Indiacon CivilSubscribe

Textbook › Geotechnical Engineering › Chapter 1 › Lesson 1.2

1.2 Three-phase system

Geotechnical Engineering Chapter 1: Soil formation and phase relations Under review — not yet three-checked Author: Indiacon

Learning objectives

After this lesson you should be able to:

  • Draw a three-phase diagram of soil and name the volumes of solids, water, air, voids and the total element, and the corresponding weights.
  • Define void ratio, porosity, degree of saturation and water content from that diagram, with SI units.
  • Distinguish dry, saturated and partially saturated states, and state what happens to the phases when a saturated sample is dried at constant total volume.
  • Use the volume identities V = Vs + Vv and Vv = Vw + Va to compute e, n and S from given phase volumes.

Theory

A soil element is a mixture of mineral (and sometimes organic) solids, water and air. The solids form a skeleton; the spaces between them are voids. The voids may be filled with water, with air, or with both. This is the three-phase system used throughout soil mechanics. Ice can appear as a fourth phase in frozen ground; that case is left to later, specialist study.

It is convenient to imagine the three phases separated, as in the figure: solids packed at the bottom, water next, and air at the top. The separated diagram has the same volumes and weights as the real mixture. It does not represent a real layering in the ground.

Three-phase diagram of soilAirWaterSolidsVaVwVsVvVWwWsWVa + Vw = VvVv + Vs = VWw + Ws = WAir has negligibleweight (Wa = 0)Indiacon original, not to scale
Figure 1.2: Three-phase diagram of a soil element, with volumes on the left and weights on the right. Indiacon original, not to scale.

The volume of solids is Vs. The volume of water is Vw and the volume of air is Va. The volume of voids is Vv = Vw + Va. The total volume of the element is V = Vs + Vv = Vs + Vw + Va. On the weight side, the weight of solids is Ws and the weight of water is Ww. The weight of air is taken as zero for ordinary geotechnical work, so the total weight is W = Ws + Ww.

Four definitions follow at once. Void ratio e is the volume of voids divided by the volume of solids: e = Vv / Vs. It is a ratio and has no unit. Porosity n is the volume of voids divided by the total volume: n = Vv / V. It is often written as a percentage. Degree of saturation S is the volume of water divided by the volume of voids: S = Vw / Vv. It runs from 0 in a dry soil to 1 (or 100 %) in a saturated soil, when Va = 0. Water content w (also called moisture content) is the weight of water divided by the weight of solids: w = Ww / Ws. It is often written as a percentage. Masses may be used in place of weights, because the same gravity acts on both.

The same soil can be dry (Vw = 0, S = 0), saturated (Va = 0, S = 1), or partially saturated (both Vw and Va present, 0 < S < 1). A saturated clay below the water table is close to S = 1. A recently compacted fill is usually partially saturated. In a dry sand the voids are almost all air. If a saturated sample is dried and the total volume is held constant, water leaves the voids and is replaced by air: e and n stay the same, while S falls towards 0. If the soil shrinks as it dries, V and Vv change as well; that shrinkage is a separate effect, treated later with consistency limits.

Unit weight (weight density) will be used in the next lesson: the bulk unit weight is γ = W / V, the dry unit weight is γd = Ws / V, and the unit weight of water is γw = Ww / Vw. Specific gravity of the soil solids, G, is the ratio of the unit weight of the solids to the unit weight of water, G = (Ws / Vs) / γw. Those relations, and the important identity S e = w G, are derived in Lesson 1.3. The present lesson stops at the phase diagram and the four definitions e, n, S and w.

Because e, n, S and w are ratios, they do not depend on the size of the element chosen. Any convenient total volume, for example 1 m³, may be used in a calculation. The laboratory measures water content on an oven-dried specimen (IS 2720 Part 2) and specific gravity of the solids (IS 2720 Part 3); volumes of voids are then inferred from the relations in Lesson 1.3 rather than measured directly on a three-phase drawing.

Derivation

  1. Start from a soil element and separate the phases in the mind only, without changing Vs, Vw or Va.
  2. Write the two volume identities: Vv = Vw + Va and V = Vs + Vv = Vs + Vw + Va.
  3. Define e = Vv / Vs. Then n = Vv / V = Vv / (Vs + Vv). Divide numerator and denominator by Vs to obtain n = e / (1 + e), and the inverse e = n / (1 − n).
  4. Define S = Vw / Vv. Then Vw = S Vv. In a saturated soil Va = 0, so Vv = Vw and S = 1. In a dry soil Vw = 0 and S = 0.
  5. Define w = Ww / Ws (or, with masses, w = Mw / Ms). This is independent of the volume definitions; it is linked to e and S once G and γw are introduced in Lesson 1.3.
Formulas, symbols and SI units
  • Vv = Vw + Va (m³)
  • V = Vs + Vv = Vs + Vw + Va (m³)
  • e = Vv / Vs (dimensionless)
  • n = Vv / V = e / (1 + e) (dimensionless; often as %)
  • S = Vw / Vv (dimensionless; 0 dry, 1 saturated)
  • w = Ww / Ws = Mw / Ms (dimensionless; often as %)
  • W = Ws + Ww (N or kN); weight of air taken as zero
Assumptions and limits
  • The soil is treated as a continuum made of solids, water and air only; organic matter is included with the solids unless a separate organic fraction is measured.
  • The weight of air is neglected.
  • The definitions use the current volumes of the element. If the element changes volume (shrinkage, swell, compression), e and n change and must be recomputed for the new volume.
  • S = 1 is an ideal saturated state. A small amount of trapped air can remain in a “saturated” laboratory specimen; that is a testing limit, not a change in the definition.
  • Water content uses the oven-dry mass of solids as the denominator, as in the standard laboratory method.

Codes and standards

Indian Standards are cited by number and clause only; no clause text, tables or figures are reproduced. Other standards are listed for comparison, not ranked.

  • IS 2720 (Part 2): methods of test for soils — determination of water content (part cited by number only; clause numbers omitted because the official text was not on the box at writing).
  • IS 2720 (Part 3): methods of test for soils — determination of specific gravity (part cited by number only; clause numbers omitted for the same reason).
  • The definitions of e, n, S and w are identities of the three-phase model used in standard textbooks (for example Terzaghi, Peck and Mesri; Craig). They are not a table in IS 1498:1970.
  • ASTM D2216 (water content) and ASTM D854 (specific gravity) are named for comparison only, not ranked.

Worked examples

Example 1 (illustrative): volumes to e, n and S

Problem. A soil element has volume of solids Vs = 0.40 m³, volume of water Vw = 0.25 m³ and volume of air Va = 0.15 m³. Find the total volume, the volume of voids, the void ratio, the porosity and the degree of saturation.

  1. Total volume V = Vs + Vw + Va = 0.40 + 0.25 + 0.15 = 0.80 m³.
  2. Volume of voids Vv = Vw + Va = 0.25 + 0.15 = 0.40 m³.
  3. Void ratio e = Vv / Vs = 0.40 / 0.40 = 1.00.
  4. Porosity n = Vv / V = 0.40 / 0.80 = 0.50, or 50.0 %.
  5. Check: n = e / (1 + e) = 1.00 / 2.00 = 0.50.
  6. Degree of saturation S = Vw / Vv = 0.25 / 0.40 = 0.625, or 62.5 %.
  7. The soil is partially saturated (both water and air in the voids).

Answer. V = 0.80 m³, Vv = 0.40 m³, e = 1.00, n = 50.0 %, S = 62.5 %; partially saturated.

Example 2 (illustrative): a saturated sample, then dried at constant volume

Problem. A saturated laboratory specimen has total volume V = 500 cm³ and volume of solids Vs = 280 cm³. (a) Find e, n and S. (b) The specimen is then dried until no water remains, and the total volume does not change. What are e, n and S after drying?

  1. Saturated means Va = 0, so Vv = Vw = V − Vs = 500 − 280 = 220 cm³.
  2. Void ratio e = Vv / Vs = 220 / 280 = 0.7857.
  3. Porosity n = Vv / V = 220 / 500 = 0.44, or 44.0 %.
  4. Degree of saturation S = Vw / Vv = 220 / 220 = 1, or 100 %.
  5. After drying at constant total volume, Vs, Vv and V are unchanged, so e is still 0.7857 and n is still 44.0 %.
  6. The 220 cm³ that was water is now air, so Vw = 0 and S = 0.

Answer. (a) e = 0.7857, n = 44.0 %, S = 100 %. (b) After drying at constant volume: e = 0.7857, n = 44.0 %, S = 0.

Step-by-step procedure

  1. Sketch the three-phase diagram and write the known volumes (or weights) on it.
  2. Compute any missing volume with Vv = Vw + Va and V = Vs + Vv.
  3. Compute e = Vv / Vs and n = Vv / V, and check n = e / (1 + e).
  4. Compute S = Vw / Vv. If the problem states that the soil is saturated, set Va = 0 and S = 1. If it is dry, set Vw = 0 and S = 0.
  5. Compute w only when weights or masses of water and solids are given (or after G and γw are introduced in Lesson 1.3).
  6. State the units (or that the quantity is dimensionless) and whether S and n are reported as ratios or as percentages.

Site notes

  • A borrow-pit or compacted-fill sample brought to the laboratory is a three-phase element: the measured water content is w, but e and S are not visible on site and must be calculated from density and specific gravity.
  • Do not assume a clay is saturated just because it looks wet. Degree of saturation is a calculated ratio, not a colour or feel.
  • When a sample is sealed badly, water is lost before weighing and the reported water content is too low. Keep samples in airtight containers.
  • A saturated clay that dries and cracks has not only lost water; it has also changed volume, so e and n have changed. The constant-volume drying of Example 2 is a teaching case, not a description of a shrinking clay.
  • Unit weights and water contents used for earthwork payment or compaction control come from the same phase definitions; the field tests themselves are in later chapters.
Common mistakes
  • Writing e = Vv / V (that is porosity, not void ratio).
  • Writing n = Vv / Vs (that is void ratio, not porosity).
  • Using S = Vw / V instead of S = Vw / Vv.
  • Using w = Ww / W (total weight) instead of w = Ww / Ws.
  • Forgetting that a saturated soil has Va = 0, so Vv = Vw.
  • Assuming e and n fall when a sample is dried, even when the total volume is stated to be constant.
  • Mixing cm³ and m³, or grams and kilograms, in the same ratio without converting.
Quick check

e = Vv/Vs, n = Vv/V = e/(1+e), S = Vw/Vv (0 dry, 1 saturated), w = Ww/Ws. Always sketch the three-phase diagram first.

Summary

  • Soil is modelled as solids plus voids; the voids hold water, air, or both.
  • V = Vs + Vw + Va and Vv = Vw + Va. Air weight is taken as zero, so W = Ws + Ww.
  • Void ratio e = Vv/Vs; porosity n = Vv/V = e/(1+e); degree of saturation S = Vw/Vv; water content w = Ww/Ws.
  • Dry: S = 0. Saturated: S = 1 and Va = 0. Partially saturated: 0 < S < 1.
  • Drying at constant total volume leaves e and n unchanged and sends S towards 0. Volume change on drying is a separate effect.
  • Water content and specific gravity are measured in the laboratory (IS 2720 Parts 2 and 3); Lesson 1.3 links them to e and S.

Practice questions

Tap a question to see the answer.

1A soil has Vs = 0.60 m³ and Vv = 0.40 m³. What are e and n?

e = 0.40/0.60 = 0.667; n = 0.40/1.00 = 0.40, or 40.0 %. Check: n = 0.667/1.667 = 0.400.

2If n = 0.375, what is e?

e = n/(1−n) = 0.375/0.625 = 0.600.

3A partially saturated soil has Vv = 0.30 m³ and Vw = 0.12 m³. What is S, and what is Va?

S = 0.12/0.30 = 0.40, or 40 %; Va = 0.30−0.12 = 0.18 m³.

4A sample has Mw = 48 g and Ms = 160 g. What is the water content?

w = 48/160 = 0.30, or 30.0 %.

5Why is the weight of air taken as zero in the three-phase diagram?

The mass of air in the voids is negligible next to the masses of solids and water for ordinary geotechnical calculations.

6A saturated soil is allowed to dry and shrinks. Do e and n stay the same?

No. Shrinkage reduces V and Vv, so e and n fall; above the shrinkage limit the soil stays close to saturated, and S falls only once drying continues below the shrinkage limit and air enters. Only constant-volume drying leaves e and n unchanged.

References

Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. Our explanations, examples and diagrams are original; nothing is copied from these books.

  • K. Terzaghi, R. B. Peck, G. Mesri, Soil Mechanics in Engineering Practice, John Wiley and Sons, 3rd edition, 1996.
  • R. F. Craig, Craig's Soil Mechanics, Spon Press, 8th edition, 2012.
  • B. M. Das, Principles of Geotechnical Engineering, Cengage Learning, 9th edition, 2017.
  • IS 2720 (Part 2) and IS 2720 (Part 3), Methods of test for soils (cited by part number; official texts of these parts were not on the box at writing, so no clause numbers are used).
Suggest a correction

If something on this page is wrong, tell the editor. Your message is sent privately and is not published.

Sent privately to the Indiacon editor; not published.