apart.
First, look for two-force members, such as struts and links pinned at both ends with no load between: their pin forces act along the line joining the pins, which saves unknowns. Then draw each multi-force member separately. At every pin connecting two members, the forces on the two members are equal and opposite (Newton's third law); draw them with opposite arrows and the same symbols.
For a frame that is rigid on its own supports, start with the whole structure to find reactions. For a frame that would collapse without its supports (non-rigid frames, such as an A-frame on rollers), the whole-structure equations do not give all reactions, and members must be taken apart before the reactions can be found.
For machines the aim is usually the output force for a given input force. The ratio output ÷ input is the mechanical advantage. For a lever or a pair of pliers pivoting about a pin, moments about the pin give the ratio directly as the ratio of lever arms.
Derivation
- Count unknowns: two per internal pin (or one per two-force member) plus the reaction components.
- Count equations: three per rigid member in the plane.
- A frame is determinate when the number of unknowns equals three times the number of members, and the arrangement is stable.
- For a lever with input P at distance a from the pivot and output Q at distance b, ΣM_pivot = 0 gives P a = Q b, so the mechanical advantage is Q/P = a/b.
- The pin force is then found from force equilibrium of one member; for parallel P and Q acting on the same side of the pin, it equals P + Q.
Pin forces: equal and opposite on the two connected membersTwo-force member: force along the line joining its pinsLever: Q = P a / b; mechanical advantage MA = a / bDeterminacy of a plane frame: unknowns = 3 × number of rigid members
- Members are rigid; pins are frictionless.
- Two-force members are straight, pinned at both ends and unloaded between pins.
- Machines are analysed statically, at the instant considered, ignoring friction unless stated.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- No design code governs this lesson; it is pure mechanics. Portal frames and brackets designed later to IS 800:2007 or IS 456:2000 begin with exactly this kind of free-body analysis.
Worked examples
Problem. A horizontal beam AC, 4 m long, is pinned to a wall at A (0, 0) and propped by a strut BD from B (2 m, 0) on the beam to D (0, −2 m) on the wall. A 10 kN load hangs at C. Find the strut force and the pin reaction at A.
- BD is a two-force member at 45°; let it push on the beam with compression C, direction (1, 1)/√2.
- Moments about A on the beam: x Fy − y Fx for each force: −4 × 10 + 2 × C/√2 = 0, so C = 20√2 = 28.28 kN (compression).
- ΣFx on the beam: Ax + C/√2 = 0, so Ax = −20 kN, i.e. 20 kN acting towards the wall (negative x direction).
- ΣFy: Ay + C/√2 − 10 = 0, so Ay = −10 kN (downward).
- Resultant at A: √(20² + 10²) = 22.36 kN.
Answer. Strut 28.28 kN compression; pin at A 20 kN horizontal and 10 kN downward (22.36 kN)
Problem. A hand bar cutter works like pliers. The hand applies 150 N to each handle at 300 mm from the pivot pin; the cutting edges bear on the bar at 25 mm from the pin. Find the cutting force, the mechanical advantage and the pin force.
- Moments about the pin on one handle-blade member: 150 × 300 = Q × 25.
- Q = 150 × 300 / 25 = 1 800 N.
- Mechanical advantage = 300 / 25 = 12.
- The hand force and the bar reaction both act on the same side of the pin and in the same direction on that member, so the pin force is 150 + 1 800 = 1 950 N.
Answer. Cutting force 1 800 N; MA = 12; pin force 1 950 N
Step-by-step procedure
- Identify two-force members and multi-force members.
- If the frame is rigid on its supports, find the reactions from the whole frame.
- Dismember: draw each multi-force member with equal and opposite pin forces.
- Start with a member that has three or fewer unknowns; take moments about a pin.
- Check with an equation not yet used, such as equilibrium of another member.
Site notes
- Knee braces and props on site are two-force members; the beams or posts they support are multi-force members and will bend at the brace point.
- The pin force in a lever or cutter is larger than either the input or output force, so the pivot is the part most likely to wear or fail.
- Temporary works such as raking shores are frames: the shore is a two-force member, but the wall plate and sole plate carry bending and must be checked.
- Treating a multi-force member as a two-force member and forcing its pin force along the member.
- Drawing pin forces in the same direction on both connected members.
- Including internal pin forces in the free body of the whole frame.
- Using the whole-frame equations for a non-rigid frame and expecting all reactions.
- Mixing mm and m in lever arms (harmless in a ratio, but fatal in a moment).
If a member carries forces at only two points and no load between, its force runs pin to pin. Everything else bends, and needs its own free body.
Summary
- Frames and machines contain multi-force members, unlike trusses.
- Take them apart; pin forces are equal and opposite on connected members.
- Use two-force members to cut unknowns.
- Mechanical advantage of a lever = ratio of lever arms.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A crowbar 1.2 m long pivots 0.1 m from the load end. What force at the handle lifts a 3 kN load end?
P = 3 × 0.1 / 1.1 = 0.273 kN, about 273 N.
2In Example 1, what would the strut force be if the load were at B instead of C?
Moments about A: −2 × 10 + 2C/√2 = 0, so C = 10√2 = 14.14 kN.
3Why can a two-force member not carry bending?
Its two end forces must be collinear along the pin-to-pin line, so it carries only axial force.
4Pliers have handles 120 mm and jaws 20 mm from the pin. A grip of 80 N gives what jaw force?
Q = 80 × 120 / 20 = 480 N.
5How many equations are available for a frame of three rigid members in the plane?
Nine (three per member).
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, D. F. Mazurek, P. J. Cornwell, B. P. Self, Vector Mechanics for Engineers: Statics and Dynamics, McGraw Hill, 12th edition, 2019.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Pearson, 15th edition, 2022 (published 2021).
- J. L. Meriam, L. G. Kraige, J. N. Bolton, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Wiley, 9th edition, 2018.
- S. Timoshenko, D. H. Young, J. V. Rao, S. Pati, Engineering Mechanics (in SI units), McGraw Hill Education (India), 5th edition, 2013.