Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Geotechnical Engineering › Chapter 1 › Lesson 1.3

1.3 Phase relationships

Geotechnical Engineering Chapter 1: Soil formation and phase relations Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Derive the identity S e = w G from the three-phase diagram, and use it to find any one of e, w, S or G when the other three are known.
  • Derive the dry, bulk, saturated and buoyant unit weights in terms of G, e, w and γw, and convert between bulk and dry unit weight with γ = γd (1 + w).
  • Compute e, n, S, γd and γsat from typical laboratory data (G, w and a measured unit weight), with γw = 9.81 kN/m³.
  • State the assumptions in these identities and when a laboratory specific gravity, not an assumed G, should be used.

Theory

Lesson 1.2 defined the four ratios e, n, S and w from volumes and weights. This lesson links them through the specific gravity of the soil solids and the unit weight of water, and then writes the unit weights of the soil itself.

Specific gravity of the soil solids is G = (Ws / Vs) / γw, so the weight of solids in an element is Ws = G γw Vs. The unit weight of water is γw = Ww / Vw, so Ww = γw Vw. In this lesson every numerical example uses γw = 9.81 kN/m³, which is consistent with ρw = 1000 kg/m³ and g = 9.81 m/s². (The true density of water is slightly below 1 000 kg/m³ at ordinary temperatures; civil engineering calculations conventionally use 1 000 kg/m³ unless a precise water-property value is required.)

Unit volumes when Vs = 1voids esolids 1VvVsV=1+eSe = wGn = e / (1 + e)γd = G γw / (1 + e)γsat = (G + e) γw / (1 + e)γ = γd (1 + w)γw = 9.81 kN/m³ hereIndiacon original, not to scale
Figure 1.3: Unit-volume phase diagram (Vs = 1, Vv = e) and the principal unit-weight formulae. Indiacon original, not to scale.

Substitute the two weights into the definition of water content: w = Ww / Ws = (γw Vw) / (G γw Vs) = Vw / (G Vs). But Vw = S Vv and Vv = e Vs, so Vw = S e Vs. Therefore w = (S e Vs) / (G Vs) = S e / G, or S e = w G. This is the central identity of the three-phase model. It is not a material law; it follows from the definitions once G and γw are introduced. In a saturated soil S = 1 and e = w G. In a dry soil w = 0 and S = 0 (for any finite e).

Unit weights now follow by taking Vs = 1 (any convenient unit volume of solids). Then Vv = e, V = 1 + e, Ws = G γw, and, if the soil is saturated, Ww = e γw. The dry unit weight is the weight of solids over the total volume: γd = Ws / V = G γw / (1 + e). The saturated unit weight is (Ws + Ww) / V = (G + e) γw / (1 + e). The bulk unit weight of a partially saturated soil is γ = (Ws + Ww) / V = γd (1 + w), which holds whether or not the soil is saturated. The buoyant (submerged) unit weight of a saturated soil is γ′ = γsat − γw = (G − 1) γw / (1 + e).

A very useful rearrangement is e = G γw / γd − 1. Once a dry unit weight has been measured (or obtained from a bulk unit weight and a water content) and G is known, the void ratio is fixed, and S follows from S = w G / e. Porosity is still n = e / (1 + e).

G must come from a laboratory test on the actual solids (IS 2720 Part 3) when the result will be used in design, settlement or compaction control. Textbook examples often take G in a narrow band around 2.65 to 2.70 for many inorganic soils; that is a convenience for working a number, not a substitute for a test on the soil in hand. Organic soils and some mineral soils lie outside that band.

All of these formulae assume a constant γw and a single G for the solids. They do not by themselves describe how e changes under load (compression and consolidation) or how w changes as water flows; those are later chapters. They also do not replace a direct measurement of bulk density on site or in the mould.

Derivation

  1. From Lesson 1.2: e = Vv/Vs, S = Vw/Vv, w = Ww/Ws, Vv = e Vs and Vw = S Vv = S e Vs.
  2. Define G = (Ws/Vs)/γw, so Ws = G γw Vs, and γw = Ww/Vw, so Ww = γw Vw = γw S e Vs.
  3. Then w = Ww/Ws = (γw S e Vs)/(G γw Vs) = S e / G, hence S e = w G.
  4. Take Vs = 1. Then V = 1 + e, Ws = G γw, and the dry unit weight is γd = Ws/V = G γw/(1+e). Invert to obtain e = G γw/γd − 1.
  5. For a saturated soil, Va = 0, Ww = e γw, and γsat = (G γw + e γw)/(1+e) = (G+e) γw/(1+e). The buoyant unit weight is γ′ = γsat − γw = (G−1) γw/(1+e).
  6. For any degree of saturation, Ww = w Ws, so the bulk unit weight is γ = (Ws + w Ws)/V = γd (1 + w). Combined with S e = w G this also gives γ = (G + S e) γw / (1 + e).
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • S e = w G (all dimensionless, or S and w as consistent ratios)
  • n = e / (1 + e), e = n / (1 − n)
  • γd = G γw / (1 + e) = γ / (1 + w) (kN/m³)
  • γ = γd (1 + w) = (G + S e) γw / (1 + e) (kN/m³)
  • γsat = (G + e) γw / (1 + e) (kN/m³)
  • γ′ = γsat − γw = (G − 1) γw / (1 + e) (kN/m³)
  • e = G γw / γd − 1
  • γw = 9.81 kN/m³ in the worked examples (ρw = 1000 kg/m³, g = 9.81 m/s²)
Assumptions and limits
  • γw is taken as 9.81 kN/m³ unless a problem states another value. This uses the conventional 1000 kg/m³ for the density of water, not the slightly lower laboratory density at 20 °C.
  • G is the specific gravity of the soil solids, assumed uniform in the element. A measured G should be used for design; an assumed value is acceptable only in a clearly labelled illustrative example.
  • The identities assume the current volumes. They do not predict how e changes with stress or how w changes with seepage.
  • S = 1 means the voids are taken as full of water. Trapped air in a laboratory “saturated” specimen is a testing limit.
  • Weights and unit weights may be replaced by masses and densities (ρ = γ/g) without changing the ratios e, n, S, w or G.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 2720 (Part 2): determination of water content — cited by part number only; clause numbers omitted because the official text was not on the box at writing.
  • IS 2720 (Part 3): determination of specific gravity — cited by part number only, for the same reason.
  • The relations S e = w G and the unit-weight formulae are identities of the three-phase model in standard textbooks (Terzaghi, Peck and Mesri; Craig). They are not a table copied from an Indian Standard.
  • ASTM D2216 and ASTM D854, and ISO 17892 parts on water content and particle density, are named for comparison only, not ranked.

Worked examples

Example 1 (illustrative): saturated soil from G and w

Problem. A saturated soil has specific gravity of solids G = 2.67 and water content w = 18.0 %. Taking γw = 9.81 kN/m³, find the void ratio, the porosity, the dry unit weight and the saturated unit weight. Check γsat = γd (1 + w).

  1. Saturated, so S = 1. From S e = w G: e = w G = 0.180 × 2.67 = 0.4806.
  2. Porosity n = e / (1 + e) = 0.4806 / 1.4806 = 0.3246, or 32.46 %.
  3. Dry unit weight γd = G γw / (1 + e) = 2.67 × 9.81 / 1.4806 = 26.1927 / 1.4806 = 17.691 kN/m³.
  4. Saturated unit weight γsat = (G + e) γw / (1 + e) = (2.67 + 0.4806) × 9.81 / 1.4806 = 30.907386 / 1.4806 = 20.875 kN/m³.
  5. Check: γd (1 + w) = 17.691 × 1.18 = 20.875 kN/m³, which matches γsat.
  6. Buoyant unit weight, if needed, is γ′ = 20.875 − 9.81 = 11.065 kN/m³, or (G − 1) γw / (1 + e) = 1.67 × 9.81 / 1.4806 = 11.065 kN/m³.

Answer. e = 0.4806, n = 32.46 %, γd = 17.691 kN/m³, γsat = 20.875 kN/m³ (γ′ = 11.065 kN/m³).

Example 2 (illustrative): void ratio and saturation from a measured unit weight

Problem. A compacted soil has bulk unit weight γ = 19.20 kN/m³, water content w = 12.0 % and G = 2.68. Taking γw = 9.81 kN/m³, find the dry unit weight, the void ratio, the degree of saturation and the porosity.

  1. Dry unit weight γd = γ / (1 + w) = 19.20 / 1.12 = 17.143 kN/m³.
  2. Void ratio e = G γw / γd − 1 = (2.68 × 9.81) / 17.143 − 1. First, 2.68 × 9.81 = 26.2908, and 26.2908 / 17.143 = 1.5336, so e = 0.5336.
  3. Degree of saturation S = w G / e = (0.120 × 2.68) / 0.5336 = 0.3216 / 0.5336 = 0.6027, or 60.27 %.
  4. Porosity n = e / (1 + e) = 0.5336 / 1.5336 = 0.3480, or 34.80 %.
  5. The soil is partially saturated. A check on the bulk unit weight: γ = (G + S e) γw / (1 + e) = (2.68 + 0.6027 × 0.5336) × 9.81 / 1.5336 = (2.68 + 0.3216) × 9.81 / 1.5336 = 29.4457 / 1.5336 = 19.200 kN/m³.

Answer. γd = 17.143 kN/m³, e = 0.5336, S = 60.27 %, n = 34.80 %.

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Write down the known quantities and the value of γw (9.81 kN/m³ unless stated otherwise). Convert any percentages to ratios (18 % = 0.18).
  2. If the soil is stated to be saturated, set S = 1; if dry, set w = 0 and S = 0.
  3. Use S e = w G to find the missing one of e, w, S or G.
  4. If a bulk unit weight and a water content are given, compute γd = γ / (1 + w), then e = G γw / γd − 1, then S = w G / e.
  5. Compute n = e / (1 + e) and any required unit weight from γd = G γw / (1 + e), γsat = (G + e) γw / (1 + e), or γ = γd (1 + w).
  6. Check with a second identity (for example γsat = γd (1 + w) when S = 1, or a back-substitution for γ).
  7. Report unit weights in kN/m³ and ratios to a consistent number of figures. State that G was measured or assumed.

Site notes

  • Compaction control is built on these relations: a field bulk density and a water content give γd, which is then compared with a laboratory reference dry density. The comparison is only as good as the weights and the G used to interpret voids.
  • Do not take G = 2.65 for an earthwork record without a test, especially for residual soils, laterites or soils with organic matter.
  • A “saturated” fill below standing water can still contain trapped air, so a calculated S may come out slightly below 1. Report the calculated value; do not force it to 100 % without a reason.
  • Unit weights in kN/m³ are about 9.81 times the density in g/cm³ (1 g/cm³ corresponds to 9.81 kN/m³). Convert carefully; do not treat 1.80 g/cm³ as 1.80 kN/m³.
  • When a sample is trimmed or a cutter is used, the total volume V must be the volume of the soil, not the volume of a loose bag of crumbs.
Common mistakes
  • Using γw = 9.81 kN/m³ in one line and 10 kN/m³ in the next without saying so.
  • Leaving water content as 18 instead of 0.18 in S e = w G, which makes e one hundred times too large.
  • Computing e from G γw / γ − 1 using the bulk unit weight instead of the dry unit weight.
  • Writing γd = G γw / e instead of G γw / (1 + e).
  • Assuming S = 1 just because the soil was taken from below the water table, without calculating S.
  • Using an assumed G in a payment or design calculation when a laboratory value is required.
  • Forgetting that γ = γd (1 + w) is always true, while γsat = γd (1 + w) is true only when the soil is saturated.
Quick check

S e = w G. γd = G γw/(1+e) = γ/(1+w). γsat = (G+e)γw/(1+e). Use γw = 9.81 kN/m³ unless the problem states otherwise, and convert percentages to ratios before substituting.

Summary

  • The identity S e = w G links saturation, void ratio, water content and specific gravity. It follows from the definitions, not from a material test.
  • Dry unit weight γd = G γw/(1+e) = γ/(1+w). Saturated unit weight γsat = (G+e)γw/(1+e). Buoyant unit weight γ′ = γsat − γw.
  • Void ratio from a measured dry density: e = G γw/γd − 1. Then S = w G/e and n = e/(1+e).
  • Examples in this lesson use γw = 9.81 kN/m³. G should be measured (IS 2720 Part 3) when the result is used in design or control.
  • These identities describe the current state of an element. How e and w change under load or flow is treated in later chapters.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A saturated soil has w = 22.0 % and G = 2.70. What is e?

S = 1, so e = w G = 0.220 × 2.70 = 0.594.

2If e = 0.594 and G = 2.70, what is n?

n = 0.594/1.594 = 0.3726, or 37.26 %.

3For the soil of the first question, with γw = 9.81 kN/m³, what is γd?

γd = 2.70 × 9.81 / 1.594 = 26.487 / 1.594 = 16.617 kN/m³.

4A soil has γ = 18.50 kN/m³ and w = 10.0 %. What is γd?

γd = 18.50 / 1.10 = 16.818 kN/m³.

5A soil has e = 0.50, w = 12.0 % and G = 2.65. Is it saturated? What is S?

w G = 0.120 × 2.65 = 0.318; S = 0.318/0.50 = 0.636, or 63.6 %. Not saturated.

6Show that γ′ = (G − 1) γw / (1 + e).

γsat − γw = (G+e)γw/(1+e) − γw = [(G+e) − (1+e)] γw / (1+e) = (G−1) γw / (1+e).

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • K. Terzaghi, R. B. Peck, G. Mesri, Soil Mechanics in Engineering Practice, John Wiley and Sons, 3rd edition, 1996.
  • R. F. Craig, Craig's Soil Mechanics, Spon Press, 8th edition, 2012.
  • B. M. Das, Principles of Geotechnical Engineering, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2017.
  • IS 2720 (Part 2) and IS 2720 (Part 3), Methods of test for soils (cited by part number; official texts of these parts were not on the box at writing, so no clause numbers are used).
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.