4.4 Theorems of Pappus-Guldinus
After this lesson you should be able to:
- State and prove the two theorems of Pappus-Guldinus for surfaces and solids of revolution.
- Use them to find surface areas and volumes of rings, domes, cones and tanks from a centroid and a length or area.
- Recognise when the theorems do not apply.
Theory
Many civil engineering shapes are solids or surfaces of revolution: circular tanks and ring beams, domes, conical hoppers, pipe bends and silo bottoms. Their volume or surface area can be found by integration, but two theorems, first stated by Pappus of Alexandria and later restated by Paul Guldin, give the answer in one line once the centroid of the generating line or area is known.
The first theorem deals with surfaces. When a plane curve of length L is rotated about an axis in its plane that does not cross it, it sweeps a surface. The area of that surface equals the length L times the distance travelled by the centroid of the curve. For a full turn the centroid travels 2π ȳ, where ȳ is the distance of the centroid from the axis, so A = 2π ȳ L.
The second theorem deals with solids. When a plane area A is rotated about an axis in its plane that does not cross it, it sweeps a solid. The volume equals the area A times the distance travelled by its centroid: V = 2π ȳ A for a full turn. For a part turn of angle θ (radians), replace 2π by θ.
The theorems work in both directions. If the volume of a solid of revolution is known, the centroid of the generating area can be found from it. Using the known volume of a sphere, for example, gives the semicircle centroid 4r/(3π) without any integration.
Derivation
- Surface theorem: take a short element dL of the generating curve at distance y from the axis. In one full turn it sweeps a thin band of area dA = 2π y dL.
- Integrate along the curve: A = 2π ∫ y dL. By the definition of the line centroid, ∫ y dL = ȳ L, so A = 2π ȳ L.
- Volume theorem: take a small element dA of the generating area at distance y from the axis. In one full turn it sweeps a thin ring of volume dV = 2π y dA.
- Integrate over the area: V = 2π ∫ y dA = 2π ȳ A, using ∫ y dA = ȳ A.
- For rotation through an angle θ instead of 2π, each element sweeps θ y dL or θ y dA, so A = θ ȳ L and V = θ ȳ A.
- Check with a cone of base radius r and height h, generated by a right triangle with legs r and h rotated about the leg h: the triangle area is r h/2 and its centroid is r/3 from the axis, so V = 2π (r/3)(r h/2) = π r² h / 3, the known result.
Surface of revolution: A = 2π ȳ L (m², with L in m)Solid of revolution: V = 2π ȳ A (m³, with A in m²)Part revolution through θ rad: A = θ ȳ L, V = θ ȳ ATorus with tube radius a and centre radius R: V = 2π² R a², surface = 4π² R a
- The axis lies in the plane of the generating curve or area and does not cut through it (it may touch the boundary).
- ȳ is the perpendicular distance of the centroid from the axis of rotation.
- For a part revolution, the angle is in radians.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- No design code governs this lesson; it is geometry. Volumes found here are converted to self-weight with the unit weights discussed in lesson 4.5.
Worked examples
Problem. A circular area of radius 50 mm is rotated about an axis in its plane 200 mm from its centre, forming a torus (ring). Find the volume and surface area of the ring. Also show that the theorems give the volume and surface area of a sphere of radius r.
- Volume: A = π × 50² = 7 854 mm², ȳ = 200 mm. V = 2π × 200 × 7 854 = 9.870 × 10⁶ mm³.
- Surface: L = 2π × 50 = 314.16 mm, ȳ = 200 mm. Area = 2π × 200 × 314.16 = 3.948 × 10⁵ mm².
- Sphere volume: a semicircular area πr²/2 with centroid 4r/(3π) from the diameter gives V = 2π × 4r/(3π) × πr²/2 = (4/3) π r³.
- Sphere surface: a semicircular arc πr with centroid 2r/π gives A = 2π × 2r/π × πr = 4πr².
Answer. V = 9.870 × 10⁶ mm³; surface = 3.948 × 10⁵ mm²
Problem. A circular water tank has a ring beam of rectangular section, 300 mm wide and 450 mm deep, whose inner face is on a radius of 5.0 m. Find the volume of concrete in the ring beam and its self-weight, taking 25 kN/m³ for reinforced concrete.
- Section area A = 0.300 × 0.450 = 0.135 m².
- The section centroid is at mid-width, so ȳ = 5.0 + 0.15 = 5.15 m from the tank axis.
- V = 2π × 5.15 × 0.135 = 4.368 m³.
- Self-weight = 4.368 × 25 = 109.2 kN. Using the inner radius instead of the centroid radius would give 4.241 m³, about 3 per cent low.
Answer. 4.368 m³ of concrete; 109.2 kN
Step-by-step procedure
- Identify the generating curve (for a surface) or area (for a solid) and the axis of rotation.
- Find the length L or area A of the generator.
- Find the perpendicular distance ȳ of its centroid from the axis (composite method if needed).
- Multiply: A = 2π ȳ L or V = 2π ȳ A (θ instead of 2π for a part turn).
- Check with a simple known shape or a rough bounding estimate.
Site notes
- Concrete quantities for circular tank walls, ring beams, domes and manhole rings are found quickly with Pappus; use the centroid radius of the section, not the inner or outer radius.
- Paint and waterproofing areas of domes and cylindrical shells follow from the surface theorem; for a dome, the generating curve is the arc of the meridian.
- For pipe bends and curved drains, a part revolution through the bend angle gives the volume of concrete surround.
- Using the distance of the centroid from the wrong axis.
- Using the area centroid when the surface theorem needs the line centroid, or the other way round.
- Applying the theorems when the axis cuts through the generating area.
- Using degrees for a part revolution.
- Using the inner radius of a ring instead of the centroid radius.
For a thin ring, V ≈ mean circumference × section area; if your Pappus result differs from this by more than a few per cent for a thin ring, check ȳ.
Summary
- Surface of revolution: A = 2π ȳ L.
- Solid of revolution: V = 2π ȳ A.
- Part turn: replace 2π by θ in radians.
- The axis must not cross the generator; ȳ is measured from the axis of rotation.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1Use Pappus to find the volume of a cone of base radius 1.5 m and height 3 m.
Triangle area 2.25 m², centroid 0.5 m from the axis: V = 2π × 0.5 × 2.25 = 7.069 m³ (= π r² h/3).
2Find the curved surface area of a cone of base radius 1.5 m and height 2 m.
Slant length L = 2.5 m with centroid at r/2 = 0.75 m: A = 2π × 0.75 × 2.5 = 11.78 m².
3A ring beam of section 250 mm wide × 400 mm deep has its inner face at 4.0 m radius. Find its volume.
ȳ = 4.125 m, A = 0.1 m²: V = 2π × 4.125 × 0.1 = 2.592 m³.
4Find the curved surface area of a hemispherical dome of radius 6 m.
Quarter-circle arc L = π × 6 / 2 with centroid 2r/π from the axis: A = 2π × (12/π) × 3π = 2π r² = 226.2 m².
5Can the volume theorem be used for an area that straddles the axis of rotation? Why?
No. Elements on the two sides would sweep overlapping volumes, and the signed first moment would cancel; the theorem needs the axis not to cut the area.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, D. F. Mazurek, P. J. Cornwell, B. P. Self, Vector Mechanics for Engineers: Statics and Dynamics, McGraw Hill, 12th edition, 2019.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Pearson, 15th edition, 2022 (published 2021).
- J. L. Meriam, L. G. Kraige, J. N. Bolton, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Wiley, 9th edition, 2018.
- S. Timoshenko, D. H. Young, J. V. Rao, S. Pati, Engineering Mechanics (in SI units), McGraw Hill Education (India), 5th edition, 2013.