6.3 Virtual work for connected systems
After this lesson you should be able to:
- Define the degrees of freedom of a connected system and choose generalised coordinates to describe it.
- Express the positions of load points in terms of a coordinate and differentiate them to get virtual displacements.
- Solve linkages, toggles, scissor lifts and compound beams with internal hinges by one virtual-work equation per degree of freedom.
Theory
Many systems are made of several rigid bodies joined by pins, sliders and rollers: toggle clamps, scissor lifts, folding gates, and beams joined by internal hinges. Solving them by equilibrium means drawing a free-body diagram of each member and eliminating the forces at every connection. Virtual work avoids this, because the forces at frictionless connections do equal and opposite virtual work on the two bodies they join and cancel out.
The number of independent coordinates needed to fix the position of a system is its number of degrees of freedom. A toggle or a single scissor stage has one degree of freedom: one angle θ fixes every point. Such a system needs only one equation, δU = 0, to relate the applied forces. A system with n degrees of freedom gives n independent equations, one for each independent virtual displacement.
The key step is geometry. Write the coordinate of each point where a force acts, measured from a fixed origin along the line of the force, as a function of the generalised coordinate, for example y_B = L sin θ. Differentiate to get the virtual displacement, δy_B = L cos θ δθ. Each force then contributes its component times the virtual change of its coordinate, with the sign set by whether the coordinate is measured in the direction of the force.
For compound beams with internal hinges (Gerber beams), releasing a support turns part of the beam into a chain of rigid segments that rotate about their remaining supports and hinges. The displaced shape is a set of straight lines, and similar triangles give the movement of each load. This is the same construction used for influence lines of determinate structures.
Derivation
- Toggle: links AB and BC, each of length L, are pinned at fixed A and at a slider C on the line AC. With θ the angle of the links to AC, y_B = L sin θ and x_C = 2 L cos θ.
- Virtual displacements: δy_B = L cos θ δθ and δx_C = −2 L sin θ δθ.
- Loads: P acts downward at B (opposite to +y), and Q acts at C towards A (opposite to +x). δU = −P δy_B − Q δx_C = −P L cos θ δθ + 2 Q L sin θ δθ.
- δU = 0 for any δθ gives Q = P / (2 tan θ) = (P/2) cot θ.
- Scissor lift with n stages: platform height h = n L sin θ and the sliding foot at x = L cos θ, where L is the full length of each link. With load W on the platform and actuator force F pushing the slider inward, −W n L cos θ δθ + F L sin θ δθ = 0, so F = n W cot θ.
Virtual displacement from geometry: δy = (dy/dθ) δθδU = Σ F · δr = 0 for each independent δθToggle: Q = (P/2) cot θScissor lift with n stages: F = n W cot θ (actuator horizontal at the sliding foot)Bar leaning at θ to the vertical, weight W, held by horizontal force P at the top: P = (W/2) tan θ
- Connections are frictionless pins, rollers and sliders, so their internal forces do no net work.
- Links are rigid and weightless unless their weight is included as an applied force.
- Virtual displacements are infinitesimal and consistent with all remaining constraints.
- The system has a known number of degrees of freedom; one generalised coordinate per degree of freedom is used.
Codes and standards
Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.
- No design code governs this lesson; it is mechanics of rigid linkages. Mobile elevating work platforms and lifting equipment are covered by their own equipment and safety standards, which are outside the scope of this lesson.
Worked examples
Problem. A toggle press has two links each 0.4 m long. A downward force of 10 kN acts at the central pin B, and the links make 30° with the line of the slider. Find the horizontal force Q on the slider needed for equilibrium. Repeat for 10°.
- Coordinates: y_B = L sin θ, x_C = 2 L cos θ.
- δU = −10 × L cos θ δθ + Q × 2 L sin θ δθ = 0, so Q = 10/(2 tan θ).
- At 30°: Q = 10/(2 × 0.5774) = 8.660 kN.
- At 10°: Q = 10/(2 × 0.1763) = 28.36 kN. As the links flatten, a small force at B produces a very large force at the slider; this is the toggle action used in clamps and stone crushers.
Answer. Q = 8.660 kN at 30°; 28.36 kN at 10°
Problem. A single-stage scissor lift has two crossed links each 2 m long, pinned at their mid-points. It carries a 6 kN platform load. The actuator acts horizontally at the sliding foot. Find the actuator force when the links are at 20° to the horizontal, and for a three-stage lift at the same angle. Ignore self-weight and friction.
- Single stage: h = L sin θ, x = L cos θ, so F = W cot θ.
- F = 6/tan 20° = 6/0.3640 = 16.48 kN.
- Three stages: h = 3 L sin θ, so F = 3 W cot θ = 49.46 kN.
- The force is largest when the lift is low (small θ); this is why the actuator size of a scissor lift is set by the first lift from the stowed position.
Answer. Single stage 16.48 kN; three stages 49.46 kN
Problem. A compound beam ABCD has a pin at A, a roller at B (6 m from A), an internal hinge at C (8 m from A) and a roller at D (12 m from A). A 20 kN load acts mid-way between C and D. Find the reaction at B by virtual work and check by statics.
- Release B and let it rise δ. Segment ABC rotates about A, so C rises (8/6) δ.
- Segment CD rotates about D; the load at mid-span of CD rises half of C's movement: (1/2)(8/6) δ = (2/3) δ.
- δU = R_B δ − 20 × (2/3) δ = 0, so R_B = 13.33 kN.
- Check: CD alone gives R_D = 10 kN and a 10 kN downward force at the hinge on ABC. Moments about A: R_B × 6 = 10 × 8, R_B = 13.33 kN; then R_A = 10 − 13.33 = −3.33 kN (3.33 kN downward).
Answer. R_B = 13.33 kN upward; R_A = 3.33 kN downward; R_D = 10 kN
Step-by-step procedure
- Count the degrees of freedom and choose one coordinate (usually an angle) for each.
- Fix an origin and write the coordinate of every load point along the load's line of action as a function of the chosen coordinate.
- Differentiate to get the virtual displacements.
- Write δU = Σ (force × virtual displacement, with sign) = 0.
- Solve, and check the limiting cases (θ → 0 or 90°) for physical sense.
Site notes
- Toggle clamps, formwork tie wedges and jaw crushers use the large force multiplication of nearly straight links; the same action can also overload a member if links are allowed to flatten by mistake.
- Scissor lifts need their largest actuator force at the lowest position, so a lift that cannot rise from fully lowered with a load may still hold it once raised.
- For compound beams on site, such as cantilever and suspended-span bridge decks, the internal hinge changes the load path; a load on the suspended span puts load on the anchor span's cantilever.
- Measuring a coordinate from a point that moves, instead of from a fixed origin.
- Taking the virtual displacement of the whole link instead of the point where the force acts.
- Sign errors: a force does positive work only when its point moves in the force's direction.
- Forgetting the weight of heavy links when it is not small compared with the loads.
- Using the scissor formula for one stage on a multi-stage lift (the force scales with the number of stages).
As a linkage approaches a straight (dead-centre) position, the ratio of output to input force grows without limit in the ideal model; a result that stays small near θ → 0 for a toggle signals a geometry error.
Summary
- Forces at frictionless connections cancel in virtual work.
- One degree of freedom gives one equation, δU = 0.
- Write positions as functions of θ, differentiate, multiply by forces, add.
- Toggle Q = (P/2) cot θ; scissor F = n W cot θ.
Practice questions
Tap a question to see the answer.
1A toggle has a 8 kN load at its central pin with links at 45° to the slider line. Find the slider force.
Q = 8/(2 × tan 45°) = 4 kN.
2A single-stage scissor lift carries 4 kN with links at 30°. Find the actuator force.
F = 4 cot 30° = 6.928 kN.
3A uniform bar of weight 500 N, hinged at its lower end, leans at 30° to the vertical and is held by a horizontal force P at its top. Find P.
x_B = L sin θ, y_G = (L/2) cos θ: −P L cos θ + (W L/2) sin θ = 0, so P = (W/2) tan θ = 250 × 0.5774 = 144.3 N.
4In Example 3, the 20 kN load is moved to the hinge C. Find R_B.
C rises (8/6) δ: R_B = 20 × 8/6 = 26.67 kN.
5How many degrees of freedom does a single-stage scissor lift have, and how many virtual-work equations are needed?
One degree of freedom (the angle θ), so one equation.
6Why do the pin forces inside a linkage not appear in the virtual-work equation?
At each frictionless pin the two connected members exert equal and opposite forces on the same moving point, so their virtual works cancel.
References
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, D. F. Mazurek, P. J. Cornwell, B. P. Self, Vector Mechanics for Engineers: Statics and Dynamics, McGraw Hill, 12th edition, 2019.
- R. C. Hibbeler, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Pearson, 15th edition, 2022 (published 2021).
- J. L. Meriam, L. G. Kraige, J. N. Bolton, Engineering Mechanics: Statics, Wiley, 9th edition, 2018.
- S. Timoshenko, D. H. Young, J. V. Rao, S. Pati, Engineering Mechanics (in SI units), McGraw Hill Education (India), 5th edition, 2013.