Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Concrete Technology › Chapter 1 › Lesson 1.3

1.3 Mixing water

Concrete Technology Chapter 1: Ingredients of concrete Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • State the IS 456:2000 cl. 5.4 requirement that mixing and curing water be clean and free from injurious amounts of named contaminants, and that potable water is generally considered satisfactory.
  • Recall the Table 1 (cl. 5.4) permissible limits for organic and inorganic solids, sulphates, chlorides and suspended matter, including the two chloride limits, and apply them to a laboratory report.
  • Apply the 28-day cube-strength and initial-setting-time comparisons with distilled water in cl. 5.4.1.2 and 5.4.1.3, and the pH rule in cl. 5.4.2.
  • State the cl. 5.4.3 position on sea water, and the cl. 5.4.4 rule that water satisfactory for mixing is also suitable for curing, with the staining caution.

Theory

The water in a concrete mix does two jobs: it reacts with the cement (Lesson 1.1) and it gives the fresh mixture its workability. Any dissolved or suspended material in that water can change the setting time, the strength, the risk of corrosion of embedded steel, or the appearance of the hardened surface. IS 456:2000 cl. 5.4 is the Indian Standard rule for mixing and curing water. This lesson is about that rule. Admixtures, which are also added in the water or with it, are Lesson 1.4.

Cl. 5.4 requires that water used for mixing and curing shall be clean and free from injurious amounts of oils, acids, alkalis, salts, sugar, organic materials or other substances that may be deleterious to concrete or steel. Potable water is generally considered satisfactory for mixing concrete. That is a starting point, not a claim that every drinking-water supply automatically meets every limit in the clause: a supply can be potable and still be worth checking if there is any doubt, and a non-potable supply can still be shown to be suitable by the tests in the clause.

Mixing-water checks (IS 456 cl. 5.4)Potable water: usually OKpH not less than 6Table 1 solids limits28-day cubes vs distilledSetting time vs distilledNo sea water with steelCubes: average ≥ 90 percent of distilled controlSet: ≥ 30 min, and within ± 30 min of controlIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 1.3: The principal IS 456 cl. 5.4 checks on mixing water, including the sea-water restriction where steel is embedded. Indiacon original, not to scale.

As a guide, cl. 5.4 gives three numerical checks. (a) To neutralize 100 ml of the sample, using phenolphthalein as indicator, should not require more than 5 ml of 0.02 normal NaOH; the test is that in cl. 8.1 of IS 3025 (Part 22). (b) To neutralize 100 ml of the sample, using mixed indicator, should not require more than 25 ml of 0.02 normal H2SO4; the test is that in cl. 8 of IS 3025 (Part 23). (c) The permissible limits for solids shall be as given in Table 1 of the code. Those Table 1 limits, in our own words, are: organic matter, 200 mg/l, tested as per IS 3025 (Part 18); inorganic matter, 3 000 mg/l, IS 3025 (Part 18); sulphates (as SO3), 400 mg/l, IS 3025 (Part 24); chlorides (as Cl), 2 000 mg/l for concrete not containing embedded steel and 500 mg/l for reinforced concrete work, IS 3025 (Part 32); and suspended matter, 2 000 mg/l, IS 3025 (Part 17). The chloride limit is the one that most often governs on a coastal or industrial site, and it is tighter once steel is embedded.

Cl. 5.4.2 states that the pH value of the water shall be not less than 6. A lower pH means an acidic water, which can attack the paste and the steel. There is no upper pH stated in this clause; highly alkaline waters are judged through the acidity/alkalinity titration and the solids limits, and through the strength and setting tests if there is doubt.

If there is doubt about the development of strength, cl. 5.4.1 requires the suitability of the water to be ascertained by the compressive-strength and initial-setting-time tests in cl. 5.4.1.2 and 5.4.1.3 (the sampling rules are in cl. 5.4.1.1: the sample shall represent the water proposed for concreting, including seasonal variation, and shall not be treated except as in the regular supply). Cl. 5.4.1.2: the average 28-day compressive strength of at least three 150 mm cubes prepared with the proposed water shall not be less than 90 percent of the average strength of three similar cubes prepared with distilled water. The cubes are prepared, cured and tested in accordance with IS 516. Cl. 5.4.1.3: the initial setting time of a test block made with the appropriate cement and the proposed water shall not be less than 30 minutes, and shall not differ by more than 30 minutes either way from the initial setting time of a control block made with the same cement and distilled water. The blocks are prepared and tested in accordance with IS 4031 (Part 5). Both tests have to be read together when strength is in doubt: a water that passes setting but fails the 90 percent strength rule is not shown to be suitable by cl. 5.4.1.

Sea water is treated separately. Cl. 5.4.3 states that mixing or curing of concrete with sea water is not recommended because of the presence of harmful salts. Under unavoidable circumstances sea water may be used for mixing or curing in plain concrete with no embedded steel, after due consideration of the disadvantages and of precautions, including the use of an appropriate cement system. It is not a permission to use sea water in reinforced or prestressed concrete. Chlorides in sea water are far above the 500 mg/l Table 1 limit for reinforced work, which is the same physical reason written in a different clause.

Cl. 5.4.4 states that water found satisfactory for mixing is also suitable for curing concrete. However, water used for curing should not produce any objectionable stain or unsightly deposit on the concrete surface. The presence of tannic acid or iron compounds is objectionable in that respect. A river or tank water that has passed the mixing-water tests can still stain a fair-faced wall if it is used for curing without that extra look at staining.

Derivation

  1. Write each solid concentration in mg/l and compare it with the Table 1 limit that applies to the member (plain or reinforced, for chlorides). A value above the applicable limit fails the Table 1 guide.
  2. For the alkalinity/acidity guide: compare the titre on 100 ml with 5 ml of 0.02 N NaOH (phenolphthalein) or 25 ml of 0.02 N H2SO4 (mixed indicator). A titre above the stated volume fails that guide.
  3. Compare the measured pH with 6. A pH less than 6 fails cl. 5.4.2.
  4. For the strength test, let f_w be the average 28-day strength of at least three 150 mm cubes made with the proposed water, and f_d the average of three similar cubes made with distilled water, both as in IS 516. The ratio is r = f_w / f_d. Suitability on this test requires r ≥ 0.90.
  5. For the setting-time test, let t_w be the initial setting time with the proposed water and t_d the initial setting time of the distilled-water control, both as in IS 4031 (Part 5). Suitability on this test requires t_w ≥ 30 min and |t_w − t_d| ≤ 30 min.
  6. Sea water is not recommended. It may be considered only for plain concrete with no embedded steel, under cl. 5.4.3, and only after the disadvantages and precautions have been considered. It is not used in this lesson as a mixing water for reinforced concrete.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Table 1 (IS 456:2000 cl. 5.4), solids, mg/l: organic 200; inorganic 3 000; sulphate as SO3 400; chloride as Cl 2 000 (no embedded steel) or 500 (reinforced concrete); suspended matter 2 000
  • Titre on 100 ml: ≤ 5 ml of 0.02 N NaOH (phenolphthalein); ≤ 25 ml of 0.02 N H2SO4 (mixed indicator)
  • pH ≥ 6 (cl. 5.4.2)
  • r = f_w / f_d ≥ 0.90 at 28 days, three 150 mm cubes each, IS 516 (cl. 5.4.1.2)
  • t_w ≥ 30 min and |t_w − t_d| ≤ 30 min (cl. 5.4.1.3, IS 4031 (Part 5))
  • Sea water: not recommended; only possibly for plain concrete with no embedded steel (cl. 5.4.3)
Assumptions and limits
  • The Table 1 and titration limits are the guide values in cl. 5.4. They are not a substitute for the strength and setting tests when there is doubt about strength (cl. 5.4.1).
  • The 90 percent strength rule compares averages of at least three 150 mm cubes at 28 days, made, cured and tested as in IS 516, with distilled water as the control. A single cube is not a test result under this clause.
  • The setting-time comparison uses the same cement in both blocks and the method of IS 4031 (Part 5). A change of cement brand resets the control.
  • The sample must represent the water that will actually be used, including seasonal variation, and must not be pre-treated except as in the regular supply (cl. 5.4.1.1).
  • “Potable” is a useful starting point (cl. 5.4). It is not, by itself, a laboratory certificate against Table 1.
  • Cl. 5.4.3 is not a design method for marine concrete with steel. Reinforced and prestressed members are not mixed with sea water in this lesson.
  • This lesson does not reproduce Table 1 as a figure, and it does not select a water source for a project.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 456:2000 cl. 5.4 — mixing and curing water to be clean and free from injurious amounts of oils, acids, alkalis, salts, sugar, organic materials or other substances deleterious to concrete or steel; potable water generally considered satisfactory; guide (a), (b) and Table 1.
  • IS 456:2000 Table 1 (cl. 5.4) — permissible limits for solids, with the IS 3025 parts named in the table, as listed in the formulas above.
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 5.4.1, 5.4.1.1–5.4.1.3 — sampling; 28-day cube comparison (90 percent, IS 516, 150 mm cubes); initial setting time (30 min and ± 30 min, IS 4031 (Part 5)).
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 5.4.2 — pH not less than 6. Cl. 5.4.3 — sea water. Cl. 5.4.4 — curing water, including the staining caution (tannic acid or iron compounds).
  • IS 3025 (Parts 17, 18, 22, 23, 24 and 32) — methods named in cl. 5.4 and Table 1. IS 516 — cube testing. IS 4031 (Part 5) — setting time.
  • EN 1008 (mixing water for concrete) and ASTM C1602 are named for comparison only, not ranked.

Worked examples

Example 1 (illustrative): Table 1 solids and pH for a reinforced member

Problem. A laboratory reports the following on a proposed mixing water, tested as in the IS 3025 parts named in IS 456:2000 Table 1: organic matter 80 mg/l; inorganic matter 1 200 mg/l; sulphate as SO3 180 mg/l; chloride as Cl 620 mg/l; suspended matter 150 mg/l; pH 6.8. The concrete is reinforced. Does the water pass the Table 1 limits and cl. 5.4.2? Which single result governs?

  1. Organic matter 80 mg/l is below 200 mg/l. Inorganic matter 1 200 mg/l is below 3 000 mg/l. Sulphate as SO3 180 mg/l is below 400 mg/l. Suspended matter 150 mg/l is below 2 000 mg/l. pH 6.8 is not less than 6, so cl. 5.4.2 is satisfied.
  2. The concrete is reinforced, so the chloride limit is 500 mg/l, not 2 000 mg/l. The reported chloride is 620 mg/l, which is above 500 mg/l.
  3. The water therefore fails the Table 1 chloride limit for reinforced concrete. The other solids and the pH would have been acceptable. The chloride result governs.
  4. The same water might be considered, on Table 1 alone, for plain concrete with no embedded steel, because 620 mg/l is below 2 000 mg/l. That is not a permission to use it in the reinforced member in this example.

Answer. No. The chloride content 620 mg/l exceeds the 500 mg/l Table 1 limit for reinforced concrete. That single result governs.

Example 2 (illustrative): strength and setting-time comparison with distilled water

Problem. There is doubt about a non-potable supply. Three 150 mm cubes made with the proposed water and tested at 28 days as in IS 516 give 28.5, 29.4 and 28.5 N/mm². Three similar cubes made with distilled water give 32.8, 33.4 and 32.8 N/mm². The initial setting time with the proposed water is 95 min; the distilled-water control, with the same cement, is 70 min, both as in IS 4031 (Part 5). Does the water meet cl. 5.4.1.2 and cl. 5.4.1.3?

  1. Average strength with the proposed water f_w = (28.5 + 29.4 + 28.5) / 3 = 86.4 / 3 = 28.80 N/mm².
  2. Average strength with distilled water f_d = (32.8 + 33.4 + 32.8) / 3 = 99.0 / 3 = 33.00 N/mm².
  3. Ratio r = 28.80 / 33.00 = 0.8727, or 87.3 percent, which is less than 90 percent. The water fails cl. 5.4.1.2.
  4. Initial setting time t_w = 95 min, which is not less than 30 min. The difference from the control is |95 − 70| = 25 min, which is not more than 30 min. The water would have met cl. 5.4.1.3.
  5. Because cl. 5.4.1 requires both tests when strength is in doubt, the failure of the 90 percent strength rule means the water has not been shown to be suitable, even though the setting-time test was passed.

Answer. No. The 28-day ratio is 87.3 percent, which is below the 90 percent of cl. 5.4.1.2. The setting-time test (95 min, 25 min from the control) would have passed cl. 5.4.1.3 on its own.

Step-by-step procedure

  1. State whether the concrete will contain embedded steel. That choice sets the Table 1 chloride limit (500 mg/l or 2 000 mg/l).
  2. If the water is potable and there is no particular cause for doubt, cl. 5.4 treats it as generally satisfactory. Still record the source.
  3. If the water is not potable, or there is any doubt, have it tested for pH, the two titration guides, and the Table 1 solids, using the IS 3025 parts named in the code.
  4. Compare each result with the matching limit. A single failed limit is enough to reject the water on the Table 1 or pH or titration guide.
  5. If doubt remains about strength, sample as in cl. 5.4.1.1 and run the 28-day cube comparison (cl. 5.4.1.2, IS 516) and the initial-setting-time comparison (cl. 5.4.1.3, IS 4031 (Part 5)). Both must be satisfied.
  6. Do not use sea water for mixing or curing reinforced or prestressed concrete. For plain concrete with no embedded steel, cl. 5.4.3 is a last resort, not a default, and only after the disadvantages and precautions have been considered.
  7. If the water is accepted for mixing, it may be used for curing (cl. 5.4.4), provided it will not stain the surface (watch for tannic acid and iron compounds).

Site notes

  • A borehole, tanker or irrigation canal is not “the same as potable water” until it has been tested. Seasonal change in a canal can move chlorides and silt; retest when the source changes.
  • The chloride limit of 500 mg/l is for reinforced concrete. Do not apply the 2 000 mg/l plain-concrete figure to a footing, slab or column that contains bars.
  • Sea water, beach sand already wetted by sea water, and unwashed marine aggregate are all chloride sources. Cl. 5.4.3 does not license any of them in reinforced work.
  • Curing water that rust-stains a fair-faced wall may still have been acceptable as mixing water. Use a non-staining supply for visible surfaces, as cl. 5.4.4 warns.
  • Keep a sample and the test report with the pour record when a non-potable source is used. The sample should represent the water actually batched.
  • Admixtures (Lesson 1.4) are not a method of “correcting” a water that has failed cl. 5.4.
Common mistakes
  • Using the 2 000 mg/l chloride limit on a reinforced member, or the 500 mg/l limit as if it applied to sulphate or to organic matter.
  • Treating a potable-water certificate as a Table 1 test report, or, the other way, rejecting a potable supply without a reason for doubt.
  • Comparing one cube, or a 7-day result, with the 90 percent rule, which is an average of at least three 150 mm cubes at 28 days.
  • Passing a water on setting time alone when the 28-day strength ratio is below 90 percent, or the reverse, when cl. 5.4.1 has been invoked.
  • Using sea water in a reinforced or prestressed member, or treating cl. 5.4.3 as an ordinary permission for plain concrete.
  • Using a curing water that stains the surface, against the caution in cl. 5.4.4, because it had already been accepted for mixing.
  • Ranking IS 456 against EN 1008 or ASTM C1602, or substituting an overseas mixing-water limit for Table 1.
Quick check

Potable water is generally satisfactory (IS 456 cl. 5.4). pH ≥ 6. Table 1: Cl⁻ 500 mg/l with embedded steel (2 000 mg/l without), SO3 400 mg/l, organics 200 mg/l, inorganics 3 000 mg/l, suspended 2 000 mg/l. If in doubt: f_w ≥ 0.90 f_d at 28 days, and setting time ≥ 30 min and within ± 30 min of the distilled control. No sea water where steel is embedded.

Summary

  • Mixing and curing water must be clean and free from injurious amounts of oils, acids, alkalis, salts, sugar and organic matter. Potable water is generally considered satisfactory.
  • IS 456:2000 Table 1 sets numerical limits on solids, including two chloride limits: 500 mg/l for reinforced concrete and 2 000 mg/l where no steel is embedded. The pH shall be not less than 6.
  • When strength is in doubt, the proposed water must give at least 90 percent of the 28-day strength of a distilled-water control, and an initial setting time of at least 30 min that is within 30 min of the control.
  • Sea water is not recommended, and may be considered only for plain concrete with no embedded steel, after the disadvantages and precautions have been considered.
  • Water that is satisfactory for mixing is satisfactory for curing, provided it does not stain the surface.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1What pH limit does IS 456:2000 cl. 5.4.2 set for mixing water?

The pH shall be not less than 6.

2A reinforced footing is to be cast. Which Table 1 chloride limit applies?

500 mg/l (concrete with embedded steel).

3A report gives sulphate as SO3 = 520 mg/l. Does that pass Table 1?

No. The limit is 400 mg/l.

4Cubes with proposed water average 27.0 N/mm²; distilled-water cubes average 30.0 N/mm². What is the ratio, and does it meet cl. 5.4.1.2?

r = 27.0/30.0 = 0.90, or 90 percent, which meets the “not less than 90 percent” rule.

5Initial set with proposed water is 50 min; the distilled control is 90 min. Does this meet cl. 5.4.1.3?

The 50 min is not less than 30 min, but |50 − 90| = 40 min, which is more than 30 min, so it fails the ± 30 min rule.

6May sea water be used to mix a reinforced grade beam, under IS 456 cl. 5.4.3?

No. Mixing or curing with sea water is not recommended, and the only unavoidable-circumstances provision in cl. 5.4.3 is for plain concrete with no embedded steel.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • A. M. Neville, Properties of Concrete, Pearson, 5th edition, 2011.
  • P. K. Mehta, P. J. M. Monteiro, Concrete: Microstructure, Properties, and Materials, McGraw Hill, 4th edition, 2014.
  • IS 456:2000 cl. 5.4–5.4.4 and Table 1, cited by number only. IS 3025 parts, IS 516 and IS 4031 (Part 5) named as the test methods in that clause.
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.