Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Engineering Mechanics › Chapter 6 › Lesson 6.4

6.4 Potential energy and stability of equilibrium

Engineering Mechanics Chapter 6: Virtual work and stability Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Define potential energy for gravity and linear springs and write the total potential energy of a one-degree-of-freedom system.
  • Show that equilibrium positions are where dV/dq = 0 and classify them as stable, unstable or neutral from the second derivative.
  • Find the critical load of a spring-restrained rigid column and the tipping angle of a block, and relate them to buckling and overturning.

Theory

For forces that come from gravity and elastic springs, the work done depends only on the start and end positions, not on the path. Such forces are called conservative, and their work can be written as the decrease of a potential energy V: U = −ΔV. Gravity gives V_g = W y, where y is the height of the centre of gravity, and a linear spring gives V_e = ½ k x², where x is its extension or compression.

If all the forces doing work on a system are conservative, the virtual work is δU = −δV = −(dV/dq) δq for a system with one coordinate q. The principle of virtual work then says that the system is in equilibrium where dV/dq = 0: equilibrium positions are the stationary points of the total potential energy.

stableV″ > 0unstableV″ < 0neutralV″ = 0Equilibrium: dV/dq = 0Indiacon original, not to scale
Figure 6.4: The shape of the potential-energy curve decides stability: a minimum is stable, a maximum is unstable and a flat curve is neutral. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Equilibrium is not enough for safety; it must also be stable. If the system is pushed slightly away and V rises, the forces push it back, like a ball in a bowl: d²V/dq² > 0, stable. If V falls, the system runs away, like a ball balanced on a dome: d²V/dq² < 0, unstable. If V stays the same, the equilibrium is neutral, like a ball on a flat floor; when d²V/dq² = 0, higher derivatives decide.

This energy test is the simplest model of buckling. A rigid post held upright by a spring at its top, carrying a vertical load P, is stable for small P because the spring energy outweighs the loss of gravity energy; above a critical load P_cr the upright position becomes unstable. Real columns behave in the same way with bending stiffness in place of the spring, which leads to Euler's buckling load in strength of materials. The same energy idea explains why a tall, narrow block tips over once it is tilted past a definite angle.

Derivation

  1. Rigid post of length L hinged at its base, with a vertical load P at the top and a horizontal spring of stiffness k at the top that stays horizontal. For a tilt θ, the spring stretches L sin θ and the load drops from L to L cos θ.
  2. V(θ) = ½ k L² sin² θ + P L cos θ.
  3. dV/dθ = k L² sin θ cos θ − P L sin θ = L sin θ (k L cos θ − P). Equilibrium at θ = 0, and also at cos θ = P/(k L) when P < k L.
  4. d²V/dθ² = k L² cos 2θ − P L cos θ. At θ = 0 this is k L² − P L, positive (stable) when P < k L and negative (unstable) when P > k L. Critical load P_cr = k L.
  5. At the tilted equilibrium cos θ = c = P/(k L): d²V/dθ² = k L² (2c² − 1) − k L² c² = k L² (c² − 1) < 0, so the tilted positions are unstable.
  6. With a rotational spring k_θ at the base instead, V = ½ k_θ θ² + P L cos θ and the same steps give P_cr = k_θ / L.
  7. Rigid block of width b and height h tilted by θ about one bottom corner: the centre of gravity is at height y_G = (h/2) cos θ + (b/2) sin θ. dV/dθ = W (−(h/2) sin θ + (b/2) cos θ) = 0 at tan θ = b/h, and d²V/dθ² = −W y_G < 0 there: that position is unstable, and beyond it the block tips over.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Gravity: V_g = W y (J); spring: V_e = ½ k x²
  • Equilibrium: dV/dq = 0
  • Stable: d²V/dq² > 0; unstable: d²V/dq² < 0; neutral: = 0 (check higher derivatives)
  • Post with translational spring at the top: P_cr = k L
  • Post with rotational spring at the base: P_cr = k_θ / L
  • Block about a corner: tipping angle θ = arctan(b/h); energy barrier ΔV = W [½ √(b² + h²) − h/2]
Assumptions and limits
  • Only conservative forces (gravity and linear elastic springs) do work; friction and damping are ignored.
  • The bodies are rigid; deformable columns need bending energy and lead to Euler buckling.
  • The spring in the post model stays horizontal; for small angles this matches most textbook idealisations.
  • The block rocks about a fixed corner without sliding.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • No design code governs this energy method itself. The design of steel compression members against buckling is covered by IS 800:2007 Section 7; this lesson gives only the underlying stability idea.
  • Unit weight of plain concrete in Example 2 is 24 kN/m³, as permitted by IS 456:2000 clause 19.2.1 (see lesson 4.5).

Worked examples

Example 1 (exam style)

Problem. A rigid post 3 m long is hinged at its base and held at the top by a horizontal spring of stiffness 50 kN/m. A vertical load P acts at the top. Find the critical load. For P = 120 kN, check the stability of the upright position and find any other equilibrium position.

  1. V = ½ k L² sin² θ + P L cos θ.
  2. P_cr = k L = 50 × 3 = 150 kN.
  3. For P = 120 kN at θ = 0: d²V/dθ² = k L² − P L = 450 − 360 = 90 kN·m > 0, so the upright position is stable.
  4. Other equilibrium: cos θ = P/(k L) = 120/150 = 0.8, θ = 36.87°. There d²V/dθ² = k L² (c² − 1) = 450 × (0.64 − 1) = −162 kN·m < 0, so it is unstable: if the post is pushed beyond about 37°, it falls.

Answer. P_cr = 150 kN; at 120 kN upright is stable (V″ = 90 kN·m); tilted equilibrium at 36.87° is unstable (V″ = −162 kN·m)

Example 2 (site style)

Problem. A plain concrete block 0.6 m wide, 1.8 m tall and 1.0 m long stands on its narrow end on a level slab. Taking 24 kN/m³, find its weight, the tilt angle at which it will tip over about a bottom edge, and the work needed to tilt it to that point.

  1. W = 0.6 × 1.8 × 1.0 × 24 = 25.92 kN.
  2. Tipping angle: tan θ = b/h = 0.6/1.8, so θ = 18.43°.
  3. Height of the centre of gravity: upright h/2 = 0.900 m; at tipping ½ √(0.6² + 1.8²) = 0.9487 m.
  4. Energy barrier ΔV = 25.92 × (0.9487 − 0.900) = 1.262 kN·m = 1.262 kJ. Only a small push is needed once it starts tilting, so tall blocks must be stacked low or propped.

Answer. W = 25.92 kN; tips at 18.43°; ΔV = 1.262 kJ

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Choose one coordinate q that describes the system.
  2. Write V(q) as the sum of W y for each weight and ½ k x² for each spring, all in terms of q.
  3. Differentiate: solve dV/dq = 0 for the equilibrium positions.
  4. Find d²V/dq² at each one: positive stable, negative unstable, zero check higher derivatives.
  5. For a load parameter P, find the value at which d²V/dq² at the working position becomes zero; that is the critical load.

Site notes

  • Tall precast panels, stacked blocks and formwork must be propped or braced because their tipping angle is small and the energy needed to topple them is low.
  • Temporary props and shores fail suddenly by losing stability, not by crushing; their bracing acts like the spring in Example 1 and must be stiff enough to keep the working load well below the critical load.
  • A wide, low stack has a large tipping angle and a high energy barrier; on site, store units flat or on their widest face whenever possible.
Common mistakes
  • Leaving out the sign of the gravity term: a load that moves down lowers V.
  • Stopping at dV/dq = 0 and calling every equilibrium safe without checking d²V/dq².
  • Using large-angle geometry wrongly, for example taking the spring stretch as L θ for large θ instead of L sin θ.
  • Confusing the critical load of an ideal rigid model with the design load of a real member, which also needs strength and imperfection checks.
  • Treating a block on a corner as stable after it passes the angle where its centre of gravity is over the corner.
Quick check

An equilibrium position is safe only if the total potential energy is a minimum there; for a spring-restrained post that means P < k L, and the margin P_cr / P should be well above one.

Summary

  • V = W y + ½ k x²; U = −ΔV for conservative forces.
  • Equilibrium where dV/dq = 0.
  • Stable if d²V/dq² > 0, unstable if < 0, neutral if = 0.
  • Spring-restrained post: P_cr = k L (or k_θ / L); block tips at arctan(b/h).

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A rigid post 4 m long has a rotational spring of 600 kN·m/rad at its base. Find the critical load.

P_cr = k_θ / L = 600/4 = 150 kN.

2A system has V(x) = 2x³ − 3x² (kJ, x in m). Find and classify the equilibrium positions.

V′ = 6x² − 6x = 0 at x = 0 and x = 1. V″ = 12x − 6: −6 at x = 0 (unstable), +6 at x = 1 (stable).

3A block 0.5 m wide and 2 m tall stands on end. At what tilt does it tip?

θ = arctan(0.5/2) = 14.04°.

4In Example 1, is the upright position stable for P = 180 kN?

V″ = 450 − 180 × 3 = −90 kN·m < 0, so it is unstable (P > P_cr = 150 kN).

5Give an example of neutral equilibrium.

A cylinder lying on a level floor: rolling it does not change the height of its centre, so V is constant.

6A 2 m post with a top spring carries 40 kN. What spring stiffness gives a margin of 2 against the critical load?

Need k L ≥ 2 × 40 = 80 kN, so k ≥ 40 kN/m.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, D. F. Mazurek, P. J. Cornwell, B. P. Self, Vector Mechanics for Engineers: Statics and Dynamics, McGraw Hill, 12th edition, 2019.
  • R. C. Hibbeler, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Pearson, 15th edition, 2022 (published 2021).
  • J. L. Meriam, L. G. Kraige, J. N. Bolton, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Wiley, 9th edition, 2018.
  • S. Timoshenko, D. H. Young, J. V. Rao, S. Pati, Engineering Mechanics (in SI units), McGraw Hill Education (India), 5th edition, 2013.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.