5.3 Moment-area method
After this lesson you should be able to:
- State and prove the two moment-area theorems relating the M/(E I) diagram to changes of slope and to tangential deviations of the elastic curve.
- Use the theorems with a reference tangent (at a fixed end or at a point of symmetry) to find slopes and deflections of cantilevers and simply supported beams.
- Handle beams whose E I varies along the length, such as stepped or strengthened sections, where the moment-area method is easier than integration.
Theory
Integrating E I y″ = M gives the whole elastic curve, but very often only the deflection at one point is wanted, such as the tip of a cantilever or the middle of a span. The moment-area method, developed in the nineteenth century by C. E. Greene and O. Mohr, goes straight to such values by working with areas and centroids of the bending moment diagram. Each value of M is divided by the E I at that section to give the M/(E I) diagram, which is simply the curvature diagram of the beam.
The first theorem follows directly from the curvature: the change in slope between two points A and B on the elastic curve equals the area of the M/(E I) diagram between them. A positive (sagging) area means the slope increases from A to B, turning anticlockwise.
The second theorem deals with distance. Draw the tangent to the elastic curve at A and extend it to the vertical through B. The vertical distance from that tangent to the curve at B is called the tangential deviation of B from the tangent at A, t_B/A. It equals the first moment of the M/(E I) area between A and B, taken about B. The order matters: t_B/A uses moments about B, and t_A/B, the deviation of A from the tangent at B, uses moments about A; the two are generally different.
The method works best when a tangent of known direction is available. At a fixed end the tangent is horizontal, so for a cantilever the tip deflection is just t_tip/fixed end. In a symmetric simply supported beam the tangent at midspan is horizontal, so the midspan deflection equals t_support/midspan. In unsymmetric cases, the tangent at one support is used and the deflection is found from similar triangles. Because only areas and centroids of known shapes are needed, the method is fast for stepped beams, where E I changes along the length, and it is the basis of the conjugate beam method in lesson 5.4.
Derivation
- Use the convention of lesson 5.1: y upward, sagging M positive, slopes θ = dy/dx small.
- From E I y″ = M: dθ/dx = M/(E I), so dθ = (M/(E I)) dx.
- Integrate from A to B: θ_B − θ_A = ∫ from A to B of (M/(E I)) dx, which is the area of the M/(E I) diagram between A and B (theorem I).
- The tangents drawn at the two ends of an element dx cut off a length dt on the vertical through B, where dt = x̄ dθ and x̄ is the horizontal distance from the element to B (small angles).
- Summing: t_B/A = ∫ from A to B of x̄ (M/(E I)) dx, the first moment of the M/(E I) area between A and B about the vertical through B (theorem II).
- With sagging moments, t_B/A is positive when B lies above the tangent drawn at A.
- Check, cantilever of length L with tip load P, fixed at A: the M/(E I) diagram is a triangle of height P L/(E I) at A. Area = P L²/(2 E I), so θ_tip = P L²/(2 E I). Its centroid is 2L/3 from the tip, so δ = t_tip/A = (P L²/(2 E I)) × (2L/3) = P L³/(3 E I), as in lesson 5.1.
- Check, simply supported beam with uniform load w: the tangent at midspan C is horizontal. The M/(E I) area from A to C is a half parabola with area (2/3)(L/2)(w L²/(8 E I)) = w L³/(24 E I), giving the end slope, and its centroid is 5L/16 from A, so δ = t_A/C = (w L³/(24 E I)) × (5L/16) = 5 w L⁴/(384 E I).
Theorem I: θ_B − θ_A = area of the M/(E I) diagram between A and B (rad)Theorem II: t_B/A = (area of M/(E I) between A and B) × (distance of its centroid from B) (mm or m)Rectangle b × h: area b h, centroid b/2Triangle base b, height h: area b h/2, centroid b/3 from the tall side (2b/3 from the zero-height vertex)Parabolic spandrel (zero slope at vertex), base b, height h: area b h/3, centroid b/4 from the tall endHalf of a symmetric parabolic segment, base b, height h: area 2 b h/3, centroid 3b/8 from the peakCantilever, point load P at distance a from the fixed end: δ_tip = P a²(3L − a)/(6 E I)Units: M in kN·m, E I in kN·m², areas in rad, moments of areas in m
- The same assumptions as lesson 5.1: linear elastic material, small slopes and deflections, shear deformation neglected.
- E I may vary along the beam; the M/(E I) diagram simply takes the local value at each section.
- Tangential deviations are measured vertically, which is valid because slopes are small.
- The method gives deflections relative to a tangent; to obtain an absolute deflection, the reference tangent must have a known direction or be related to the supports by geometry.
- Limits: hinges inside a beam break the elastic curve's slope continuity, so theorem I cannot be applied across an internal hinge without allowing for the slope jump there.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- The moment-area theorems are mechanics, and no code prescribes them; they are one of several equivalent ways of computing the elastic deflections that codes then limit.
- The deflection limits explained in lesson 5.1 apply: IS 456:2000 cl. 23.2 for reinforced concrete members, where a stiffness allowing for cracking and long-term effects must be used, and IS 800:2007 Table 6 for steel members.
- Side by side, not ranked: EN 1992-1-1 and ACI 318 give methods for the effective stiffness of cracked concrete members that can be fed into an M/(E I) diagram, while EN 1993-1-1 and AISC 360 practice use the elastic E I of the steel section, in each case with the deflection limits of that code family.
Worked examples
Problem. A steel cantilever 2 m long carrying a sign exerts a 5 kN load at its tip. E I = 3.0 × 10¹² N·mm² (3000 kN·m²). Use the moment-area method to find the tip slope and deflection.
- The tangent at the fixed end A is horizontal, so θ_tip and δ_tip are measured from it.
- M/(E I) diagram: a triangle, zero at the tip and P L/(E I) = 5 × 2/3000 = 3.333 × 10⁻³ m⁻¹ at A.
- Theorem I: θ_tip = area = (1/2) × 2 × 3.333 × 10⁻³ = 3.33 × 10⁻³ rad.
- Theorem II: centroid of the triangle is 2L/3 = 1.333 m from the tip; δ = 3.333 × 10⁻³ × 1.333 = 4.44 × 10⁻³ m = 4.44 mm.
- Check with P L³/(3 E I) = 5 × 8/9000 = 4.44 mm.
Answer. θ_tip = 3.33 × 10⁻³ rad; δ_tip = 4.44 mm
Problem. A steel purlin spans 5 m between rafters and carries 4 kN/m. E I = 5.0 × 10¹² N·mm² (5000 kN·m²). Find the end slope and midspan deflection by the moment-area method.
- By symmetry, the tangent at midspan C is horizontal.
- Peak M = w L²/8 = 4 × 25/8 = 12.5 kN·m; peak M/(E I) = 2.5 × 10⁻³ m⁻¹.
- Area of the M/(E I) diagram from A to C (half of a parabolic segment): (2/3) × 2.5 × 2.5 × 10⁻³ = 4.167 × 10⁻³ rad. By theorem I this is the end slope θ_A.
- Its centroid is 3/8 × 2.5 = 0.9375 m from C, that is 1.5625 m (5L/16) from A.
- Theorem II: δ = t_A/C = 4.167 × 10⁻³ × 1.5625 = 6.51 × 10⁻³ m = 6.51 mm.
- Check: 5 w L⁴/(384 E I) = 5 × 4 × 625/(384 × 5000) = 6.51 mm.
Answer. θ_A = 4.17 × 10⁻³ rad; δ = 6.51 mm
Problem. A cantilever 3 m long carries 10 kN at its tip. The inner 1.5 m (near the fixed end) is strengthened with plates so that its E I is 2E I₀, while the outer 1.5 m has E I₀ = 8.0 × 10¹² N·mm² (8000 kN·m²). Find the tip deflection, and compare it with a cantilever of E I₀ throughout and one of 2E I₀ throughout.
- |M| = P x (hogging), with x measured from the tip; M/(E I) = P x/(E I₀) for 0 ≤ x ≤ 1.5 m and P x/(2E I₀) for 1.5 ≤ x ≤ 3 m.
- Theorem II about the tip: δ = ∫ x (M/(E I)) dx = (P/E I₀)[a³/3 + (L³ − a³)/6] with a = 1.5 m, L = 3 m.
- a³/3 = 1.125 m³ and (27 − 3.375)/6 = 3.9375 m³; total 5.0625 m³.
- δ = 10 × 5.0625/8000 = 6.33 × 10⁻³ m = 6.33 mm.
- E I₀ throughout: P L³/(3 E I₀) = 10 × 27/24 000 = 11.25 mm; 2E I₀ throughout: 5.63 mm.
- Plating only the inner half recovers most of the benefit, because the moment and the lever arm to the tip are both largest near the support.
Answer. δ_tip = 6.33 mm (11.25 mm unplated, 5.63 mm fully plated)
Step-by-step procedure
- Draw the bending moment diagram and divide each part by the local E I to get the M/(E I) diagram.
- Choose a reference tangent of known direction: a fixed end, or the midspan of a symmetric beam.
- Split the M/(E I) diagram into simple shapes (rectangles, triangles, parabolic spandrels) with known areas and centroids.
- Use theorem I for the change of slope between the reference point and the point wanted.
- Use theorem II, taking moments about the correct point, for the tangential deviation.
- Turn the deviation into a deflection, directly if the reference tangent is horizontal, or by similar triangles from the support tangent if it is not.
Site notes
- Strengthening a beam with plates or fibre wraps only over the high-moment zone is common in repair work; the moment-area method shows quickly how much stiffness this restores.
- Tapered or haunched beams, as in some portal frames and bridge girders, have E I that varies along the span; the M/(E I) diagram handles them directly.
- Cantilever balconies and canopies are sensitive to fixity at the support: a small rotation there adds a deflection equal to that rotation times the projection, on top of the bending deflection.
- Measured deflections on a load test can be compared with moment-area predictions to estimate the actual stiffness of an existing beam.
- Using the bending moment diagram instead of the M/(E I) diagram where E I varies.
- Taking the moment of area about the wrong point: t_B/A needs moments about B.
- Treating a tangential deviation as a deflection when the reference tangent is not horizontal.
- Using the centroid of a triangle or spandrel measured from the wrong end.
- Ignoring signs when the M/(E I) diagram has both sagging and hogging parts.
Change of slope between two points = area of the M/(E I) diagram between them. Deviation of B from the tangent at A = that area times the distance of its centroid from B. For a cantilever, the tip deflection is the moment of the whole M/(E I) diagram about the tip; for a symmetric simply supported beam, the midspan deflection is the moment of half the diagram about a support.
Summary
- The M/(E I) diagram is the curvature diagram of the beam.
- Theorem I: change of slope between A and B equals the M/(E I) area between them.
- Theorem II: the tangential deviation t_B/A equals the first moment of that area about B.
- A horizontal reference tangent, at a fixed end or a point of symmetry, turns deviations directly into deflections.
- The method is quick for single deflections and for beams with varying E I.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1State the first moment-area theorem.
The change in slope of the elastic curve between two points equals the area of the M/(E I) diagram between those points.
2Using the moment-area method, find the tip deflection of a 3 m cantilever under 2 kN/m. E I = 1.0 × 10¹³ N·mm² (10 000 kN·m²).
The M/(E I) diagram is a parabolic spandrel with area w L³/(6 E I) and centroid 3L/4 from the tip, so δ = w L⁴/(8 E I) = 2 × 81/80 000 = 2.03 × 10⁻³ m = 2.03 mm.
3A simply supported beam of span 6 m carries a central load of 48 kN; E I = 4.8 × 10¹³ N·mm² (48 000 kN·m²). Find the end slope and central deflection by moment-area.
Half M/(E I) diagram: triangle with height P L/(4 E I) and base L/2, area P L²/(16 E I) = 48 × 36/(16 × 48 000) = 2.25 × 10⁻³ rad (end slope). Centroid L/3 = 2 m from A, so δ = 2.25 × 10⁻³ × 2 = 4.5 mm.
4Why is the tangent at midspan used as the reference in a symmetrically loaded simply supported beam?
Because by symmetry the slope at midspan is zero, so that tangent is horizontal and the deviation of the support from it equals the midspan deflection.
5If the M/(E I) diagram between A and B is entirely sagging, is B above or below the tangent drawn at A?
Above: a positive moment of a sagging area means the curve bends upward away from the tangent, so t_B/A is positive and B lies above the tangent at A.
6A 2 m cantilever carries 10 kN at its mid-length (1 m from the fixed end). E I = 2.0 × 10¹² N·mm² (2000 kN·m²). Find the tip deflection.
The M/(E I) diagram is a triangle over the inner 1 m only, with height P a/(E I) = 10 × 1/2000 = 5 × 10⁻³ m⁻¹ at the fixed end: area = (1/2) × 1 × 5 × 10⁻³ = 2.5 × 10⁻³ rad. Its centroid is a/3 from the fixed end, so 2 − 0.333 = 1.667 m from the tip. δ = 2.5 × 10⁻³ × 1.667 = 4.17 × 10⁻³ m = 4.17 mm, the same as P a²(3L − a)/(6 E I) = 10 × 1 × 5/12 000.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- B. J. Goodno, J. M. Gere, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2018.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Mechanics of Materials, Pearson, 10th edition, 2016.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, D. F. Mazurek, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, 8th edition, 2020.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition, 1998.