Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Engineering Mechanics › Chapter 2 › Lesson 2.4

2.4 Zero-force members and special loadings

Engineering Mechanics Chapter 2: Analysis of trusses and frames Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • State and prove the two rules that identify zero-force members by inspection.
  • Find zero-force members in a truss before writing any equations, and explain why they are still needed.
  • Use symmetry and joint-load rules to shorten truss analysis.

Theory

Many trusses contain members that carry no force under a particular loading. Spotting them first saves work and reduces the chance of error. Two rules, both direct results of joint equilibrium, cover almost every case.

Rule 1: if only two members meet at a joint, they are not collinear, and the joint carries no external load or reaction, then both members carry zero force. Rule 2: if three members meet at an unloaded joint and two of them are collinear, the third member carries zero force, and the two collinear members carry equal forces. A useful extension of rule 2: if a load acts along the third member at such a joint, the third member carries exactly that load.

20 kNGrey: zero-force members for this loadIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 2.4: With a single load at L2, the three verticals are zero-force members by inspection. Indiacon original, not to scale.

A zero-force member is not a useless member. It braces long compression members against buckling by cutting their effective length, it keeps the truss stable under other load cases (wind from the other side, moving loads, erection), and it may carry load once the joints deflect slightly. Removing it because it shows zero in one analysis is a classic and dangerous error.

Symmetry is the other short cut. A symmetric truss under symmetric loading has equal forces in mirror-image members, so only half the truss needs to be solved. Under antisymmetric loading, mirror members carry forces of equal size and opposite sign.

Derivation

  1. Rule 1: let members a and b meet at an unloaded joint, with b not along a. Take axes with x along a. ΣFy = 0 involves only b, through Fb sin θ where θ ≠ 0, so Fb = 0. Then ΣFx = 0 gives Fa = 0.
  2. Rule 2: let members a and b be collinear along x, and member c at angle θ ≠ 0. ΣFy = 0 involves only c: Fc sin θ = 0, so Fc = 0. ΣFx = 0 then gives Fa = Fb.
  3. Extension: if a load P acts at that joint along the line of c, ΣFy = 0 along the normal to a and b gives Fc = P with the sign set by the direction of P (tension if P pulls away from c).
  4. Symmetry: reflecting the truss and its loads about the axis of symmetry maps the equilibrium equations onto themselves, so the unique solution must be symmetric.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Two non-collinear members, unloaded joint: F1 = F2 = 0
  • Two collinear members plus a third, unloaded joint: F3 = 0 and F1 = F2
  • Same joint with load P along the third member: F3 = P (tension if P pulls away from the member)
  • Symmetric truss, symmetric loads: mirror members carry equal forces
Assumptions and limits
  • Ideal truss with pin joints and joint loads.
  • The rules apply to one load case at a time; a member that is zero in one case may carry force in another.
  • Small deflections, so the geometry does not change under load.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 800:2007 cl. 3.8 and Table 3 still apply to members that carry zero force under gravity loads; for example, a member normally acting as a tie in a roof truss but liable to reverse under wind is limited to an effective slenderness of 350. EN 1993-1-1 and AISC 360 have their own slenderness provisions; listed for comparison, not ranked.

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style)

Problem. The truss of lessons 2.1 and 2.3 (bottom joints L0 to L4 at 3 m, top joints U1 to U3 at 3 m height, diagonals U1–L2 and U3–L2) carries a single 20 kN load at L2. Identify the zero-force members, then find the forces in U1–L2 and U1–U2.

  1. Joint L1: members L0–L1 and L1–L2 are collinear and L1 carries no load, so U1–L1 = 0 (rule 2). Similarly U3–L3 = 0.
  2. Joint U2: U1–U2 and U2–U3 are collinear and U2 carries no load, so U2–L2 = 0.
  3. Reactions are 10 kN at each support. At L0: F_L0U1 = −10√2 = −14.14 kN.
  4. Joint U1 (U1–L1 = 0): ΣFy: −F_L0U1/√2 − F_U1L2/√2 = 0, so F_U1L2 = +14.14 kN.
  5. ΣFx at U1: −F_L0U1/√2 + F_U1U2 + F_U1L2/√2 = 0, so 10 + F_U1U2 + 10 = 0 and F_U1U2 = −20 kN. Check by section about L2: 10 × 6 / 3 = 20 kN compression.

Answer. Zero-force: U1–L1, U2–L2, U3–L3. U1–L2 = 14.14 kN T; U1–U2 = 20 kN C

Example 2 (site style)

Problem. The same truss now carries the 20 kN load at the top joint U2 instead (for example a deck bearing on the top chord). Which verticals are now zero, and what does U2–L2 carry?

  1. Joints L1 and L3 are still unloaded with collinear chords, so U1–L1 = U3–L3 = 0.
  2. At U2 the load acts along the vertical U2–L2, pushing towards L2. By the extension of rule 2, F_U2L2 = −20 kN (compression).
  3. Check at L2: the diagonals give upward components 14.14/√2 × 2 = 20 kN, balancing the 20 kN push from the vertical.
  4. The same vertical is a zero-force member in Example 1 and a 20 kN strut here, which is why it cannot be removed.

Answer. U1–L1 = U3–L3 = 0; U2–L2 = 20 kN compression

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Before writing equations, scan every joint with two or three members.
  2. Apply rule 1 to unloaded two-member joints and rule 2 to unloaded three-member joints with a collinear pair.
  3. Mark zero members on the sketch; re-scan, since removing them can create new two- or three-member joints.
  4. Use symmetry where loads are symmetric.
  5. Solve the remaining members by joints or sections.

Site notes

  • Verticals that read zero under dead load often carry wind or crane loads; do not omit them, and do not remove them during repairs without a check.
  • A zero-force member halves the buckling length of the compression chord it braces. Leaving out a light brace can therefore cut the chord capacity sharply.
  • During erection, temporary loads at unusual joints can put force into members that are zero in service; check the erection sequence.
Common mistakes
  • Applying rule 2 when the joint carries a load or reaction.
  • Applying rule 1 when the two members are collinear (then they carry equal forces, not necessarily zero).
  • Deleting zero-force members from the structure instead of only from the calculation.
  • Forgetting to re-scan after marking zero members.
  • Assuming a member is zero under all load cases because it is zero under one.
Quick check

Look for T-shaped joints with no load: the stem of the T is a zero-force member. Look for L-shaped joints with no load: both legs are zero.

Summary

  • Two non-collinear members at an unloaded joint: both zero.
  • Two collinear members plus a third at an unloaded joint: the third is zero.
  • Zero-force members still provide bracing and stability under other loads.
  • Symmetric loading on a symmetric truss gives symmetric forces.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1At an unloaded joint, members meet at 0°, 180° and 90°. Which carries zero force?

The member at 90° (the two at 0° and 180° are collinear).

2At the free end of a cantilever truss, two non-collinear members meet and no load acts there. What are their forces?

Both are zero (rule 1).

3In Example 1, if the load moved from L2 to L1, would U1–L1 still be zero?

No. L1 is now loaded, so U1–L1 carries the 20 kN load as tension.

4Give two reasons zero-force members are provided.

They brace compression members against buckling and carry load under other load cases or during erection.

5In Example 1, what is the force in L1–L2?

Equal to L0–L1 (rule 2 at L1): from joint L0, F_L0L1 = 14.14/√2 = 10 kN tension.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, D. F. Mazurek, P. J. Cornwell, B. P. Self, Vector Mechanics for Engineers: Statics and Dynamics, McGraw Hill, 12th edition, 2019.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Pearson, 15th edition, 2022 (published 2021).
  • J. L. Meriam, L. G. Kraige, J. N. Bolton, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Wiley, 9th edition, 2018.
  • S. Timoshenko, D. H. Young, J. V. Rao, S. Pati, Engineering Mechanics (in SI units), McGraw Hill Education (India), 5th edition, 2013.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.