Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Structural Analysis › Chapter 5 › Lesson 5.3

5.3 Maximum effects under moving loads

Structural Analysis Chapter 5: Influence lines and moving loads Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Place a single point load, a uniform load longer than the span and a uniform load shorter than the span for the greatest reaction, shear and moment at a section.
  • Find the position of a train of wheel loads that gives the greatest moment and the greatest shear at a given section, using the average-load test and trial positions.
  • Find the absolute maximum bending moment in a simply supported girder under a load train, and draw the idea of maximum moment and shear envelopes.

Theory

Lesson 5.1 gave the value of a quantity for any load position. Design needs the worst position. For a single point load the answer is immediate: put it at the peak ordinate of the influence line. For a uniform load that can be longer than the span (a lane load, a crowd), cover every part of the line with the sign wanted. For a uniform load shorter than the span, such as a tracked vehicle, the greatest moment at a section occurs when the section divides the load in the same ratio as it divides the span; the ordinates at the two ends of the load are then equal. Sign convention for this chapter: the moving unit load acts downward; reactions are positive upward; the shear at a section is positive when the resultant of the forces on the part to its left acts upward; a sagging bending moment is positive and a hogging one negative; truss member forces are positive in tension; x is measured from the left support.

A train of wheel loads is moved in steps. For the moment at a section C a distance a from A on a span L, moving the whole train a small distance dx towards B changes the moment by (a b/L)(W_L/a − W_R/b) dx, where W_L and W_R are the loads to the left and right of C. The moment is greatest when moving either way reduces it, which happens only as a wheel crosses the section, with the average load on the left equal to the average load on the whole span: W_L/a = W/L, tested with that wheel counted first on one side and then on the other. Usually more than one wheel passes the test, so each candidate is evaluated and the largest kept, and both directions of travel are checked because the train order matters.

Absolute maximum moment under a wheel trainABP_k (heavier)P₂resultant Wspan centre midway between P_k and WIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 5.3: Absolute maximum bending moment: the span centre is placed midway between the critical wheel and the resultant of the loads on the span; the maximum occurs under that wheel. Indiacon original, not to scale.

For shear at a section, the greatest positive shear usually occurs with the leading wheel just to the right of the section and the rest of the train on the right; moving the train on until the second wheel reaches the section raises the ordinates of the wheels still on the right, but the first wheel crosses the jump and turns negative, so one or two trial positions settle it.

The absolute maximum bending moment is the largest moment anywhere in the span for any position of the train. It always occurs under a wheel, usually the heaviest wheel near the resultant. With that wheel at a distance from the resultant, the moment under it is greatest when the centre of the span lies midway between the wheel and the resultant of all loads on the span. For a single load P it is PL/4 at midspan; for two equal loads P at spacing s it is P(L − s/2)²/(2L), provided both loads stay on the span. The curve of the greatest moment at every section is the maximum moment envelope, used to curtail flange plates and reinforcement in girders.

Derivation

  1. Moment at C from loads P_i at ordinates y_i: M_C = Σ P_i y_i, with the moment line rising at slope b/L to the left of C and falling at slope a/L to the right.
  2. Move the whole train a small distance dx towards B: loads left of C gain ordinate (b/L) dx each and loads right of C lose (a/L) dx each, so dM = (W_L b − W_R a) dx/L.
  3. At the maximum, dM changes sign from positive to negative, which happens only when a wheel crosses C; the test is W_L/a ≤ W/L ≤ (W_L + P_C)/a, with P_C the wheel at C.
  4. Absolute maximum: let the resultant W of the loads on the span lie a distance e from the chosen wheel P_k. With the wheel at x from A, R_A = W(L − x − e)/L and the moment under P_k is M = R_A x − M_L, where M_L is the moment about P_k of the loads to its left (constant while no wheel enters or leaves).
  5. dM/dx = W(L − 2x − e)/L = 0 gives x = (L − e)/2: the midspan lies midway between P_k and the resultant.
  6. Uniform load of length d shorter than the span: the moment at C is w × area under the line between the load ends; the derivative of that area is w(y_right − y_left), zero when the end ordinates are equal, which makes the load divide in the ratio a : b.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Single point load: maximum = P × peak ordinate (kN, kN m)
  • Uniform load longer than the span: maximum = w × area of the line with the required sign
  • Short uniform load of length d: section divides the load as it divides the span (a : b)
  • Train, moment at C: W_L/a = W/L with a wheel at C, tested both ways
  • Absolute maximum moment: span centre midway between the critical wheel and the resultant; single load PL/4
  • Two equal loads P at spacing s: M_abs = P(L − s/2)²/(2L) (both loads on the span)
Assumptions and limits
  • Simply supported (determinate) girders with straight influence lines, loads applied directly or at panel points.
  • The wheel loads and spacings of the train are fixed; the train may run in either direction.
  • Static loads; dynamic amplification is added separately by the factor that the governing bridge loading code specifies.
  • Loads that leave or enter the span during a move are re-checked, because the test assumes the same set of loads on the span.
  • Limits: the average-load test locates candidate positions only; the final answer is the largest of the trial values. Continuous and indeterminate girders need curved influence lines and computer load stepping.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • Placing moving loads on influence lines is a result of statics; no design code governs the mechanics of this lesson, and no Indian Standard clause is cited here.
  • Indian, European and American practice, side by side and not ranked, specify their own design vehicles, wheel trains, lane loads and dynamic allowances for road and railway bridges (in India, the Indian Roads Congress bridge loading code and the railway bridge rules); those loads are moved across influence lines by the methods of this lesson, and their values are not reproduced here.

Worked examples

Example 1 (uniform load shorter than the span)

Problem. A simply supported girder spans 20 m. A uniform moving load of 30 kN/m, 8 m long, crosses it. Find the greatest bending moment at a section 5 m from A, and compare it with the load centred on the section.

  1. Moment line at C: peak ab/L = 5 × 15/20 = 3.75 m.
  2. The section divides the span 5 : 15 = 1 : 3, so the load is divided 2 m : 6 m and runs from x = 3 m to x = 11 m.
  3. End ordinates: at 3 m, 3 × 15/20 = 2.25 m; at 11 m, 5 × 9/20 = 2.25 m (equal, as required).
  4. Area: (2.25 + 3.75)/2 × 2 + (3.75 + 2.25)/2 × 6 = 6 + 18 = 24 m²; M = 30 × 24 = 720 kN m.
  5. Load centred on C (1 m to 9 m): ordinates 0.75 m and 2.75 m, area 9 + 13 = 22 m², M = 660 kN m, about 8 per cent less.

Answer. Greatest moment at 5 m: 720 kN m with the load from 3 m to 11 m

Example 2 (absolute maximum moment under two wheels)

Problem. Two wheel loads of 120 kN and 80 kN, 3 m apart, cross a simply supported girder of span 15 m. Find the absolute maximum bending moment.

  1. Resultant 200 kN, at 80 × 3/200 = 1.2 m from the 120 kN wheel towards the 80 kN wheel.
  2. Critical wheel: 120 kN (the heavier, nearer the resultant). Place the midspan (7.5 m) midway between it and the resultant: the 120 kN wheel at 7.5 − 0.6 = 6.9 m from A, the 80 kN wheel at 9.9 m.
  3. R_A = 200 × (15 − 8.1)/15 = 92 kN; moment under the 120 kN wheel = 92 × 6.9 = 634.8 kN m.
  4. Compare the 120 kN wheel at midspan: R_A = (120 × 7.5 + 80 × 4.5)/15 = 84 kN, M = 630 kN m.
  5. A step-by-step scan of every position in both directions of travel confirms 634.8 kN m as the largest moment.

Answer. Absolute maximum moment 634.8 kN m, under the 120 kN wheel 6.9 m from a support

Example 3 (wheel train: moment at a section)

Problem. A girder of span 24 m carries a train of four wheels of 100, 100, 150 and 150 kN at 2 m spacing, in that order from left to right. Find the greatest bending moment at section C, 8 m from A.

  1. W = 500 kN, so W/L = 20.83 kN/m and (W/L) a = 166.7 kN must lie on the left of C at the critical position.
  2. Test the second wheel at C: on the left, 100 kN without it and 200 kN with it; 166.7 lies between, so this position passes.
  3. Ordinates (peak 8 × 16/24 = 5.333 m): wheels at 6, 8, 10 and 12 m have ordinates 4.0, 5.333, 4.667 and 4.0 m.
  4. M_C = 100 × 4.0 + 100 × 5.333 + 150 × 4.667 + 150 × 4.0 = 2 233 kN m.
  5. Other positions (first or third wheel at C) give smaller values; a full scan confirms 2 233 kN m for this order. If the train runs the other way (150 kN wheels leading on the left), a 150 kN wheel at C gives 2 267 kN m, so both directions must be checked.

Answer. Greatest M_C = 2 233 kN m (2 267 kN m if the train is reversed)

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Draw the influence line of the quantity at the section.
  2. Single load: put it at the peak. Long uniform load: cover the region with the required sign. Short uniform load: make the end ordinates equal.
  3. Wheel train: list candidate positions with a wheel at the section that pass the average-load test, in both directions of travel.
  4. Evaluate Σ P y for each candidate and keep the largest; check that no wheel has entered or left the span unnoticed.
  5. For the absolute maximum, place the span centre midway between the critical wheel and the resultant, repeat for the next heaviest wheels, and keep the largest.

Site notes

  • Bridge girders, crane runway beams and gantry girders carry moving wheels; the governing case is found by these steps or by software that steps the vehicle across the span in small increments.
  • For crane runway beams the two crane wheels on one side are a two-load train, and the absolute maximum moment formula with s, the wheel spacing, gives a quick hand check.
  • Abnormal loads such as transformer trailers crossing an existing bridge are checked by moving the actual axle train across the influence lines of the critical girders.
  • Maximum moment and shear envelopes decide where flange plates, prestressing tendons or bars may be stopped along a girder.
Common mistakes
  • Placing the heaviest wheel at midspan and calling it the absolute maximum without placing the resultant correctly.
  • Checking only one direction of travel for an unsymmetrical train.
  • Using the average-load test and not evaluating the moment for every candidate that passes it.
  • Forgetting that a wheel may have left the span, which changes the resultant.
  • Centring a short uniform load on the section instead of making its end ordinates equal.
Quick check

For a single moving load the absolute maximum moment is PL/4 at midspan, and for two equal loads P at spacing s it is P(L − s/2)²/(2L); with s = 0 this returns 2P × L/4.

Summary

  • Single load at the peak; long uniform load over the region of the required sign.
  • Short uniform load: the section divides the load in the same ratio as the span.
  • Wheel train: a wheel at the section, average load left equal to average load on the span, then evaluate candidates.
  • Absolute maximum: midspan midway between the critical wheel and the resultant.
  • Envelopes of maximum moment and shear guide curtailment along the girder.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A single 150 kN load crosses a simply supported girder of 12 m span. Find the absolute maximum bending moment.

PL/4 = 150 × 12/4 = 450 kN m, at midspan.

2A uniform load of 20 kN/m, longer than the span, crosses a 16 m simply supported span. Find the greatest moment at the quarter point.

w × ½ × L × ab/L = w a b/2 = 20 × 4 × 12/2 = 480 kN m.

3Two equal wheels of 100 kN at 4 m spacing cross a 20 m span. Find the absolute maximum moment and compare it with the two wheels placed symmetrically about midspan.

P(L − s/2)²/(2L) = 100 × 18²/40 = 810 kN m; symmetric about midspan (8 m and 12 m) gives 100 × 8 = 800 kN m.

4For Example 3, reverse the train so the 150 kN wheels lead from the left. Which wheel goes to the section, and what is the greatest moment at C?

A 150 kN wheel (the second one, at 8 m, with wheels at 6, 10 and 12 m); M_C = 150 × 4.0 + 150 × 5.333 + 100 × 4.667 + 100 × 4.0 = 2 267 kN m.

5For the train of Example 3 in its original order, find the greatest positive shear at C.

Leading 100 kN wheel just right of C, wheels at 8, 10, 12 and 14 m with ordinates 0.667, 0.583, 0.5 and 0.417: V = 66.7 + 58.3 + 75 + 62.5 = 262.5 kN (the next trial gives 204.2 kN).

6A uniform load of 40 kN/m, 6 m long, crosses an 18 m span. Find the greatest moment at midspan.

Load centred (6 m to 12 m), end ordinates 3.0 m, peak 4.5 m: area = 2 × (3.0 + 4.5)/2 × 3 = 22.5 m²; M = 40 × 22.5 = 900 kN m.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • R. C. Hibbeler, Structural Analysis, Pearson, 10th edition, 2018.
  • C. S. Reddy, Basic Structural Analysis, Tata McGraw Hill (now McGraw Hill Education (India)), 3rd edition, 2011.
  • D. Menon, Structural Analysis, Narosa Publishing House, 2nd edition.
  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.