Time-cost trade-off
Most projects can be finished sooner by spending more: extra shifts, more crews or equipment, faster methods or premium materials. Crashing is the systematic way to decide which activities to speed up and by how much, to shorten the project at least extra cost. It is used when a client needs early completion, when delays must be recovered, or when bonuses or penalties change the economics.
Each activity has a normal duration and cost, and a crash duration and cost, the shortest possible time at a higher cost. The cost slope is the extra cost per day saved. Direct costs rise as the project is compressed, while indirect costs, such as site overheads, supervision and equipment hire, fall with shorter duration. The total cost curve, the sum of both, has a minimum at the optimum duration.
The procedure is iterative. Find the critical path. Crash the critical activity with the lowest cost slope by one day, or by the amount possible before another path becomes critical. Recompute. When there are multiple critical paths, each must be shortened together, so look for the cheapest combination, or a single activity common to all paths. Stop when the extra direct cost exceeds the saving in indirect cost, or when no further crashing is possible. Fast-tracking, overlapping activities planned in sequence, is the other compression tool; it costs less money but adds risk of rework.
Cost slope = (crash cost − normal cost) / (normal duration − crash duration)Total cost = direct + indirectCrash the cheapest critical activity firstStop when Δ direct cost > Δ indirect saving
Problem. A project takes 20 days at ₹40 lakh direct cost; indirect cost is ₹1.5 lakh per day. Critical activity P can be cut by 3 days at ₹0.8 lakh/day; Q by 2 days at ₹2.0 lakh/day. Which should be crashed?
- Crashing P saves ₹1.5 lakh per day in indirect cost for ₹0.8 lakh direct, a net saving of ₹0.7 lakh per day.
- Crash P by 3 days: duration 17 days, net saving ₹2.1 lakh (if P remains on the only critical path).
- Crashing Q costs ₹2.0 lakh against a ₹1.5 lakh saving: net loss, so do not crash Q unless time is valued more.
Answer. Crash P by 3 days to 17 days; do not crash Q
Quick quiz
1What is cost slope?
Extra direct cost per day saved by crashing an activity.
2Why do indirect costs fall with shorter duration?
Site overheads and hire charges are time-related.
3What is fast-tracking?
Overlapping activities that would normally be in sequence.
- IS 15883 (series) (India): Guidelines for construction project management, one part per knowledge area.
Clauses and documents to read
- IS 15883 (Part 2):2013 (time management)
- IS 15883 (Part 3):2015 (cost management)
Cited by number and clause only. We do not reproduce clause text, tables or figures (BIS Act 2016, s.10(5) and s.11). Check the current edition and amendments before use.
References and further reading
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. We do not copy text, figures, tables or solved problems from any book; our explanations and examples are original.
- B. C. Punmia, K. K. Khandelwal, Project Planning and Control with PERT and CPM, Laxmi Publications, latest edition.
- J. W. Hinze, Construction Planning and Scheduling, Pearson, latest edition.
Free and official sources
Found an error? Write to indiacongroupofengineers [at] gmail [dot] com. For corrections and feedback. We never ask for payment or personal details.