Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Strength of Materials › Chapter 5 › Lesson 5.5

5.5 Strain energy method for deflection

Strength of Materials Chapter 5: Deflection of beams Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Write the strain energy stored in a member by axial force and by bending, and explain why it equals the work done by slowly applied loads.
  • Find deflections by equating external work to strain energy, by Castigliano's second theorem and by the unit (dummy) load method.
  • Apply the energy method to beams and to bent frames such as sign posts and brackets, where the other methods of this chapter become awkward.

Theory

When a load is applied slowly to an elastic member, it does work as the member deforms, and that work is stored in the member as strain energy. If the load rises from zero to P while its point of application moves through δ, and the response is linear, the work done is the area of the triangle under the load-deflection line, ½ P δ. Removing the load returns the energy, which is why an elastic structure springs back. This energy balance, external work equals internal strain energy, gives a third route to deflections alongside integration (lessons 5.1 and 5.2) and the area methods (lessons 5.3 and 5.4).

Inside the member the energy is stored element by element. A short length dx of a bar carrying an axial force N stretches by N dx/(E A), so it stores N² dx/(2 E A). A short length of a beam carrying a bending moment M rotates through dθ = M dx/(E I), so it stores M² dx/(2 E I). Summing over the length gives U = ∫ N²/(2 E A) dx for axial members and U = ∫ M²/(2 E I) dx for beams. In ordinary beams the bending term is far larger than the shear term, so shear energy is neglected here, as it was in lesson 5.1.

P (real)Real load: moment MU = ∫ M²/(2 E I) dx1 (unit)Unit load: moment mδ = ∫ M m/(E I) dxdeflected shapeδ under P: ½ P δ = UCastigliano: δ = ∂U/∂PIndiacon original
Figure 5.5: Strain energy method: the real load stores U = ∫ M²/(2 E I) dx, and a unit load at the point wanted gives the deflection as ∫ M m/(E I) dx. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Equating ½ P δ to U only works when a single load acts and the deflection wanted is under that load and along its line. Castigliano's second theorem removes that limit: for a linear elastic structure, the deflection of any load point along the line of that load is the partial derivative of the total strain energy with respect to that load, δᵢ = ∂U/∂Pᵢ. If no load acts where the deflection is wanted, a fictitious load Q is added there, the derivative is taken, and Q is then set to zero. The same rule with a couple gives a rotation, θ = ∂U/∂C.

Carrying out Castigliano's theorem with a fictitious load always produces the same integral, δ = ∫ M m/(E I) dx, where M is the bending moment from the real loads and m is the bending moment from a unit load applied at the point and in the direction of the deflection wanted. This is the unit load or dummy load method, also obtained from the principle of virtual work met in engineering mechanics. It handles frames with several members, members of varying E I and horizontal as well as vertical movements, and it is the basis of the energy methods of structural analysis.

Derivation

  1. Sign convention for moments as in lesson 5.1: sagging positive. Energy contains M², so the sign of M does not affect U, but M and m must use the same convention in the unit load integral.
  2. Axial member: an element dx stretches by N dx/(E A). The force rises from 0 to N, so the work stored is ½ N (N dx/(E A)) = N² dx/(2 E A); for constant N, U = N² L/(2 E A).
  3. Beam element: dθ = M dx/(E I) (lesson 5.1). The moment rises from 0 to M, so the energy stored is ½ M dθ = M² dx/(2 E I); U = ∫ M²/(2 E I) dx.
  4. Simply supported beam, central load P: M = P x/2 on each half, so U = 2 ∫₀^(L/2) (P x/2)²/(2 E I) dx = P² L³/(96 E I). Setting ½ P δ = U gives δ = P L³/(48 E I), the result of lesson 5.1.
  5. Cantilever, tip load P, x measured from the free end: M = −P x, U = ∫₀^L P² x²/(2 E I) dx = P² L³/(6 E I), and Castigliano gives δ = ∂U/∂P = P L³/(3 E I).
  6. Castigliano's second theorem: for a linear structure U is a quadratic function of the loads, U = ½ Σ Pᵢ δᵢ. Increasing one load Pᵢ by dPᵢ adds work δᵢ dPᵢ to first order, so ∂U/∂Pᵢ = δᵢ.
  7. Unit load form: with a fictitious load Q at the point wanted, the total moment is M + Q m, so ∂U/∂Q at Q = 0 equals ∫ (M + Q m) m/(E I) dx at Q = 0, which is ∫ M m/(E I) dx.
  8. Check, simply supported beam with uniform load w and a unit load at midspan: M = w x(L − x)/2 and m = x/2 for x ≤ L/2, so δ = 2 ∫₀^(L/2) (w x (L − x)/2)(x/2)/(E I) dx = 5 w L⁴/(384 E I).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Axial: U = N² L/(2 E A) (N·mm or J, with N in N, L in mm, E in N/mm², A in mm²)
  • Bending: U = ∫ M²/(2 E I) dx (kN·m = kJ when M is in kN·m, E I in kN·m², x in m)
  • Single load: ½ P δ = U
  • Castigliano's second theorem: δᵢ = ∂U/∂Pᵢ, θᵢ = ∂U/∂Cᵢ
  • Unit load method: δ = ∫ M m/(E I) dx (+ Σ N n L/(E A) for axial members)
  • Results: cantilever tip load U = P² L³/(6 E I); simply supported central load U = P² L³/(96 E I)
  • Bent frame, post height h and arm a, tip load P: δ_vertical = P(a³/3 + a² h)/(E I), δ_horizontal = P a h²/(2 E I)
Assumptions and limits
  • Linear elastic material and small deflections, so the load-deflection line is straight and the work of a slowly applied load is ½ P δ; Castigliano's second theorem needs this linearity.
  • Loads are applied gradually; a suddenly applied or falling load does more work (lesson 1.6) and is not covered by ½ P δ.
  • Shear and axial energy in beams and frames are neglected compared with bending energy unless members are short and deep or mainly axial; trusses use axial energy only.
  • Strain energy is not additive load by load: U for two loads acting together is not the sum of the separate energies, because U is quadratic in the loads. Deflections from the unit load integral may be superposed; energies may not.
  • Limits: the method gives the deflection at chosen points, not the whole elastic curve; for the full curve use integration or Macaulay's method.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • The strain energy method is mechanics, and no design code governs it; codes accept elastic deflections found by any consistent method.
  • The deflection limits explained in lesson 5.1 apply to the results: IS 456:2000 cl. 23.2 for reinforced concrete members (span/250 overall, span/350 or 20 mm after partitions and finishes) and IS 800:2007 Table 6 for steel members (span/300 or span/360 for the simply supported floor beam case used in this chapter).
  • Side by side, not ranked: EN 1990 with EN 1992-1-1 and EN 1993-1-1, ACI 318 and AISC 360 practice likewise leave the method of computing elastic deflection to the engineer and compare the result with the limits of their own code family.

Worked examples

Example 1 (site style: steel cantilever bracket by energy)

Problem. The steel bracket of lesson 5.1, Example 2: a cantilever 1.5 m long with a 10 kN load at the tip, E I = 4.0 × 10¹² N·mm² (4000 kN·m²). Find the strain energy stored and the tip deflection by equating work and energy.

  1. With x from the tip, M = −10 x kN·m.
  2. U = ∫₀^1.5 (10 x)²/(2 × 4000) dx = 100 × 1.5³/(6 × 4000) = 0.01406 kN·m = 14.06 J.
  3. External work of the slowly applied load = ½ P δ, so δ = 2 U/P = 2 × 0.01406/10 = 2.81 × 10⁻³ m.
  4. δ = 2.81 mm, the same as P L³/(3 E I) in lesson 5.1.

Answer. U = 14.06 J; δ_tip = 2.81 mm

Example 2 (exam style: Castigliano with a fictitious load)

Problem. An office floor beam spans 6 m simply supported with a uniform load of 12 kN/m and E I = 1.6 × 10¹³ N·mm² (16 000 kN·m²), as in lesson 5.1, Example 1. Find the midspan deflection with a fictitious load Q at midspan, and the end slope with a fictitious couple C at A.

  1. With Q at midspan, for 0 ≤ x ≤ 3 m: M = 36 x − 6 x² + Q x/2, so ∂M/∂Q = x/2.
  2. δ = ∂U/∂Q at Q = 0 = 2 ∫₀³ (36 x − 6 x²)(x/2)/E I dx = 2 × (162 − 60.75)/16 000 = 202.5/16 000 = 0.01266 m.
  3. Midspan deflection = 12.66 mm, equal to 5 w L⁴/(384 E I).
  4. With a couple C at A, M = 36 x − 6 x² + C(1 − x/6) over the whole span, so ∂M/∂C = 1 − x/6.
  5. θ_A = ∫₀⁶ (36 x − 6 x²)(1 − x/6)/E I dx = 108/16 000 = 6.75 × 10⁻³ rad, equal to w L³/(24 E I).

Answer. δ_mid = 12.66 mm; θ_A = 6.75 × 10⁻³ rad

Example 3 (civil frame: road sign post with an overhanging arm)

Problem. A road sign hangs from the end of a horizontal arm 2 m long fixed rigidly to the top of a vertical post 3 m high, which is fixed at its base. The sign weighs 5 kN. Both members have E I = 2.0 × 10¹² N·mm² (2000 kN·m²). Find the vertical and horizontal movement of the arm tip, neglecting axial and shear deformation.

  1. Arm, x from the tip: M = 5 x; unit vertical load at the tip: m = x. Post: M = 5 × 2 = 10 kN·m constant; m = 2.
  2. δ_v = [∫₀² 5 x² dx + ∫₀³ 10 × 2 dy]/E I = (13.33 + 60)/2000 = 0.03667 m = 36.7 mm.
  3. For the horizontal movement put a unit horizontal load at the tip: m = 0 in the arm and m = y in the post, with y measured down from the top.
  4. δ_h = ∫₀³ 10 y dy/E I = 45/2000 = 0.0225 m = 22.5 mm.
  5. The post contributes most of the vertical movement (60 of 73.3), so stiffening the post is the most effective fix if the sign sags or sways too much.

Answer. δ_vertical = 36.7 mm; δ_horizontal = 22.5 mm

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Decide which deflection or rotation is wanted, and where.
  2. Write the bending moment M from the real loads in each member, with x measured from a convenient end in each segment.
  3. If a real load acts at that point and along that direction, use δ = ∂U/∂P; otherwise apply a unit load (or unit couple for a rotation) there and write its moment m in each segment, using the same sign convention.
  4. Evaluate δ = Σ ∫ M m/(E I) dx member by member, adding Σ N n L/(E A) for axial members if they matter.
  5. A positive result means the movement is in the direction of the unit load; a negative result means the opposite direction.
  6. Check one result against a standard formula or another method.

Site notes

  • Sign gantries, cantilever lighting poles and canopy brackets are bent frames; the unit load method gives their tip movement directly, including the large share that comes from the post bending.
  • For trusses such as roof trusses and temporary falsework, the same method with axial terms, δ = Σ N n L/(E A), gives joint deflections and camber, which is taken up in structural analysis.
  • Energy ideas explain why a suddenly applied or dropped load is dangerous: the member must absorb more energy than under a slowly applied load, so stresses and deflections are larger (lesson 1.6).
  • When a deflection check fails, the M m/(E I) integrand shows which member or segment contributes most, which tells the engineer where added stiffness pays off.
Common mistakes
  • Using ½ P δ = U when more than one load acts or when the deflection is wanted away from the load.
  • Adding the strain energies of separate load cases; energy is quadratic in load, so only deflections superpose.
  • Using different sign conventions or different origins for M and m in the same segment.
  • Forgetting a member of a frame, typically the post, in the unit load sum.
  • Leaving the fictitious load Q in the answer instead of setting it to zero after differentiating.
Quick check

Deflection at a point = ∫ M m/(E I) dx, with m the moment from a unit load at that point in the wanted direction. For a cantilever with tip load check U = P² L³/(6 E I) and δ = 2U/P = P L³/(3 E I). If doubling the load does not quadruple your strain energy, the expression for U is wrong.

Summary

  • Strain energy is the work stored in an elastic member by slowly applied loads: N² L/(2 E A) for axial force and ∫ M²/(2 E I) dx for bending.
  • For a single load, ½ P δ = U gives the deflection under the load.
  • Castigliano's second theorem, δ = ∂U/∂P, gives the deflection of any load point; a fictitious load or couple gives deflections and slopes anywhere.
  • The unit load method, δ = ∫ M m/(E I) dx, is the practical form and handles frames and varying E I.
  • Energy is not additive between load cases, but deflections found this way are.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1Why is the work done by a gradually applied load ½ P δ and not P δ?

The load grows from zero to P while the deflection grows from zero to δ along a straight line, so the work is the triangular area under the load-deflection line, ½ P δ. P δ would apply only if the full load acted throughout the movement.

2A cantilever 2 m long carries 6 kN at its tip; E I = 5000 kN·m². Find the strain energy and the tip deflection.

U = P² L³/(6 E I) = 36 × 8/30 000 = 9.6 × 10⁻³ kN·m = 9.6 J. δ = 2U/P = 3.2 × 10⁻³ m = 3.2 mm, which equals P L³/(3 E I).

3A steel tie 3 m long, area 500 mm², E = 200 000 N/mm², carries 50 kN. Find the strain energy and the extension.

U = N² L/(2 E A) = (50 000)² × 3000/(2 × 200 000 × 500) = 37 500 N·mm = 37.5 J. Extension = N L/(E A) = 1.5 mm, and ½ N δ = ½ × 50 000 × 1.5 = 37 500 N·mm, which checks.

4A simply supported beam of span 4 m carries 30 kN at midspan; E I = 1.0 × 10¹³ N·mm². Find the deflection under the load by energy and the energy stored.

δ = P L³/(48 E I) = 30 000 × 4000³/(48 × 10¹³) = 4.0 mm. U = ½ P δ = ½ × 30 000 × 4.0 = 60 000 N·mm = 60 J, the same as P² L³/(96 E I).

5Use the unit load method for the tip deflection of a cantilever 2 m long under 3 kN/m, E I = 4000 kN·m².

With x from the tip, M = −3 x²/2 and m = −x, so δ = ∫₀² (3 x³/2) dx/E I = w L⁴/(8 E I) = 3 × 16/32 000 = 1.5 × 10⁻³ m = 1.5 mm.

6Two loads act on a beam. Why can the strain energies of the two separate load cases not be added to get the total?

Strain energy is a quadratic function of the loads. With both loads acting, U contains a cross term from the work each load does through the deflection caused by the other. Doubling a single load gives four times the energy, not twice.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
  • E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.